Putin's Hamas overture provokes storm of outrage from Israel

The Independent on Sunday, London


Putin's Hamas overture provokes storm of outrage from Israel
By Anne Penketh and Eric Silver in Jerusalem
Published: 11 February 2006

President Vladimir Putin's attempt to place Russia at the heart of
the Middle East peace process by inviting Hamas leaders to Moscow for
talks has provoked surprise in Europe and alarm in Israel.

Mr Putin broke ranks on Thursday with the other members of the
international quartet - the US, EU and UN - by announcing the
invitation to Hamas, officially designated as a terrorist
organisation by the Americans. Mr Putin said that Russia had never
considered Hamas to be terrorists. The Russian Defence Minister,
Sergei Ivanov, predicted that "sometime in the future, many leading
states will start maintaining some contacts with Hamas". Although
Russia is a member of the quartet, which, last week in London,
carefully co-ordinated its response to the shock Hamas victory in the
Palestinian elections, the Kremlin has been marginalised in the
Middle East peace process for more than a decade.

The quartet warned the suicide bombers of Hamas last week that all
members of a future Palestinian government must be committed to "non-
violence" and the recognition of Israel.

Diplomats said that the British Government had not been forewarned of
the Russian overture to Hamas, although they stressed that it was too
early to say whether the move marked a major shift in policy. France
did not object, so long as agreed "objectives and principles" were
observed.

But the reaction in Israel was sharp: "It's not just a slap in the
face to Israel. It's a slap in the face to Western countries," said
one Israeli official.

Tzipi Livni, the Foreign Minister, warned before flying home from a
visit to the US that granting Hamas legitimacy without insisting it
renounce terrorism and recognise Israel was a "slippery slope". It
would, she added, have a negative effect "not only for Israel, but
for the international community." But Gidi Grinstein, a former peace
negotiator who now heads Re'ut, a Tel-Aviv think-tank, said: "It may
be disappointing that Putin has broken ranks, but in the end he may
be putting Hamas on the spot. They will have to choose between their
loyalty to the Palestinian population, its well-being, prosperity and
security on the one hand and their ideology."

Mr Putin's move appears to be part of a more assertive stance on the
international stage before he hosts the G8 summit in St Petersburg
next July. At home, Mr Putin has cracked down on human rights,
opposition parties and press freedom.

The Republican senator John McCain, speaking at a security conference
on Sunday, called for a boycott of the summit: "Under Mr Putin,
Russia today is neither a democracy nor one of the world's leading
economies, and I seriously question whether the G8 leaders should
attend.''

But buoyed by strong oil prices, the Kremlin is safe in the knowledge
that the West needs Moscow to help mediate in the nuclear stand-off
with Iran.

© 2006 Independent News and Media Limited