Asia Times Online
Jun 7, 2005
Islamic push for Malaysian moderation
By Marwaan Macan-Markar
BANGKOK - Despite its location on the margins of the Islamic world, Malaysia is coming out well ahead of other Muslim countries on the pivotal question of how to redeem the battered image of Islam and its followers.
Such a rise in significance over other Islamic centers of gravity, such as Egypt, Saudi Arabia or Iran in the Middle East or Pakistan in South Asia, stems from moves underway by the Organization of the Islamic Conference (OIC) to give itself a face-lift.
The OIC's interest in Malaysia to help push through the sweeping reforms it has in mind was confirmed during a recently concluded meeting in Pakistan. During that gathering, from May 28-29, the moderate ideals of Islam Hadhari being advocated by Malaysian Prime
Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi were embraced as the way forward.
The OIC wants Islam Hadhari, or civilizational Islam, to be a central pillar in the new look it is seeking for itself, Malaysian Foreign Minister Syed Hamid Albar said recently.
Other changes in the cards, according to the minister, are a new name and charter for this premier Islamic body that reflects the views of the world's Muslims.
Calls for such reform originated during the last OIC summit hosted by Malaysia in October 2003. That was the first gathering of the 57-member body since September 11, 2001, which gave rise to a global image of Muslims as prone to violence and supporting terrorism.
The recommendations made by Islamic experts during the recent meeting in Pakistan are to be fine-tuned at a gathering of OIC foreign ministers in Yemen in July. They will then be tabled at a special summit of Muslim leaders to be held in Mecca toward the end of the year.
Malaysia's appeal for a beleaguered organization such as the OIC, often criticized as being long on talk but short on concrete action, also stems from other factors that make the nation stand out in the Islamic world. It is an economic success story where modernity and multiculturalism have been given room to flower rather than been crushed by religious extremists.
But a political minefield awaits the OIC in the journey ahead, given the ideas that make up the core of Islam Hadhari the Malaysian premier is advocating. They espouse an Islam that accepts differences, is comfortable with religious pluralism, and is open to democratic rights.
Among the 10 principles that frame this vision are those that stress a "free and independent people", a "just and trustworthy government" and "protection of the rights of minority groups and women", wrote Mohamed Sharif Bashir of the Islamic University of Malaysia on IslamOnline, an Internet magazine.
Such values, however, are woefully absent across much of the Muslim world. These countries, in fact, are notorious for their human-rights violations, and their leaders often dominate the rogues' gallery of dictators, autocrats and oppressive monarchies.
Uzbekistan President Islam Karimov is the latest among such strongmen to capture the headlines of the world's media. His brutal crackdown of protesters in May mirrored a pattern of suppression common in other Islamic countries where the victims were also Muslims. According to media reports, hundreds of people were killed in that Central Asian republic when government troops fired at the demonstrators.
Karimov's Uzbekistan has also been known for the widespread torture of Muslims arrested on charges of Islamic "extremism" and "fundamentalism", New York-based global rights body Human Rights Watch stated. The forms of torture have ranged from beatings, burnings and asphyxiation to a detainee being immersed in boiling water.
In late May, another human-rights champion, Amnesty International, lay bare the extremism and abuse that prevails in Muslim countries such as Egypt, Iran, Libya, Pakistan, the Maldives, Saudi Arabia, Sudan and Syria.
"Human-rights abuses flourish most brutally in the absence of democracy, and unfortunately, the record of Muslim countries in political freedom is pretty dismal," Irfan Husain wrote in a commentary that appeared last week in the Dubai-based Khaleej Times.
A United Nations report in April about the lack of political reform in the Arab world was as caustic, arguing that the region could be shattered by violence and social upheaval if democracy was further denied to the people.
"Throughout the [Arab] region, the concentration of power in the hands of the executive, be it a monarchy, military dictatorship or a civilian president elected without competition, has created a kind of political 'black hole' at the center of Arab political life," stated the UN report, "Arab Human Development Report 2004".
The OIC's quest to transform itself as an advocate of Islam Hadhari fits in with the UN report's call for change. More importantly, it reveals a belated commitment to give a due place to citizens in the Muslim world rather than maintain the habit of placating their governments.
Such a move would make this pan-Muslim body sound more credible when it articulates its mission to protect the interest of the ummah, or the people who make up the global Islamic community.
How far the OIC gets on this path will be seen later this year when it finally unveils its version of Islam Hadhari at the summit to be held in Islam's birthplace. A watered-down version to satisfy the despots and the autocrats in the Muslim world would relegate the OIC's reforms to mere cosmetic changes.
Were that to happen, the OIC will have a list of countries that help perpetuate the image of the Muslim world as prone to terrorism, religious extremism and tyranny. Malaysia, where 60% of the country's 25 million people are Muslim, will not be among them.
(Inter Press Service)
© Copyright 1999 - 2005 Asia Times Online Ltd.
Tuesday, June 07, 2005
Muslim Anguish, Western Condescension
Muslim anguish, Western condescension
By Spengler
Why do Muslims riot over alleged desecration of the Koran? For the same reason that Christians used to riot over alleged desecration of the Host, the wafer that when consecrated becomes the body of Jesus Christ, according to Catholic belief. For Muslims, the Koran is not a holy book, like the Christian Gospels or the Jewish Torah, but the
incarnate presence of Allah on Earth, dictated to the Prophet Mohammed word-for-word by the Archangel Gabriel. It is not prophecy, but the presence of divinity, as a number of commentators have observed, including this one (The crescent and the conclave, April
19, 2005).
Under the rubric Muslim anguish and Western hypocrisy (Nov 23, 2004), I observed that Christianity once killed apostates as a matter of routine, an action defended in retrospect by Catholic theologians such as Michael Novak as appropriate to the times. Western commentators condemn the guards of the US prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, for desecrating the Koran, while regarding Pakistani or Afghan Koran rioters as primitives. Condescending Westerners should look more closely at their own history. [1]
Host-desecration riots by Christians in 1298 led to an estimated 100,000 deaths in Germany and Austria, starting with the execution by fire of the entire Jewish community of Rottingen. Enraged Christians killed 3,000 Jews in Prague after a priest carrying a consecrated Host wafer was sprayed by sand. Other killings took place in Rome in 1021, Strasbourg in 1308, Posen in 1399, Silesia in 1451, and so forth. Medieval Jews, to be sure, were less likely to have tortured a consecrated Host than Marine guards were to have flushed a Koran down the toilet, and historians agree that the charge was a fabrication. [2] Christian sensitivities, nonetheless, were just as bloodthirsty as in today's Pakistan.
Worshipping divine incarnation in a book, to be sure, has quite different implications than worshipping the incarnate presence of God in bread and wine. Textual criticism becomes heresy as a matter of course. And without the sort of textual criticism that busied the Christian reformers at the turn of the 16th century, it is odd to speak of an Islamic reformation. A book in whose very words God reveals his presence must remain stuck in time like a fly in amber.
Muslim violence over desecration of the Koran is not uncommon, as a matter of fact. According to the Nigerian Christian journalist Rudolf Ogoo Okonkwo:
"In December of 1994, a Nigerian Christian trader, Gideon Akaluka, was accused of tearing pages out of the Koran in the northern city of Kano. Muslim youths launched an attack on him. He was rescued by the police and locked up in Bompai prison. On December 26, 1996, Muslim groups stormed the prison, pulled Akaluka out and beheaded him. They hoisted his head on a pike and paraded through the streets of Kano.
"On December 12, 2001, a Nigerian Christian truck driver, Saint Moritz, was reversing his truck near a fruit market in Kano. His truck accidentally ran into an area occupied by a Koranic study group. As students fled, one dropped his Koran. The truck trampled on a copy of the Koran. Muslim groups pursued the man. He ran to a police station. Mobs stormed the police station, overpowered the few cops on post and dragged the man to the street. They beat the man unconscious. He later died in a hospital."
No one, of course, is accused of desecrating a consecrated Host any longer, so Catholics have no one against whom to riot. Few Catholics, for that matter, still believe that the wafer really turns into the flesh of Jesus Christ (according to a 1992 Gallup Poll, only 30% of American Catholics polled clearly expressed this belief), and therefore are unlikely to riot even if someone really were to desecrate a Host. Unlike the skeptical Catholics, Muslims actually believe in the divine character of the Koran, and thus have something to riot about.
It now seems clear that some of the Guantanamo guards did abuse copies of the Koran, even if they did not, as Newsweek reported, flush one down a toilet. It would be surprising if US interrogators never resorted to Koran abuse as a technique for breaking down the will of prisoners. Like sensory deprivation, psychotropic drugs and physical stress, desecrating the Koran may be an effective interrogation technique. That does not make the practice any less deplorable, but the fact that it is likely to be quite effective in destroying the morale of Muslim prisoners increases the probability that it will be applied on occasion.
Two things explain the effectiveness of Koran desecration as a means of breaking Muslim morale. The first is that the Koran hosts Allah's incarnate presence, so to speak. The second is the peculiar importance of success to Islam. Unlike Christianity or Judaism,
worldly success is the ultimate testimony of Islam; the muezzin calls, "Come to prayer. Come to success!", and its emblem is the crescent, a symbol of secular growth, as opposed to the cross, a symbol of renunciation of worldly things. As I wrote in Horror and humiliation in Fallujah (April 27, 2004),
"The West cannot endure without faith that a loving Father dwells beyond the clouds that obscure His throne ... The Islamic world cannot endure without confidence in victory, that to "come to prayer" is the same thing as to "come to success". Humiliation - the perception that the ummah cannot reward those who submit to it - is beyond its capacity to endure."
Abusing the Koran is the equivalent of abusing Allah himself, and tells the Muslim prisoner that his god is powerless to avenge insults. Again, I do not condone such things, but merely observe that an effective weapon is more likely to be put to use. As I wrote in "Horror and humiliation in Fallujah:
"Radical Islam has risen against the West in response to its humiliation - intentional or not - at Western hands. The West can break the revolt by inflicting even worse humiliation upon the Islamists, poisoning the confidence of their supporters in the Muslim world."
The ultimate in American condescension is the "Muslim World Outreach" strategy exposed by US News and World Report on April 25. [3] As David E Kaplan reported:
"Although US officials say they are wary of being drawn into a theological battle, many have concluded that America can no longer sit on the sidelines as radicals and moderates fight over the future of a politicized religion with over a billion followers. The result has been an extraordinary - and growing - effort to influence what officials describe as an Islamic reformation.
"Attempting to engineer an Islamic reformation may be the silliest initiative in foreign policy in the history of the world. The theological department of the Central Intelligence Agency will not persuade Muslims to loosen their grasp on the living presence of Allah on this Earth. In its tragic encounter with Islam, the West cannot help but inflict humiliation."
The Koran desecration affair, with its parallels to medieval Christian violence, reinforces the conclusion I drew in my November 22 essay:
"Jews and Christians had centuries to accomplish the transition from public and political religion to private and communal religion, whereas circumstances press moderate Muslims to do this on the spot. The two older religions did so under duress, chaotically, and with limited success. Whether Islam can make such a transition at all remains doubtful."
Notes
[1] See for example Kenneth Woodward, "Newsweek and the Koran" in The Wall Street Journal, May 18, 2005, p A14.
[2] According to Wikipedia, "Host desecration is an anti-Semitic myth similar to the blood libel myth. It started in late 13th-century England and France (a century after Christians started making blood libel accusations against Jews), where it was claimed that Jews would steal consecrated Host wafers and torture them. According to the Roman Catholic dogma of transubstantiation, a consecrated Host wafer becomes the flesh of Jesus, so it was believed that Jews would steal and torture these wafers to reenact the crucifixion of Christ."
[3] "Hearts, Minds and Dollars" by David E Kaplan, US News and World Report, April 25, 2005.
(Copyright 2005 Asia Times Online Ltd. All rights reserved.)
By Spengler
Why do Muslims riot over alleged desecration of the Koran? For the same reason that Christians used to riot over alleged desecration of the Host, the wafer that when consecrated becomes the body of Jesus Christ, according to Catholic belief. For Muslims, the Koran is not a holy book, like the Christian Gospels or the Jewish Torah, but the
incarnate presence of Allah on Earth, dictated to the Prophet Mohammed word-for-word by the Archangel Gabriel. It is not prophecy, but the presence of divinity, as a number of commentators have observed, including this one (The crescent and the conclave, April
19, 2005).
Under the rubric Muslim anguish and Western hypocrisy (Nov 23, 2004), I observed that Christianity once killed apostates as a matter of routine, an action defended in retrospect by Catholic theologians such as Michael Novak as appropriate to the times. Western commentators condemn the guards of the US prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, for desecrating the Koran, while regarding Pakistani or Afghan Koran rioters as primitives. Condescending Westerners should look more closely at their own history. [1]
Host-desecration riots by Christians in 1298 led to an estimated 100,000 deaths in Germany and Austria, starting with the execution by fire of the entire Jewish community of Rottingen. Enraged Christians killed 3,000 Jews in Prague after a priest carrying a consecrated Host wafer was sprayed by sand. Other killings took place in Rome in 1021, Strasbourg in 1308, Posen in 1399, Silesia in 1451, and so forth. Medieval Jews, to be sure, were less likely to have tortured a consecrated Host than Marine guards were to have flushed a Koran down the toilet, and historians agree that the charge was a fabrication. [2] Christian sensitivities, nonetheless, were just as bloodthirsty as in today's Pakistan.
Worshipping divine incarnation in a book, to be sure, has quite different implications than worshipping the incarnate presence of God in bread and wine. Textual criticism becomes heresy as a matter of course. And without the sort of textual criticism that busied the Christian reformers at the turn of the 16th century, it is odd to speak of an Islamic reformation. A book in whose very words God reveals his presence must remain stuck in time like a fly in amber.
Muslim violence over desecration of the Koran is not uncommon, as a matter of fact. According to the Nigerian Christian journalist Rudolf Ogoo Okonkwo:
"In December of 1994, a Nigerian Christian trader, Gideon Akaluka, was accused of tearing pages out of the Koran in the northern city of Kano. Muslim youths launched an attack on him. He was rescued by the police and locked up in Bompai prison. On December 26, 1996, Muslim groups stormed the prison, pulled Akaluka out and beheaded him. They hoisted his head on a pike and paraded through the streets of Kano.
"On December 12, 2001, a Nigerian Christian truck driver, Saint Moritz, was reversing his truck near a fruit market in Kano. His truck accidentally ran into an area occupied by a Koranic study group. As students fled, one dropped his Koran. The truck trampled on a copy of the Koran. Muslim groups pursued the man. He ran to a police station. Mobs stormed the police station, overpowered the few cops on post and dragged the man to the street. They beat the man unconscious. He later died in a hospital."
No one, of course, is accused of desecrating a consecrated Host any longer, so Catholics have no one against whom to riot. Few Catholics, for that matter, still believe that the wafer really turns into the flesh of Jesus Christ (according to a 1992 Gallup Poll, only 30% of American Catholics polled clearly expressed this belief), and therefore are unlikely to riot even if someone really were to desecrate a Host. Unlike the skeptical Catholics, Muslims actually believe in the divine character of the Koran, and thus have something to riot about.
It now seems clear that some of the Guantanamo guards did abuse copies of the Koran, even if they did not, as Newsweek reported, flush one down a toilet. It would be surprising if US interrogators never resorted to Koran abuse as a technique for breaking down the will of prisoners. Like sensory deprivation, psychotropic drugs and physical stress, desecrating the Koran may be an effective interrogation technique. That does not make the practice any less deplorable, but the fact that it is likely to be quite effective in destroying the morale of Muslim prisoners increases the probability that it will be applied on occasion.
Two things explain the effectiveness of Koran desecration as a means of breaking Muslim morale. The first is that the Koran hosts Allah's incarnate presence, so to speak. The second is the peculiar importance of success to Islam. Unlike Christianity or Judaism,
worldly success is the ultimate testimony of Islam; the muezzin calls, "Come to prayer. Come to success!", and its emblem is the crescent, a symbol of secular growth, as opposed to the cross, a symbol of renunciation of worldly things. As I wrote in Horror and humiliation in Fallujah (April 27, 2004),
"The West cannot endure without faith that a loving Father dwells beyond the clouds that obscure His throne ... The Islamic world cannot endure without confidence in victory, that to "come to prayer" is the same thing as to "come to success". Humiliation - the perception that the ummah cannot reward those who submit to it - is beyond its capacity to endure."
Abusing the Koran is the equivalent of abusing Allah himself, and tells the Muslim prisoner that his god is powerless to avenge insults. Again, I do not condone such things, but merely observe that an effective weapon is more likely to be put to use. As I wrote in "Horror and humiliation in Fallujah:
"Radical Islam has risen against the West in response to its humiliation - intentional or not - at Western hands. The West can break the revolt by inflicting even worse humiliation upon the Islamists, poisoning the confidence of their supporters in the Muslim world."
The ultimate in American condescension is the "Muslim World Outreach" strategy exposed by US News and World Report on April 25. [3] As David E Kaplan reported:
"Although US officials say they are wary of being drawn into a theological battle, many have concluded that America can no longer sit on the sidelines as radicals and moderates fight over the future of a politicized religion with over a billion followers. The result has been an extraordinary - and growing - effort to influence what officials describe as an Islamic reformation.
"Attempting to engineer an Islamic reformation may be the silliest initiative in foreign policy in the history of the world. The theological department of the Central Intelligence Agency will not persuade Muslims to loosen their grasp on the living presence of Allah on this Earth. In its tragic encounter with Islam, the West cannot help but inflict humiliation."
The Koran desecration affair, with its parallels to medieval Christian violence, reinforces the conclusion I drew in my November 22 essay:
"Jews and Christians had centuries to accomplish the transition from public and political religion to private and communal religion, whereas circumstances press moderate Muslims to do this on the spot. The two older religions did so under duress, chaotically, and with limited success. Whether Islam can make such a transition at all remains doubtful."
Notes
[1] See for example Kenneth Woodward, "Newsweek and the Koran" in The Wall Street Journal, May 18, 2005, p A14.
[2] According to Wikipedia, "Host desecration is an anti-Semitic myth similar to the blood libel myth. It started in late 13th-century England and France (a century after Christians started making blood libel accusations against Jews), where it was claimed that Jews would steal consecrated Host wafers and torture them. According to the Roman Catholic dogma of transubstantiation, a consecrated Host wafer becomes the flesh of Jesus, so it was believed that Jews would steal and torture these wafers to reenact the crucifixion of Christ."
[3] "Hearts, Minds and Dollars" by David E Kaplan, US News and World Report, April 25, 2005.
(Copyright 2005 Asia Times Online Ltd. All rights reserved.)
[UMNO] Money Politics: "Meludah Ke Langit"
The Sun, Kuala Lumpur
Umno shooting itself in the foot, says MP
Maria J. Dass, 6 Jun 2005
PETALING JAYA: "Meludah ke langit" was how an Umno MP described the party's plans to change the term "money politics" in its code of ethics to "political bribery".
Currently members are charged under the party's laws for money politics but allowing cases to be hauled to court due to the change in term is tantamount to shooting oneself in the foot, said the politician who spoke on condition of anonymity.
Suspending membership, and relinquishing the party and government posts of members who are found guilty of money politics is one thing, he said. "But when it involves threat to their parliamentary and state seats what is going to happen? Is Umno willing to drop the nine members with parliamentary and state seats and then contest in nine by-elections?
"This problem of corruption is everywhere -- even in PAS and DAP but they keep it well guarded. Only Umno wants to kill itself," he said.
"More so the party goes after the small fries and allows the bigger ones to get away because the whole disciplinary system itself is corrupted."
The Umno constitution states that party members who are suspended of their membership must relinquish their party and government post.
That vacant post will be filled by a deputy or managed by someone appointed in an acting capacity.
Umno shooting itself in the foot, says MP
Maria J. Dass, 6 Jun 2005
PETALING JAYA: "Meludah ke langit" was how an Umno MP described the party's plans to change the term "money politics" in its code of ethics to "political bribery".
Currently members are charged under the party's laws for money politics but allowing cases to be hauled to court due to the change in term is tantamount to shooting oneself in the foot, said the politician who spoke on condition of anonymity.
Suspending membership, and relinquishing the party and government posts of members who are found guilty of money politics is one thing, he said. "But when it involves threat to their parliamentary and state seats what is going to happen? Is Umno willing to drop the nine members with parliamentary and state seats and then contest in nine by-elections?
"This problem of corruption is everywhere -- even in PAS and DAP but they keep it well guarded. Only Umno wants to kill itself," he said.
"More so the party goes after the small fries and allows the bigger ones to get away because the whole disciplinary system itself is corrupted."
The Umno constitution states that party members who are suspended of their membership must relinquish their party and government post.
That vacant post will be filled by a deputy or managed by someone appointed in an acting capacity.
[Malaysia] Najib: Don't Divide the Muslims
Najib warns PAS not to divide nation's Muslims
Malaysiakini, Jun 6, 2005
The government today warned the fundamentalist Islamic opposition party PAS to act responsibly and not cause divisions among the nation's Muslims after it vowed to reform itself under new leadership.
"It's too early to tell in terms of what the new PAS leadership will do," Deputy Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak said after last week's annual congress of PAS which saw veteran party members turfed out.
"I hope they will be responsible and not do something that will divide Muslims or use excessive methods which touch on faith," he told reporters.
PAS has foundered since its humiliating election defeat in 2004 general elections which slashed its presence in parliament from 27 seats to five and lost it the former heartland of Terengganu state.
The new guard ushered in last week has urged the party to halt its alienating rhetoric and make itself more attractive to Malaysia's Chinese and Indian communities so that it can become a viable alternative government.
In a sign of the times, Nasharuddin Mat Isa, the party's moderate and western-educated secretary-general, beat incumbent fundamentalist cleric Hassan Shukri for the post of deputy president, the top position up for grabs in the leadership elections.
Hardline police rejected
Najib, the Umno deputy president said PAS's hardline approach had been comprehensively rejected in multicultural Malaysia.
People continue to have confidence in Umno because of "its moderate and progressive policies, which are based on Muslim principles," he said.
Muslim Malays make up some 60 percent of Malaysia's 25 million population, with Chinese accounting for 25 percent and Indians 7.5 percent.
- AFP
Malaysiakini, Jun 6, 2005
The government today warned the fundamentalist Islamic opposition party PAS to act responsibly and not cause divisions among the nation's Muslims after it vowed to reform itself under new leadership.
"It's too early to tell in terms of what the new PAS leadership will do," Deputy Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak said after last week's annual congress of PAS which saw veteran party members turfed out.
"I hope they will be responsible and not do something that will divide Muslims or use excessive methods which touch on faith," he told reporters.
PAS has foundered since its humiliating election defeat in 2004 general elections which slashed its presence in parliament from 27 seats to five and lost it the former heartland of Terengganu state.
The new guard ushered in last week has urged the party to halt its alienating rhetoric and make itself more attractive to Malaysia's Chinese and Indian communities so that it can become a viable alternative government.
In a sign of the times, Nasharuddin Mat Isa, the party's moderate and western-educated secretary-general, beat incumbent fundamentalist cleric Hassan Shukri for the post of deputy president, the top position up for grabs in the leadership elections.
Hardline police rejected
Najib, the Umno deputy president said PAS's hardline approach had been comprehensively rejected in multicultural Malaysia.
People continue to have confidence in Umno because of "its moderate and progressive policies, which are based on Muslim principles," he said.
Muslim Malays make up some 60 percent of Malaysia's 25 million population, with Chinese accounting for 25 percent and Indians 7.5 percent.
- AFP
[Malaysia] PAS' New Leaders
Radio Singapore International
Malaysia's largest opposition party PAS names new liberal leaders
June 6, 2005
Malaysia's largest opposition party named new liberal leaders, shunning hard line clerics on Sunday. Parti Islam se-Malaysia or PAS elected 43-year-old reformist Nasharudin Mat
Isa as new deputy to ultra conservative leader Hadi Awang. Many other liberals also won posts, marking a major power shift in the party ahead of general elections in 2008.
This shows that PAS realizes the old guards don't have what it takes to win the votes and that it must modernize with the times.
Professor Shamsul A. Baharrudin (SB) is the Director of the Institute of the Malay World and Civilization at the University Kebangsaan in Malaysia. He first tells Howie Lim the significance of Nasharudin Mat Isa being voted in as new deputy to Hadi Awang.
SB: I think the most important consequence of this is that the PAS members are giving a signal to the public that it is willing to change from what seemed to be a very exclusive party leadership to a more inclusive one in which interests of Malays beyond Islam and non-Muslims will be considered equally important in this multi-cultural and multi-ethnic society so PAS is ready to make changes to its approach and policy.
Nasharudin's also been touted as one who represents the group of young professionals who turned to PAS after Anwar Ibrahim was sacked and arrested in 1998. He is also seen as a rising star in PAS and the future face of the party. Tell us more about the man.
SB: I think if Nasharudin takes over, what it promises is that he's a very global and international person and secondly, he's also involved in the corporate movement and therefore, I can see PAS moving away from the Taliban type of politics, to a more right now and contemporary type of politics.
Could you also comment on the significance of the many other liberals who won posts such as Husam Musa, Mohamed Sabu and Hasan Ali? Does this indicate the general direction that PAS will be taking?
SB: What we have to read from this is that these leaders are already there, even in the old guard. What's important now is how can these leaders who are in the old guard change according to the new leadership and therefore, I believe, they will be inline in the way they think with the new shift in PAS and this will bring PAS to a different level of communications and also interaction with the general public and with the potential voters as well. I think these are the changes we will be looking out for with the new leadership.
Hadi Awang talks about the party needing to change to stay relevant. Could you elaborate on this? Has PAS been languishing thus far? SB: If we look at the concrete results of the election in 99 and 2004, PAS has actually won support by default. Also, in our over anxious need to exert about the global influence Islam has over the world, we've forgotten that PAS hasn't delivered very much economically to their voters. We need to move beyond political Islam and into more bread and butter Islam. I think this is what we're looking at because the loss they suffered in Kelantan cannot be denied. They fell from the dominant party to hardly surviving with less than a two seat majority. You can see that even without the 99 success and 2004 failure Kelantan being the center for PAS for many years has also suffered from loss of support.
Though Hadi Awang talks about this need to change, he does say that this leadership change will not mean that PAS drops its goal of turning Malaysia into a strict Islamic state, based on the Koran. How does this go inline with the changes that PAS is undergoing, like you talked about?
SB: Well, these are all pronouncements that he's made, I think, as a safe-face device that had to be made in order to comfort themselves. These are the contradictions they have to solve in party as soon as possible.
And that was Professor Shamsul A. Baharrudin (SB), Director of the Institute of the Malay World and Civilization at the University Kebangsaan in Malaysia, speaking to Howie Lim.
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2005/6/6/nation
/11142788&sec=nation
Most dramatic change in decades
JOCELINE TAN Monday June 6, 2005
A LOUD roar of approval erupted from the packed hall when it was announced that Nasharudin Mat Isa was the new deputy president of PAS. The 42-year-old rising star had defeated two of the most established faces in PAS. But for the PAS faithful present, it was more than just a contest for a top party post.
Nasharudin's win signified the most dramatic leadership change that the party had seen in decades. It also signalled the party's intention to introduce urgent reform in the party.
Nasharuddin polled 536 votes against the hardline incumbent Senator Hassan Shukri and former Kelantan deputy mentri besar Datuk Halim Abdul Rahman. The three men stayed glued to their seats as the standard salutation of Takbir! and "Allah!" rose from the floor.
Hassan, ousted after only one term, was a dogmatic figure whom many saw as a liability to president Datuk Seri Hadi Awang. Hadi sat expressionless through the announcement. He had remained above the fray throughout the election campaign.
But his long-time friend and party colleague Datuk Mustafa Ali said: "Hadi may not show it but he is for the change. He really welcomes it."
Party members would be loathed to admit it but Hadi has struggled to fill the shoes of his late predecessor, Datuk Fadzil Mohd Noor, who was respected for his Islamic rigour as well as his political dexterity.
Hadi's Islamic credentials are quite unchallenged but he has none of the political savvy and charm of Fadzil.
It is obvious that members think that Nasharudin, with his relative youth, education, broad worldview and people skills, will be able to complement Hadi.
The vice-presidents' contest also ushered Kelantan top favourite Husam Musa, 46, into the top placing. Kedah orator Mohamad Sabu, 50, came in second. His win is seen as the delegates' way of keeping the geographical balance of power in the party. Incumbent Datuk Dr Hassan Ali, who is also Selangor PAS chief, retained his seat but the wind of change blew him down to third place.
The fact that delegates were prepared to accept an all non-ulama team of vice-presidents also surprised onlookers.
Members insist the trio make a good team - Husam as a thinking politician, Mat Sabu as grassroots leader and Dr Hassan as the link to the middle-of-the-road Malays.
Woman vice-president candidate Dr Siti Mariah Mahmood failed to make it despite staunch support from Datuk Seri Nik Aziz Nik Mat.
The dominantly male delegates were obviously not ready for a woman.
Husam, 46, had been the favourite from the beginning. His efforts at turning around Kelantan's financial crisis had won him admirers in the party and accolades from his Mentri Besar boss.
Nik Aziz, who had turned up only after lunch, after complaining of a headache earlier in the morning, tried not to smile too broadly at his young protégé's victory.
Out-going vice-president Mustafa probably felt the greatest sense of satisfaction. He had sent out a strong signal when he stepped aside to make way for new blood.
Some said the party agenda Hadi spelt out in his presidential speech on Friday was seen by delegates as a signal for a new and more energetic team to carry out the onerous challenge.
The central committee saw about 30% new faces.
PAS is not a party that accepts change easily or readily. It must have taken a great deal of courage for members to go for such dramatic change. The expectations of the new team will be sky-high and the new line-up will have to perform and deliver.
Malaysia's largest opposition party PAS names new liberal leaders
June 6, 2005
Malaysia's largest opposition party named new liberal leaders, shunning hard line clerics on Sunday. Parti Islam se-Malaysia or PAS elected 43-year-old reformist Nasharudin Mat
Isa as new deputy to ultra conservative leader Hadi Awang. Many other liberals also won posts, marking a major power shift in the party ahead of general elections in 2008.
This shows that PAS realizes the old guards don't have what it takes to win the votes and that it must modernize with the times.
Professor Shamsul A. Baharrudin (SB) is the Director of the Institute of the Malay World and Civilization at the University Kebangsaan in Malaysia. He first tells Howie Lim the significance of Nasharudin Mat Isa being voted in as new deputy to Hadi Awang.
SB: I think the most important consequence of this is that the PAS members are giving a signal to the public that it is willing to change from what seemed to be a very exclusive party leadership to a more inclusive one in which interests of Malays beyond Islam and non-Muslims will be considered equally important in this multi-cultural and multi-ethnic society so PAS is ready to make changes to its approach and policy.
Nasharudin's also been touted as one who represents the group of young professionals who turned to PAS after Anwar Ibrahim was sacked and arrested in 1998. He is also seen as a rising star in PAS and the future face of the party. Tell us more about the man.
SB: I think if Nasharudin takes over, what it promises is that he's a very global and international person and secondly, he's also involved in the corporate movement and therefore, I can see PAS moving away from the Taliban type of politics, to a more right now and contemporary type of politics.
Could you also comment on the significance of the many other liberals who won posts such as Husam Musa, Mohamed Sabu and Hasan Ali? Does this indicate the general direction that PAS will be taking?
SB: What we have to read from this is that these leaders are already there, even in the old guard. What's important now is how can these leaders who are in the old guard change according to the new leadership and therefore, I believe, they will be inline in the way they think with the new shift in PAS and this will bring PAS to a different level of communications and also interaction with the general public and with the potential voters as well. I think these are the changes we will be looking out for with the new leadership.
Hadi Awang talks about the party needing to change to stay relevant. Could you elaborate on this? Has PAS been languishing thus far? SB: If we look at the concrete results of the election in 99 and 2004, PAS has actually won support by default. Also, in our over anxious need to exert about the global influence Islam has over the world, we've forgotten that PAS hasn't delivered very much economically to their voters. We need to move beyond political Islam and into more bread and butter Islam. I think this is what we're looking at because the loss they suffered in Kelantan cannot be denied. They fell from the dominant party to hardly surviving with less than a two seat majority. You can see that even without the 99 success and 2004 failure Kelantan being the center for PAS for many years has also suffered from loss of support.
Though Hadi Awang talks about this need to change, he does say that this leadership change will not mean that PAS drops its goal of turning Malaysia into a strict Islamic state, based on the Koran. How does this go inline with the changes that PAS is undergoing, like you talked about?
SB: Well, these are all pronouncements that he's made, I think, as a safe-face device that had to be made in order to comfort themselves. These are the contradictions they have to solve in party as soon as possible.
And that was Professor Shamsul A. Baharrudin (SB), Director of the Institute of the Malay World and Civilization at the University Kebangsaan in Malaysia, speaking to Howie Lim.
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2005/6/6/nation
/11142788&sec=nation
Most dramatic change in decades
JOCELINE TAN Monday June 6, 2005
A LOUD roar of approval erupted from the packed hall when it was announced that Nasharudin Mat Isa was the new deputy president of PAS. The 42-year-old rising star had defeated two of the most established faces in PAS. But for the PAS faithful present, it was more than just a contest for a top party post.
Nasharudin's win signified the most dramatic leadership change that the party had seen in decades. It also signalled the party's intention to introduce urgent reform in the party.
Nasharuddin polled 536 votes against the hardline incumbent Senator Hassan Shukri and former Kelantan deputy mentri besar Datuk Halim Abdul Rahman. The three men stayed glued to their seats as the standard salutation of Takbir! and "Allah!" rose from the floor.
Hassan, ousted after only one term, was a dogmatic figure whom many saw as a liability to president Datuk Seri Hadi Awang. Hadi sat expressionless through the announcement. He had remained above the fray throughout the election campaign.
But his long-time friend and party colleague Datuk Mustafa Ali said: "Hadi may not show it but he is for the change. He really welcomes it."
Party members would be loathed to admit it but Hadi has struggled to fill the shoes of his late predecessor, Datuk Fadzil Mohd Noor, who was respected for his Islamic rigour as well as his political dexterity.
Hadi's Islamic credentials are quite unchallenged but he has none of the political savvy and charm of Fadzil.
It is obvious that members think that Nasharudin, with his relative youth, education, broad worldview and people skills, will be able to complement Hadi.
The vice-presidents' contest also ushered Kelantan top favourite Husam Musa, 46, into the top placing. Kedah orator Mohamad Sabu, 50, came in second. His win is seen as the delegates' way of keeping the geographical balance of power in the party. Incumbent Datuk Dr Hassan Ali, who is also Selangor PAS chief, retained his seat but the wind of change blew him down to third place.
The fact that delegates were prepared to accept an all non-ulama team of vice-presidents also surprised onlookers.
Members insist the trio make a good team - Husam as a thinking politician, Mat Sabu as grassroots leader and Dr Hassan as the link to the middle-of-the-road Malays.
Woman vice-president candidate Dr Siti Mariah Mahmood failed to make it despite staunch support from Datuk Seri Nik Aziz Nik Mat.
The dominantly male delegates were obviously not ready for a woman.
Husam, 46, had been the favourite from the beginning. His efforts at turning around Kelantan's financial crisis had won him admirers in the party and accolades from his Mentri Besar boss.
Nik Aziz, who had turned up only after lunch, after complaining of a headache earlier in the morning, tried not to smile too broadly at his young protégé's victory.
Out-going vice-president Mustafa probably felt the greatest sense of satisfaction. He had sent out a strong signal when he stepped aside to make way for new blood.
Some said the party agenda Hadi spelt out in his presidential speech on Friday was seen by delegates as a signal for a new and more energetic team to carry out the onerous challenge.
The central committee saw about 30% new faces.
PAS is not a party that accepts change easily or readily. It must have taken a great deal of courage for members to go for such dramatic change. The expectations of the new team will be sky-high and the new line-up will have to perform and deliver.
[Malaysia] PAS Faces Reform
Al-Jazeera, 05 June 2005
Malaysia Islamic party faces reform
"Definitely there is a call for change. Delegates want leaders who can
deliver success. They want economic development. In their eyes, the old
guard has failed and now they need the young to lead"
- Shamsul Amir Baharuddin, National University of Malaysia
The raison d'etre of Malaysia's Islamic party - the establishment of an Islamic state - is under threat as it attempts to re-establish itself in mainstream politics. At its national congress in the northern state of Kota Bharu, Parti Islam SeMalaysia (PAS) called for former deputy premier Anwar Ibrahim to lead the country's opposition alliance as part of changes aimed at attracting moderates and non-Muslims.
PAS is reeling from defeat in the 2004 general elections, which slashed its presence in parliament from 27 seats to five and which lost it its former heartland of Terengganu state.
PAS support had rocketed during the past few years of former prime minister Mahathir Mohammad's leadership as it capitalised on the political fallout of Mahathir's incarceration of his former deputy on sodomy charges.
But with the departure of Mahathir from the political limelight and the release of Anwar from jail, PAS is now back where it used to be - on the fringes of the system.
Poll setback
"Definitely there is a call for change. Delegates want leaders who can deliver success. They want economic development," said Shamsul Amir Baharuddin, a sociology lecturer at the National University of Malaysia.
"In their eyes, the old guard has failed and now they need the young to lead," he said, adding that unless reforms are introduced quickly, PAS may no longer even appeal to Muslims who account for 60% of Malaysia's 25 million population.
The poll setback showed that PAS's goal of turning multi-cultural Malaysia into an Islamic state has limited popular support, compared to the so-called moderate version of Islam championed by the ruling National Front coalition.
With the winds of change blowing, PAS Secretary-General Nasharuddin Mat Isa, a UK graduate who is seen as a moderate, beat incumbent conservative cleric Hassan Shukri in a three-corner fight for the post of deputy president, the top position up for grabs in leadership elections held on Sunday.
The elections were expected to see a handover to the "Young Turks" who want to inject new ideas and dump conservative rhetoric, and all three vice-president posts were won by party moderates who are not clerics for the first time in PAS's history.
Senior clerics criticised
Husam Musa, an economist and loyalist of PAS spiritual leader Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat, scored the highest number of votes followed by activist Mohamad Sabu and motivational speaker Hassan Ali, who was an incumbent.
Also for the first time in the party's 51-year history, these young professional figures openly criticised the party's senior clerics at the annual meeting.
Salahuddin Ayub, an outspoken PAS youth chief, said on Thursday that the party must open its membership to non-Muslims in the minority Chinese and Indian communities if it wants to become a viable alternative government.
Taking aim at the revered council of senior clerics, the party's highest decision-making body, he accused them of poor leadership and said PAS needed a complete makeover.
Many feel PAS has widely alienated voters with what is being perceived as its narrow Islamic agenda.
Call for change
Kamaruddin Jaffar, a 53-year-old PAS central committee member and lawmaker, said the senior clerics have failed to advance the party's strength and influence, and there had been a mood for change since the last polls. "Being the party election year, a sense for change is strong, with the senior clerics facing attacks," Kamaruddin said.
But the lawmaker said that because of PAS's "institutional system", the clerics would continue to hold power and influence party direction. Shamsul said the old guard consider themselves a cut above the rest, adopting a policy of "male-dominated exclusivity" which serves to keep the young progressive leaders and women candidates out.
PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang said during the congress that the party was at a critical crossroads and called for the charismatic Anwar to lead the charge to dislodge the coalition led by the United Malays National Organisation (UMNO).
Anwar is currently banned from politics until April 2008, the same year the next general elections are expected to be held.
Malaysia Islamic party faces reform
"Definitely there is a call for change. Delegates want leaders who can
deliver success. They want economic development. In their eyes, the old
guard has failed and now they need the young to lead"
- Shamsul Amir Baharuddin, National University of Malaysia
The raison d'etre of Malaysia's Islamic party - the establishment of an Islamic state - is under threat as it attempts to re-establish itself in mainstream politics. At its national congress in the northern state of Kota Bharu, Parti Islam SeMalaysia (PAS) called for former deputy premier Anwar Ibrahim to lead the country's opposition alliance as part of changes aimed at attracting moderates and non-Muslims.
PAS is reeling from defeat in the 2004 general elections, which slashed its presence in parliament from 27 seats to five and which lost it its former heartland of Terengganu state.
PAS support had rocketed during the past few years of former prime minister Mahathir Mohammad's leadership as it capitalised on the political fallout of Mahathir's incarceration of his former deputy on sodomy charges.
But with the departure of Mahathir from the political limelight and the release of Anwar from jail, PAS is now back where it used to be - on the fringes of the system.
Poll setback
"Definitely there is a call for change. Delegates want leaders who can deliver success. They want economic development," said Shamsul Amir Baharuddin, a sociology lecturer at the National University of Malaysia.
"In their eyes, the old guard has failed and now they need the young to lead," he said, adding that unless reforms are introduced quickly, PAS may no longer even appeal to Muslims who account for 60% of Malaysia's 25 million population.
The poll setback showed that PAS's goal of turning multi-cultural Malaysia into an Islamic state has limited popular support, compared to the so-called moderate version of Islam championed by the ruling National Front coalition.
With the winds of change blowing, PAS Secretary-General Nasharuddin Mat Isa, a UK graduate who is seen as a moderate, beat incumbent conservative cleric Hassan Shukri in a three-corner fight for the post of deputy president, the top position up for grabs in leadership elections held on Sunday.
The elections were expected to see a handover to the "Young Turks" who want to inject new ideas and dump conservative rhetoric, and all three vice-president posts were won by party moderates who are not clerics for the first time in PAS's history.
Senior clerics criticised
Husam Musa, an economist and loyalist of PAS spiritual leader Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat, scored the highest number of votes followed by activist Mohamad Sabu and motivational speaker Hassan Ali, who was an incumbent.
Also for the first time in the party's 51-year history, these young professional figures openly criticised the party's senior clerics at the annual meeting.
Salahuddin Ayub, an outspoken PAS youth chief, said on Thursday that the party must open its membership to non-Muslims in the minority Chinese and Indian communities if it wants to become a viable alternative government.
Taking aim at the revered council of senior clerics, the party's highest decision-making body, he accused them of poor leadership and said PAS needed a complete makeover.
Many feel PAS has widely alienated voters with what is being perceived as its narrow Islamic agenda.
Call for change
Kamaruddin Jaffar, a 53-year-old PAS central committee member and lawmaker, said the senior clerics have failed to advance the party's strength and influence, and there had been a mood for change since the last polls. "Being the party election year, a sense for change is strong, with the senior clerics facing attacks," Kamaruddin said.
But the lawmaker said that because of PAS's "institutional system", the clerics would continue to hold power and influence party direction. Shamsul said the old guard consider themselves a cut above the rest, adopting a policy of "male-dominated exclusivity" which serves to keep the young progressive leaders and women candidates out.
PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang said during the congress that the party was at a critical crossroads and called for the charismatic Anwar to lead the charge to dislodge the coalition led by the United Malays National Organisation (UMNO).
Anwar is currently banned from politics until April 2008, the same year the next general elections are expected to be held.
Renungan Muktamar PAS ke-51
Renungan Pemilihan Pimpinan PAS di Muktamar ke-51, 4-6 Jun 2005
oleh Subky Latif
WALAUPUN kecamuk isu mencabar kedudukan Senator Hassan Shukri sebagai Timbalan Presiden PAS tidak sama dibandingkan dengan krisis pimpinan Dato' Asri hujung 70an dan awal 80an, tetapi yang malang dan menjadi sasaran utama para penyokong pimpinan PAS ketika itu ialah Ustaz Hassan Shukri.
Ketika itu beliau Setiausaha Agung. Dia baik dengan semua, tetapi kerana dia tidak dimasukkan dalam golongan Dato Asri, maka sekalian yang tidak sekata dengan Dato' Asri berkumpul di depan mejanya dan di rumahnya baik dari Terengganu, Kedah malah Kelantan.
Dia digugurkan dari jawatannya digantikan oleh Ustaz Nakhaie dan kemudian Dato' Abu Bakar Omar. Dia terus menjadi pegawai di Pejabat Agung PAS. Tetapi orang-orang tadi berkumpul di mejanya juga.
Akhirnya pimpinan bertukar kepada Haji Yusof Rawa. Ustaz Hasan dijadikan Setiausaha Agung semula. Dari segi populariti dan kemasyhuran dari semasa ke semasa dia di tempat ke belakang. Antara Haji Yusof Rawa, Dato' Fadzil Noor, Ustaz Nik Abdul Aziz dan Ustaz Abdul Hadi Awang, dia jauh ke belakang. Antara Mustafa Ali, Mohamad Sabu, Mahfuz Omar dan Salahuddin Ayubpun, beliau ke belakang juga.
Tetapi dia naik setapak ke setapak. Seorang pemimpin mati, Hassan Shukri naik ke takut dalam hiraki pimpinan. Ada yang keluar parti dan bersara, dia naik setakuk juga hatta menjadi Timbalan Presiden.
Mungkin jawatan itu terlalu tinggi untuknya, dan ada yang merasakan ia patut diberi kepada orang lain. Tetapi hujah dan perasaan saja tidak dapat menghalangnya kejawatan yang amat penting itu.
Kalau berlaku sesuatu kepada Presiden parti, maka beliau pula menjadi pemangku dan mungkin menjadi Presiden pula. Agaknya inilah menjadikan beliau sasaran.
Satu lagi kelemahan atau kekuatannya ialah suka menegur dan menghujah setiap pemimpin baik yang tinggi mahupun yang rendah daripadanya. Dato' Asri ditegurnya. Hassan Adli ditegurnya. Dato' Muhamad Nasir ditegur. Wan Ismail bekas Timbalan Menteri Besar
Kelantan ditegurnya.
Haji Yusof Rawa, Ustaz Nik Aziz, Ustaz Fadzil Noor dan Dato' Seri Abdul Hadi Awang pun ditegurnya. Setakat Dr. Lo' Lo dan Mahfuz Omar itu apa lagilah. Ada yang melihat sikap itu satu dan ada pula satu kelemahan.
Justeru itu sekali lagi beliau menjadi sasaran. Zaman Dato' Asri dulu tiada surat layang. Tetapi kini macam-macm ada. Tidak sampai macam kempen UMNO. Bezanya ialah UMNO bertukus lumus untuk menghapuskan kempen kotor itu, PAS baru nak belajar.
‘Semua sampai kepada kami,’ kata Dato' Najib tumpang membakar percikan api dalam PAS itu.
Yang ketara ialah pencabar Senator Hassan itu tercari-cari orang yang hendak melawannya. Sampai sepuluh nama dikemukakan untuk mencabarnya. Ini membawa erti pencabarnya tidak ada satu calon yang jelas.
Bukan PAS kekurangan orang untuk menjadi pemimpin, tetapi tiada orang mahu dijadikan peluru. Biasanya PAS berkelahi kerana tidak mahu menjadi pemimpin, sedang orang lain berkelahi kerana hendak menjadi pemimpin.
Calon yang baik dari semua ialah Dato Dr Haron Din bukan saja uzur tetapi dipercayai mengelak dari bunga politicking yang boleh melarikan dari akhlak politik Islam.
Biasanya Ustaz Hassan digunakan oleh parti dan oleh pemimpin-pemimpin dulu dan sekarang untuk menyelesaikan semua masalah baik untuk pentadbiran parti dan kewangan.
Sesiapa yang mengadu masalah kepada pemimpin PAS, semuanya diarahkan kepada Hassan Shukri. Kadang-kadang yang RM50 pun diserahkan kepadanya juga. Hatta anak Patrice Lumumba, Perdana Menteri Konggo yang terbunuh dalam krisis 40 tahun datang minta bantuan tambang pulang.
Beliau tidak suka bercakap dengan akhbar termasuk akhbar parti. Publisitinya tidak banyak, tetapi sebagai senator, sekurang-kurangnya dua rang yang diluluskan oleh Dewan Rakyat ditolak oleh Dewan Negara.
Satu mengenai penggunaan racun yang boleh membahayakan serangga dan setiap makhluk bernyawa. Nama-nama binatang disebut dalam rang. Perkataan manusia tidak disebut. Pada manusialah makluk bernyawa yang paling penting.
Kedua rang mengenai kawalan keselamatan lapangan terbang awam antarabangsa dari ancaman pengganas. Lapangan terbang domestik tidak disebut, sedang pengganas tidak mengira lapangan terbang. Atas teguran itu menteri berkenaan menarik balik rang itu untuk dikemukakan semua ke Dewan Rakyat.
Jarang rang yang diluluskan oleh Dewan Rakyat ditolak oleh Dewan Negara.
Bila berbangkit persoalan agama Islam di Dewan Negara, semua senator UMNO,MICA dan MIC berkerumun di kantin dan di lobi minta pandangan Ustaz Hassan. Baru-baru ini beliau mengedarkan terjemahan Quran dalam bahasa Inggeris kepada semua senator termasuk Yang Dipertua Dewan Negara Tan Sri Hamid Pawanteh. Dakwah ke?’ Tanya Tan Sri Hamid. Jawabnya, ‘Begitulah!’
Dia selalu setuju dengan saya. Yang dia tidak setuju ialah bila saya nasihat supaya berundur kerana peribadinya habis dicerca. ‘Zaman Dato Asri dulu, ana kena lebih teruk,’ jawabnya.
Tuahnya belum nampak, tetapi beliaulah antara khadam PAS yang sentiasa dirundung malang. Dia sudah lama belajar jadi orang bawah. Menebas rumput, menyapu sampah di sekeliling Markaz Tarbiyah supaya tidak canggung bila tidak lagi menjadi pemimpin parti.
oleh Subky Latif
WALAUPUN kecamuk isu mencabar kedudukan Senator Hassan Shukri sebagai Timbalan Presiden PAS tidak sama dibandingkan dengan krisis pimpinan Dato' Asri hujung 70an dan awal 80an, tetapi yang malang dan menjadi sasaran utama para penyokong pimpinan PAS ketika itu ialah Ustaz Hassan Shukri.
Ketika itu beliau Setiausaha Agung. Dia baik dengan semua, tetapi kerana dia tidak dimasukkan dalam golongan Dato Asri, maka sekalian yang tidak sekata dengan Dato' Asri berkumpul di depan mejanya dan di rumahnya baik dari Terengganu, Kedah malah Kelantan.
Dia digugurkan dari jawatannya digantikan oleh Ustaz Nakhaie dan kemudian Dato' Abu Bakar Omar. Dia terus menjadi pegawai di Pejabat Agung PAS. Tetapi orang-orang tadi berkumpul di mejanya juga.
Akhirnya pimpinan bertukar kepada Haji Yusof Rawa. Ustaz Hasan dijadikan Setiausaha Agung semula. Dari segi populariti dan kemasyhuran dari semasa ke semasa dia di tempat ke belakang. Antara Haji Yusof Rawa, Dato' Fadzil Noor, Ustaz Nik Abdul Aziz dan Ustaz Abdul Hadi Awang, dia jauh ke belakang. Antara Mustafa Ali, Mohamad Sabu, Mahfuz Omar dan Salahuddin Ayubpun, beliau ke belakang juga.
Tetapi dia naik setapak ke setapak. Seorang pemimpin mati, Hassan Shukri naik ke takut dalam hiraki pimpinan. Ada yang keluar parti dan bersara, dia naik setakuk juga hatta menjadi Timbalan Presiden.
Mungkin jawatan itu terlalu tinggi untuknya, dan ada yang merasakan ia patut diberi kepada orang lain. Tetapi hujah dan perasaan saja tidak dapat menghalangnya kejawatan yang amat penting itu.
Kalau berlaku sesuatu kepada Presiden parti, maka beliau pula menjadi pemangku dan mungkin menjadi Presiden pula. Agaknya inilah menjadikan beliau sasaran.
Satu lagi kelemahan atau kekuatannya ialah suka menegur dan menghujah setiap pemimpin baik yang tinggi mahupun yang rendah daripadanya. Dato' Asri ditegurnya. Hassan Adli ditegurnya. Dato' Muhamad Nasir ditegur. Wan Ismail bekas Timbalan Menteri Besar
Kelantan ditegurnya.
Haji Yusof Rawa, Ustaz Nik Aziz, Ustaz Fadzil Noor dan Dato' Seri Abdul Hadi Awang pun ditegurnya. Setakat Dr. Lo' Lo dan Mahfuz Omar itu apa lagilah. Ada yang melihat sikap itu satu dan ada pula satu kelemahan.
Justeru itu sekali lagi beliau menjadi sasaran. Zaman Dato' Asri dulu tiada surat layang. Tetapi kini macam-macm ada. Tidak sampai macam kempen UMNO. Bezanya ialah UMNO bertukus lumus untuk menghapuskan kempen kotor itu, PAS baru nak belajar.
‘Semua sampai kepada kami,’ kata Dato' Najib tumpang membakar percikan api dalam PAS itu.
Yang ketara ialah pencabar Senator Hassan itu tercari-cari orang yang hendak melawannya. Sampai sepuluh nama dikemukakan untuk mencabarnya. Ini membawa erti pencabarnya tidak ada satu calon yang jelas.
Bukan PAS kekurangan orang untuk menjadi pemimpin, tetapi tiada orang mahu dijadikan peluru. Biasanya PAS berkelahi kerana tidak mahu menjadi pemimpin, sedang orang lain berkelahi kerana hendak menjadi pemimpin.
Calon yang baik dari semua ialah Dato Dr Haron Din bukan saja uzur tetapi dipercayai mengelak dari bunga politicking yang boleh melarikan dari akhlak politik Islam.
Biasanya Ustaz Hassan digunakan oleh parti dan oleh pemimpin-pemimpin dulu dan sekarang untuk menyelesaikan semua masalah baik untuk pentadbiran parti dan kewangan.
Sesiapa yang mengadu masalah kepada pemimpin PAS, semuanya diarahkan kepada Hassan Shukri. Kadang-kadang yang RM50 pun diserahkan kepadanya juga. Hatta anak Patrice Lumumba, Perdana Menteri Konggo yang terbunuh dalam krisis 40 tahun datang minta bantuan tambang pulang.
Beliau tidak suka bercakap dengan akhbar termasuk akhbar parti. Publisitinya tidak banyak, tetapi sebagai senator, sekurang-kurangnya dua rang yang diluluskan oleh Dewan Rakyat ditolak oleh Dewan Negara.
Satu mengenai penggunaan racun yang boleh membahayakan serangga dan setiap makhluk bernyawa. Nama-nama binatang disebut dalam rang. Perkataan manusia tidak disebut. Pada manusialah makluk bernyawa yang paling penting.
Kedua rang mengenai kawalan keselamatan lapangan terbang awam antarabangsa dari ancaman pengganas. Lapangan terbang domestik tidak disebut, sedang pengganas tidak mengira lapangan terbang. Atas teguran itu menteri berkenaan menarik balik rang itu untuk dikemukakan semua ke Dewan Rakyat.
Jarang rang yang diluluskan oleh Dewan Rakyat ditolak oleh Dewan Negara.
Bila berbangkit persoalan agama Islam di Dewan Negara, semua senator UMNO,MICA dan MIC berkerumun di kantin dan di lobi minta pandangan Ustaz Hassan. Baru-baru ini beliau mengedarkan terjemahan Quran dalam bahasa Inggeris kepada semua senator termasuk Yang Dipertua Dewan Negara Tan Sri Hamid Pawanteh. Dakwah ke?’ Tanya Tan Sri Hamid. Jawabnya, ‘Begitulah!’
Dia selalu setuju dengan saya. Yang dia tidak setuju ialah bila saya nasihat supaya berundur kerana peribadinya habis dicerca. ‘Zaman Dato Asri dulu, ana kena lebih teruk,’ jawabnya.
Tuahnya belum nampak, tetapi beliaulah antara khadam PAS yang sentiasa dirundung malang. Dia sudah lama belajar jadi orang bawah. Menebas rumput, menyapu sampah di sekeliling Markaz Tarbiyah supaya tidak canggung bila tidak lagi menjadi pemimpin parti.
[Malaysia] A Pill Too Hard To Swallow
Sin Chew Jit Pao, 06 June 2005
A Pill Too Hard To Swallow
One of the biggest stresses globalisation gives to the world in the new millennium, is the rise and fall of languages and civilisations. This crisis is particularly acute in countries heavily dependent on economic powers for their mere survival, such as Malaysia.
In order to align oneself with the developed West, English has become an important tool. Despite the fact that Malaysia used to be an English colony, its English standard today remains much to be desired, at least "poor English" has been cited as one of the major reasons business bosses have turned down so many job-seeking fresh graduates.
Hong Kong, Singapore and the Philippines have perhaps the highest standards of English anywhere in Asia Pacific. Hong Kong and Singapore are tiny islands with hardly any cultural burden. Prior to its reversion to the Chinese rule, Hong Kong was administered by the British, and her people, even unwilling to learn English, could hardly be bothered about picking up Mandarin. Instead, they had made the predominant culture from
neighbouring Guangdong province their cultural inclination.
Psychologically, Hong Kongers had relatively insignificant cultural obligation. If they wanted to learn English, they could always do so, hardly feeling the so-called language "invasiveness." Moreover, there were a lot of practical benefits which they could gain for learning this language, and there was completely no cause for repulsion.
Having mastered English, the Hong Kongers continued to speak their native Cantonese in the liveliest possible fashion, even scourging their influences over much of the continent through the territory's flourishing entertainment business to, at a twist of fate, influence the way the dialect should be spoken in Guangdong. The absurdity and senselessness typical of Stephen Chau's movie lingo have to a certain extent dictated the trend of the development of the Cantonese dialect.
What really made the Hong Kongers feel the invasiveness of a language, was the infiltration of Mandarin after the territory's reversion to Chinese rule. Hong Kongers were subsequently compelled to learn Mandarin, or Putonghua, although they have made only limited progress due to their unwillingness and antipathy.
As for Singapore, thanks to Lee Kuan Yew's erstwhile linguo-cultural policies, the city-state successfully moulded a citizenry largely subscribing to the concept that language was appended to economic progress, and gradually shedding most of its own historical and cultural burdens. If not because the sleepy giant which was China now stands up and
stretches its body, Singapore could not even have thought hard to organise some kind of campaign to resuscitate the Chinese language in the tiny republic; hopefully with a little help from the Chinese language acting as a sucking disc, the city-state can attach itself securely on that oversized economic behemoth.
In this respect, the various peoples of Malaysia, owing to sentimental recalcitrance, have been engaging in a tug-of-war for so many decades. The more the government plays up the importance of the national language, the more do Chinese Malaysians feel the need to safeguard their mother tongue.
A blessing or otherwise, language has always been considered within the context of cultural education, with hardly anyone thinking of associating it with economic advancement. Undeniably, that could have explained the high level of purity of the country's Chinese language education, and the pre-eminent standard in Chinese language anywhere outside Greater China.
But with the advent of the new millennium, the tide of globalisation is too hard to resist and avert. If the country's language and education policies remain bonded in the racist suspicion of yesteryear, they will hardly offer any help to the country's future development.
The highly controversial 2-4-3 solution still has to be carried on owing to some kind of reasons, but in the end, this generation of innocent school children will be victimised.
And at such an instant, the government sets the issue aside, turning its focus instead to the decision of teaching Mandarin and Tamil in national primary schools. This, while appearing to be a welcome news for Chinese education in this country, is of limited practical use, given its "technical training for a second language education" approach, which will most likely produce a new generation of Malaysians with only skin-deep knowledge of the Chinese language.
But whatever the medicine in the government's bottle is, it is predicted to, somehow, get arrested at the narrow bottleneck--a pill too hard to swallow, and too hard to be thrown out.
We have no idea when the government will lay down its prejudices to decisively operate on the country's many malignancies.
A Pill Too Hard To Swallow
One of the biggest stresses globalisation gives to the world in the new millennium, is the rise and fall of languages and civilisations. This crisis is particularly acute in countries heavily dependent on economic powers for their mere survival, such as Malaysia.
In order to align oneself with the developed West, English has become an important tool. Despite the fact that Malaysia used to be an English colony, its English standard today remains much to be desired, at least "poor English" has been cited as one of the major reasons business bosses have turned down so many job-seeking fresh graduates.
Hong Kong, Singapore and the Philippines have perhaps the highest standards of English anywhere in Asia Pacific. Hong Kong and Singapore are tiny islands with hardly any cultural burden. Prior to its reversion to the Chinese rule, Hong Kong was administered by the British, and her people, even unwilling to learn English, could hardly be bothered about picking up Mandarin. Instead, they had made the predominant culture from
neighbouring Guangdong province their cultural inclination.
Psychologically, Hong Kongers had relatively insignificant cultural obligation. If they wanted to learn English, they could always do so, hardly feeling the so-called language "invasiveness." Moreover, there were a lot of practical benefits which they could gain for learning this language, and there was completely no cause for repulsion.
Having mastered English, the Hong Kongers continued to speak their native Cantonese in the liveliest possible fashion, even scourging their influences over much of the continent through the territory's flourishing entertainment business to, at a twist of fate, influence the way the dialect should be spoken in Guangdong. The absurdity and senselessness typical of Stephen Chau's movie lingo have to a certain extent dictated the trend of the development of the Cantonese dialect.
What really made the Hong Kongers feel the invasiveness of a language, was the infiltration of Mandarin after the territory's reversion to Chinese rule. Hong Kongers were subsequently compelled to learn Mandarin, or Putonghua, although they have made only limited progress due to their unwillingness and antipathy.
As for Singapore, thanks to Lee Kuan Yew's erstwhile linguo-cultural policies, the city-state successfully moulded a citizenry largely subscribing to the concept that language was appended to economic progress, and gradually shedding most of its own historical and cultural burdens. If not because the sleepy giant which was China now stands up and
stretches its body, Singapore could not even have thought hard to organise some kind of campaign to resuscitate the Chinese language in the tiny republic; hopefully with a little help from the Chinese language acting as a sucking disc, the city-state can attach itself securely on that oversized economic behemoth.
In this respect, the various peoples of Malaysia, owing to sentimental recalcitrance, have been engaging in a tug-of-war for so many decades. The more the government plays up the importance of the national language, the more do Chinese Malaysians feel the need to safeguard their mother tongue.
A blessing or otherwise, language has always been considered within the context of cultural education, with hardly anyone thinking of associating it with economic advancement. Undeniably, that could have explained the high level of purity of the country's Chinese language education, and the pre-eminent standard in Chinese language anywhere outside Greater China.
But with the advent of the new millennium, the tide of globalisation is too hard to resist and avert. If the country's language and education policies remain bonded in the racist suspicion of yesteryear, they will hardly offer any help to the country's future development.
The highly controversial 2-4-3 solution still has to be carried on owing to some kind of reasons, but in the end, this generation of innocent school children will be victimised.
And at such an instant, the government sets the issue aside, turning its focus instead to the decision of teaching Mandarin and Tamil in national primary schools. This, while appearing to be a welcome news for Chinese education in this country, is of limited practical use, given its "technical training for a second language education" approach, which will most likely produce a new generation of Malaysians with only skin-deep knowledge of the Chinese language.
But whatever the medicine in the government's bottle is, it is predicted to, somehow, get arrested at the narrow bottleneck--a pill too hard to swallow, and too hard to be thrown out.
We have no idea when the government will lay down its prejudices to decisively operate on the country's many malignancies.
US Running Secret Prisons
Agence France-Presse
Monday, June 6, 2005
US Running 'Archipelago' of Secret Prisons: Amnesty International
The US government is operating an "archipelago" of prisons around the world, many of them secret camps into which people are being "literally disappeared," a top Amnesty International official said.
Amnesty International executive director William Schulz criticized the administration of US President George W. Bush for holding alleged battlefield combatants in "indefinite incommunicado detention" without access to lawyers in an interview with Fox News Sunday.
Schulz was pressed to substantiate Amnesty's claim in a May 25 report that the US prison camp at the Guantanamo Bay, Cuba naval base -- where hundreds of foreign terror suspects are being held indefinitely -- represents the "gulag of our times."
The gulag claim, referring to the notorious prison camp system of the Soviet Union, has drawn withering criticism from the US president, who called it "absurd." Vice President Richard Cheney and Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld have also slammed the rights group's claim.
Russian 1970 Nobel Prize winner Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn described the Soviet prison camp system in his best-selling book "The Gulag Archipelago."
Schulz said the gulag reference was not "an exact or a literal analogy."
"But there are some similarities. The United States is maintaining an archipelago of prisons around the world, many of them secret prisons into which people are being literally disappeared -- held in indefinite incommunicado detention without access to lawyers," Schulz told Fox.
Asked how AI could compare the detentions of millions of Soviet citizens in the gulag system to purported anti-US combatants captured on the battlefield, Schulz said some of those held in Guantanamo "happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.
"We do know that at least some of the 200 some prisoners who have been released from Guantanamo Bay have made pretty persuasive cases that they were imprisoned there, not because they were involved in military conflict but simply because they were enemies of the Northern Alliance," he said.
Schulz called for an official probe into the alleged rights abuses at US detention centers around the globe.
Amnesty refers in the May 25 report to Rumsfeld and US Attorney General Alberto Gonzales as alleged "torture architects."
The United States "should be the one that should investigate those who are alleged at least to be architects of torture, not just the foot soldiers who may have inflicted the torture directly, but those who authorized it or encouraged it or provided rationales for it," Schulz said.
According to Amnesty, Rumsfeld provided "the exact rules, 27 of them in fact, for interrogations, some of which do constitute torture or cruel, inhumane treatment," Schulz said.
The Guantanamo Bay camp and US detention practices have been the subject of renewed debate in recent weeks, sparked by a Newsweek magazine report -- since retracted -- that Guantanamo interrogators flushed a Koran in a toilet to rattle Muslim prisoners.
Amnesty is not the only rights group to have called on Washington to investigate alleged abuses at the camp -- Schulz pointed to released FBI documents that also raised concerns about Guantanamo interrogations.
US officials insist such concerns are unfounded, and that the "war on terror" detainees are treated as humanely as possible.
US soldiers have been tried and punished for abusing detainees -- notably at Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison, where at least one captive died -- but US officials say those are isolated incidents.
The furor sparked by Amnesty's claims shows no signs of abating.
The New York Times said Sunday that the Guantanamo Bay prison should be closed down, saying it had become "a national shame" and a "propaganda gift to America's enemies."
"What makes Amnesty's gulag metaphor apt is that Guantanamo is merely one of a chain of shadowy detention camps that also includes Abu Ghraib in Iraq, the military prison at Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan and other, secret locations run by the intelligence agencies," the Times said.
The Washington Post, whose editorial page has been more critical of Amnesty's gulag claim, reported Sunday -- citing Schulz -- that Amnesty's donations have quintupled and new memberships have doubled in the past week since it released its report.
Copyright 2005 AFP - Agence France Presse
Monday, June 6, 2005
US Running 'Archipelago' of Secret Prisons: Amnesty International
The US government is operating an "archipelago" of prisons around the world, many of them secret camps into which people are being "literally disappeared," a top Amnesty International official said.
Amnesty International executive director William Schulz criticized the administration of US President George W. Bush for holding alleged battlefield combatants in "indefinite incommunicado detention" without access to lawyers in an interview with Fox News Sunday.
Schulz was pressed to substantiate Amnesty's claim in a May 25 report that the US prison camp at the Guantanamo Bay, Cuba naval base -- where hundreds of foreign terror suspects are being held indefinitely -- represents the "gulag of our times."
The gulag claim, referring to the notorious prison camp system of the Soviet Union, has drawn withering criticism from the US president, who called it "absurd." Vice President Richard Cheney and Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld have also slammed the rights group's claim.
Russian 1970 Nobel Prize winner Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn described the Soviet prison camp system in his best-selling book "The Gulag Archipelago."
Schulz said the gulag reference was not "an exact or a literal analogy."
"But there are some similarities. The United States is maintaining an archipelago of prisons around the world, many of them secret prisons into which people are being literally disappeared -- held in indefinite incommunicado detention without access to lawyers," Schulz told Fox.
Asked how AI could compare the detentions of millions of Soviet citizens in the gulag system to purported anti-US combatants captured on the battlefield, Schulz said some of those held in Guantanamo "happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.
"We do know that at least some of the 200 some prisoners who have been released from Guantanamo Bay have made pretty persuasive cases that they were imprisoned there, not because they were involved in military conflict but simply because they were enemies of the Northern Alliance," he said.
Schulz called for an official probe into the alleged rights abuses at US detention centers around the globe.
Amnesty refers in the May 25 report to Rumsfeld and US Attorney General Alberto Gonzales as alleged "torture architects."
The United States "should be the one that should investigate those who are alleged at least to be architects of torture, not just the foot soldiers who may have inflicted the torture directly, but those who authorized it or encouraged it or provided rationales for it," Schulz said.
According to Amnesty, Rumsfeld provided "the exact rules, 27 of them in fact, for interrogations, some of which do constitute torture or cruel, inhumane treatment," Schulz said.
The Guantanamo Bay camp and US detention practices have been the subject of renewed debate in recent weeks, sparked by a Newsweek magazine report -- since retracted -- that Guantanamo interrogators flushed a Koran in a toilet to rattle Muslim prisoners.
Amnesty is not the only rights group to have called on Washington to investigate alleged abuses at the camp -- Schulz pointed to released FBI documents that also raised concerns about Guantanamo interrogations.
US officials insist such concerns are unfounded, and that the "war on terror" detainees are treated as humanely as possible.
US soldiers have been tried and punished for abusing detainees -- notably at Iraq's Abu Ghraib prison, where at least one captive died -- but US officials say those are isolated incidents.
The furor sparked by Amnesty's claims shows no signs of abating.
The New York Times said Sunday that the Guantanamo Bay prison should be closed down, saying it had become "a national shame" and a "propaganda gift to America's enemies."
"What makes Amnesty's gulag metaphor apt is that Guantanamo is merely one of a chain of shadowy detention camps that also includes Abu Ghraib in Iraq, the military prison at Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan and other, secret locations run by the intelligence agencies," the Times said.
The Washington Post, whose editorial page has been more critical of Amnesty's gulag claim, reported Sunday -- citing Schulz -- that Amnesty's donations have quintupled and new memberships have doubled in the past week since it released its report.
Copyright 2005 AFP - Agence France Presse
[Malaysia] Say No To Drug Needles
Say no to free needles!
Abu Omar
Its another presposterous and ridiculous idea from the Health Minister. First, the idea of a privileged hospital wing for paying patients and a welfare section for the “down and outs”. In one desperate move, we have recreated a classic setting for class discrimination and social segregation in public health. Is this a development or a regression in the quality of life? We are moving backwards.
Now, if they have their way, they would like to be in the business of pushing needles to the addicts. Imagine the uproar over it. Surely the addicts themselves are caught by surprise. They’ll be spinning themselves uncontrollably. It is a sign of sheer utter desperation or just another liberal dose of Marina’s antics, ill thought forays into the realm of controversy and unending search for social recognition, otherwise elusive fame.
How sure are they that there will be a reduction in HIV? There surely will be a possibility in an increase in the of usage because needles are free so the addicts only look for the stuff to pump themselves high. If that is not enough, who will distribute it? The doctors, nurses and the health inspectors are too burdened to conduct registers of deserving bona fide addicts and proper techniques for injecting the hypodermics into them . Why won’t the addicts just sell them off for some cash to buy more of the other stuff? The floodgates of abuse shall be opened wide. In one stupendous move, we have condoned drug abuse and have aided and abetted drug pushers and dealers. How criminal and immoral this shall be!
Next, it may come to legalising certain drugs. A joke has it that this will discourage addicts from stealing and theft. There’s even talk of licensing prostitution and some have been hawking the idea of distributing condoms. Another case of if you can’t beat them, join them!
But reasonable and right minded people can never accept this. You prevent harm but you should never escalate the problem by making it more harmful.
Two wrongs do not make a right. Addiction is shocking. HIV is alarming. But the solution has to be abstinence and to combat the social and psychological, human causes of the disease. Never ever give up the fight. Yes, HIV can infect the innocents but the primary causes come from the business of illicit drugs and illegitimate relationships. The liberals will be disgusted by this but they have to come to terms with morality because immorality is the cause and continuation of these tragic diseases.
Abu Omar
Its another presposterous and ridiculous idea from the Health Minister. First, the idea of a privileged hospital wing for paying patients and a welfare section for the “down and outs”. In one desperate move, we have recreated a classic setting for class discrimination and social segregation in public health. Is this a development or a regression in the quality of life? We are moving backwards.
Now, if they have their way, they would like to be in the business of pushing needles to the addicts. Imagine the uproar over it. Surely the addicts themselves are caught by surprise. They’ll be spinning themselves uncontrollably. It is a sign of sheer utter desperation or just another liberal dose of Marina’s antics, ill thought forays into the realm of controversy and unending search for social recognition, otherwise elusive fame.
How sure are they that there will be a reduction in HIV? There surely will be a possibility in an increase in the of usage because needles are free so the addicts only look for the stuff to pump themselves high. If that is not enough, who will distribute it? The doctors, nurses and the health inspectors are too burdened to conduct registers of deserving bona fide addicts and proper techniques for injecting the hypodermics into them . Why won’t the addicts just sell them off for some cash to buy more of the other stuff? The floodgates of abuse shall be opened wide. In one stupendous move, we have condoned drug abuse and have aided and abetted drug pushers and dealers. How criminal and immoral this shall be!
Next, it may come to legalising certain drugs. A joke has it that this will discourage addicts from stealing and theft. There’s even talk of licensing prostitution and some have been hawking the idea of distributing condoms. Another case of if you can’t beat them, join them!
But reasonable and right minded people can never accept this. You prevent harm but you should never escalate the problem by making it more harmful.
Two wrongs do not make a right. Addiction is shocking. HIV is alarming. But the solution has to be abstinence and to combat the social and psychological, human causes of the disease. Never ever give up the fight. Yes, HIV can infect the innocents but the primary causes come from the business of illicit drugs and illegitimate relationships. The liberals will be disgusted by this but they have to come to terms with morality because immorality is the cause and continuation of these tragic diseases.
Muslim Professor Faces US Terror Trial
High-flying professor faces US terror trial
Jamie Wilson in Washington
Monday June 6, 2005, The Guardian
Sami al-Arian is used to mixing in elite political circles. The University of Florida professor met leading politicians such as Bill Clinton and George Bush in his role as the most high-profile advocate of the Palestinian cause in America. He was even invited to White House briefings.
But for more than two years, Dr Arian has been consorting in rather less rarefied company, in the maximum-security federal penitentiary in Coleman, Florida.
The professor of computer engineering goes on trial today in what is being billed as the most important terrorism case in the United States since September 11.
Prosecutors claim that Dr Arian, and three other Arab-Americans who will be in the dock with him, commanded an Islamic Jihad cell that flourished in Tampa and infiltrated the University of South Florida. The group is said to have helped finance a series of attacks in the West Bank, Gaza Strip and Israel in which more than 100 people died, including at least one American.
More than 100 Israelis, including survivors of terrorist attacks, victims' relatives, police investigators and paramedics, have been listed to testify at the trial, in an attempt by prosecutors to show the jury the grisly end-product of terrorist fundraising. Papers, pictures and tapes of wiretaps have been sent from Israel.
The 53-count indictment also accuses the defendants of racketeering, conspiracy and extortion. "This is an elitist little group of people, all highly educated, trying to convince people to go kill themselves on their behalf," is how William Furr, the lead prosecuting attorney, described the defendants at a pre-trial hearing last week.
However, supporters and lawyers for the Kuwait-born professor claim that it is not a straightforward case of terrorist funding. Instead, they say it raises serious issues about anti-Muslim bias in the US post-September 11, freedom of speech and what they see as a blatant attempt by Israel to silence a powerful Palestinian voice in America.
William Moffitt, a veteran civil rights lawyer who is representing Dr Arian, believes that his client is in the dock because of the cause he represents rather than any crimes he has committed. "He is an effective political operator. The idea that here is this guy who is speaking to the highest echelons of the US government, I imagine, makes him a threat in [Israeli] minds."
He continued: "I do find it very offensive that the Israelis would reach out here to try to silence an advocate of the other side in the US."
A spokesman for the prosecution refused to comment, but the Israeli embassy in Washington insisted that the case was not being run from Israel. "The trial was initiated by US authorities, following the killing of a US citizen in a Palestinian Islamic Jihad attack against Israel," said a spokesman.
An FBI investigation of Dr Arian began more than 10 years ago following a television documentary, Jihad in America, which focused on the activities of the World Islam and Studies Enterprise, a thinktank set up by the professor and his brother-in-law, Mazen al-
Najjar, who was also a professor in Tampa until he was deported in 1997.
The prosecution says the thinktank and a Palestinian charity set up by Dr Arian served as fronts for funnelling money to terrorists in Israel and the occupied territories, who then carried out attacks, including a 1995 suicide bombing that killed an American, Alisa Flatow.
Dr Arian denies any involvement in terrorism, but his image in Florida has not been helped by a video taken in the early 1990s in which he is seen shouting: "Death to Israel".
Mr Moffitt has compared his client to Nelson Mandela. And if Dr Arian was such an awful terrorist, the lawyer said, why was he able to get so close to some of America's most high-profile politicians?
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005
Jamie Wilson in Washington
Monday June 6, 2005, The Guardian
Sami al-Arian is used to mixing in elite political circles. The University of Florida professor met leading politicians such as Bill Clinton and George Bush in his role as the most high-profile advocate of the Palestinian cause in America. He was even invited to White House briefings.
But for more than two years, Dr Arian has been consorting in rather less rarefied company, in the maximum-security federal penitentiary in Coleman, Florida.
The professor of computer engineering goes on trial today in what is being billed as the most important terrorism case in the United States since September 11.
Prosecutors claim that Dr Arian, and three other Arab-Americans who will be in the dock with him, commanded an Islamic Jihad cell that flourished in Tampa and infiltrated the University of South Florida. The group is said to have helped finance a series of attacks in the West Bank, Gaza Strip and Israel in which more than 100 people died, including at least one American.
More than 100 Israelis, including survivors of terrorist attacks, victims' relatives, police investigators and paramedics, have been listed to testify at the trial, in an attempt by prosecutors to show the jury the grisly end-product of terrorist fundraising. Papers, pictures and tapes of wiretaps have been sent from Israel.
The 53-count indictment also accuses the defendants of racketeering, conspiracy and extortion. "This is an elitist little group of people, all highly educated, trying to convince people to go kill themselves on their behalf," is how William Furr, the lead prosecuting attorney, described the defendants at a pre-trial hearing last week.
However, supporters and lawyers for the Kuwait-born professor claim that it is not a straightforward case of terrorist funding. Instead, they say it raises serious issues about anti-Muslim bias in the US post-September 11, freedom of speech and what they see as a blatant attempt by Israel to silence a powerful Palestinian voice in America.
William Moffitt, a veteran civil rights lawyer who is representing Dr Arian, believes that his client is in the dock because of the cause he represents rather than any crimes he has committed. "He is an effective political operator. The idea that here is this guy who is speaking to the highest echelons of the US government, I imagine, makes him a threat in [Israeli] minds."
He continued: "I do find it very offensive that the Israelis would reach out here to try to silence an advocate of the other side in the US."
A spokesman for the prosecution refused to comment, but the Israeli embassy in Washington insisted that the case was not being run from Israel. "The trial was initiated by US authorities, following the killing of a US citizen in a Palestinian Islamic Jihad attack against Israel," said a spokesman.
An FBI investigation of Dr Arian began more than 10 years ago following a television documentary, Jihad in America, which focused on the activities of the World Islam and Studies Enterprise, a thinktank set up by the professor and his brother-in-law, Mazen al-
Najjar, who was also a professor in Tampa until he was deported in 1997.
The prosecution says the thinktank and a Palestinian charity set up by Dr Arian served as fronts for funnelling money to terrorists in Israel and the occupied territories, who then carried out attacks, including a 1995 suicide bombing that killed an American, Alisa Flatow.
Dr Arian denies any involvement in terrorism, but his image in Florida has not been helped by a video taken in the early 1990s in which he is seen shouting: "Death to Israel".
Mr Moffitt has compared his client to Nelson Mandela. And if Dr Arian was such an awful terrorist, the lawyer said, why was he able to get so close to some of America's most high-profile politicians?
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005
Guantanamo Should Be Closed
Senator urges Guantánamo closure after Pentagon admits Qur'an abuse
Dan Glaister in Los Angeles
Monday June 6, 2005, The Guardian
A leading Democrat called for Guantánamo Bay to be shut down yesterday after the US army admitted at the weekend that it had uncovered instances of desecration of the Qur'an at the prison camp.
The admission came almost a month after authorities criticised Newsweek magazine for a report that interrogators at Guantánamo Bay had flushed a Qur'an down a toilet.
The Pentagon report, released late on Friday, by Brigadier General Jay Hood detailed five cases of desecration at Guantánamo, including the Qur'an being kicked, stepped on, splashed with urine and soaked in water by guards.
But Gen Hood said he had not found any proof that a copy of the Qur'an was flushed down a toilet. The White House said at the time of the Newsweek report that it contributed to riots that led to the deaths of 16 people in Afghanistan.
"Mishandling of a Qur'an here is never condoned," said Gen Hood. "When one considers the many thousands of times detainees have been moved and cells have been searched ... I think one can only conclude that respect for detainee religious beliefs was embedded in the culture of [the taskforce] from the start."
He also said he had found 15 cases of desecration of the Qur'an by inmates.
"These included using a Qur'an as a pillow, ripping pages out of the Qur'an, attempting to flush a Qur'an down the toilet and urinating on the Qur'an," the report said.
The White House reacted bullishly to the Pentagon's disclosures. Scott McClellan, the White House spokesman, said: "Our men and women in the military adhere to the highest standards, including when it comes to respecting and protecting religious freedom." But Senator Joseph Biden, the leading Democrat on the Senate's foreign relations committee, said yesterday that Guantánamo was an embarrassment and should be shut.
"This has become the greatest propaganda tool that exists for recruiting of terrorists around the world," he told ABC television.
"It is unnecessary to be in that position. The end result is, I think we should end up shutting it down, moving those prisoners.
"Those that we have reason to keep, keep. And those we don't, let go."
The US holds about 540 detainees at the camp in Cuba. In one of the five cases detailed in the Hood report, a guard went outside a cell block and urinated near an air vent. A detainee complained that the urine "splashed on him and his Qur'an while he laid near the air vent," the report said. The guard was reassigned.
In another incident an interrogator stepped on a Qur'an and then apologised to the detainee. The private contract interrogator "was later terminated for a pattern of unacceptable behaviour, an inability to follow direct guidance and poor leadership," the report said.
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005
Dan Glaister in Los Angeles
Monday June 6, 2005, The Guardian
A leading Democrat called for Guantánamo Bay to be shut down yesterday after the US army admitted at the weekend that it had uncovered instances of desecration of the Qur'an at the prison camp.
The admission came almost a month after authorities criticised Newsweek magazine for a report that interrogators at Guantánamo Bay had flushed a Qur'an down a toilet.
The Pentagon report, released late on Friday, by Brigadier General Jay Hood detailed five cases of desecration at Guantánamo, including the Qur'an being kicked, stepped on, splashed with urine and soaked in water by guards.
But Gen Hood said he had not found any proof that a copy of the Qur'an was flushed down a toilet. The White House said at the time of the Newsweek report that it contributed to riots that led to the deaths of 16 people in Afghanistan.
"Mishandling of a Qur'an here is never condoned," said Gen Hood. "When one considers the many thousands of times detainees have been moved and cells have been searched ... I think one can only conclude that respect for detainee religious beliefs was embedded in the culture of [the taskforce] from the start."
He also said he had found 15 cases of desecration of the Qur'an by inmates.
"These included using a Qur'an as a pillow, ripping pages out of the Qur'an, attempting to flush a Qur'an down the toilet and urinating on the Qur'an," the report said.
The White House reacted bullishly to the Pentagon's disclosures. Scott McClellan, the White House spokesman, said: "Our men and women in the military adhere to the highest standards, including when it comes to respecting and protecting religious freedom." But Senator Joseph Biden, the leading Democrat on the Senate's foreign relations committee, said yesterday that Guantánamo was an embarrassment and should be shut.
"This has become the greatest propaganda tool that exists for recruiting of terrorists around the world," he told ABC television.
"It is unnecessary to be in that position. The end result is, I think we should end up shutting it down, moving those prisoners.
"Those that we have reason to keep, keep. And those we don't, let go."
The US holds about 540 detainees at the camp in Cuba. In one of the five cases detailed in the Hood report, a guard went outside a cell block and urinated near an air vent. A detainee complained that the urine "splashed on him and his Qur'an while he laid near the air vent," the report said. The guard was reassigned.
In another incident an interrogator stepped on a Qur'an and then apologised to the detainee. The private contract interrogator "was later terminated for a pattern of unacceptable behaviour, an inability to follow direct guidance and poor leadership," the report said.
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005
Cukai Tanah di Kedah Naik 400%
BN Kedah 'rompak' duit rakyat dengan menaikkan cukai tanah
Tuesday, May 31, Harakahdaily
Oleh Helmi Khalid
ALOR STAR, 31 Mei 2005 (Hrkh) - Sekalipun mempunyai seorang Menteri Besar yang sakit, namun Kedah tetap berkeinginan tinggi untuk meneruskan agenda 'membalas jasa' di samping merompak duit rakyat yang mengundi Barisan Nasional (BN) dengan menghadiahkan kenaikan cukai tanah melebihi sekali ganda.
Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (Adun) PAS-Anak Bukit, Haji Amiruddin Hamzah berkata, inilah gara-gara mengistiharkan Alor Star sebagai Bandar raya pada 21 Disember 2003 lalu dengan hasil Majlis Bandaraya tersebut tidak seberapa dan sebaliknya duit rakyat terpaksa di'rompak' secara senyap. "Ia juga adalah ekoran beberapa projek mega di Kedah yang nyata tidak mendatangkan pulangan, sebagai bukti berbelas projek yang dijalankan oleh anak syarikat Perbadanan Kemajuan Negeri Kedah (PKNK) mengalami kerugian.
"Kedah Maju 2010, inilah hasil kerja sebuah kerajaan ke era negeri maju, 10 kali lebih maju dari wawasan 2020," tegas beliau.
Sambung beliau, pelaburan besar kerajaan BN Kedah untuk membangunkan Kulim High Tech Park (KHTP) nyata membawa padah kerana gagal menarik minat ramai pelabur luar malah ada syarikat yang gulung tikar dan mempunyai tunggakan bil-bil tertentu yang tinggi selain gagal membayar cukai tanah perniagaan mereka.
Di Gurun katanya, bagi tapak kilang kereta Naza Motor, kerajaan BN Kedah cukup bijak iaitu dengan membeli tanah dengan harga yang mahal dan menjual pada kadar yang terlalu murah kepada pihak Naza.
"Jelas sekali kerajaan BN Kedah telah mengalami kerugian untuk urus niaga dengan Naza itu sahaja, namun bekas Exco Kedah, Rosnah Majid menyatakan itu adalah cara terbaik untuk menarik minat pelabur datang melabur di Kedah.
Menurutnya premium cukai tanah di Kedah bakal dinaikkan tahun hadapan, dan jumlah kenaikan amat tinggi tidak lain tidak bukan sebagai menghargai jasa rakyat yang terus memberi mandat kepada BN di Kedah menerajui negeri ini.
Sementara untuk tanah kebun getah dan dusun pula, dari RM30 sehektar dinaikkan menjadi RM60 sehektar, bagi sawah padi kawasan MADA dinaikkan dari RM13 menjadi RM40 sehektar, untuk tanah kampung dinaikkan dari RM20 sehektar kepada RM80 sehektar.
Manakala cukai bagi kediaman (banglo) dari RM50 menjadi RM130 dan rumah teres dan kos rendah dari RM30 menjadi RM60.
Katanya lagi, jika diteliti, semua rakyat tidak akan terkecuali dari 'menerima' hadiah BN ini, sekaligus menunjukkan betapa prihatinnya BN Kedah sekarang ini, sekalipun tidak bermenteri besar, namun mempunyai jiwa yang besar untuk menindas rakyat.
Sementara itu, Bendahari PAS Kedah yang juga Adun (PAS-Tokai), Haji Mohd. Taulan Rasul berkata, keadaan ini amat malang sekali dan membuktikan BN Kedah sanggup menipu untuk mencapai status negeri maju.
Katanya, dalam satu persidangan DUN Kedah, sebelum pengistiharan Alor Star sebagai Bandaraya, beliau telah mengemukakan soalan tentang status cukai sama ada kekal atau dinaikkan selepas diistiharkan sebagai Bandaraya.
"Exco BN, Mohd. Basha Md. Haniffa menjawab kerajaan tidak akan menaikkan takrif cukai sekalipun bergelar Majlis Bandaraya selepas ini.
"Bashah yang disebut-sebut antara nama yang tersenarai dalam barisan MB baru Kedah ternyata bercakap tidak benar, itu sewaktu menjadi Exco, tak tahulah apa pula akan dibohongi kalau-kalau terpilih sebagai MB baru Kedah," jelas Taulan yang juga bekas Penasihat Undang-undang Majlis Perbandaran Alor Setar sebelum ini.- mks.
Tuesday, May 31, Harakahdaily
Oleh Helmi Khalid
ALOR STAR, 31 Mei 2005 (Hrkh) - Sekalipun mempunyai seorang Menteri Besar yang sakit, namun Kedah tetap berkeinginan tinggi untuk meneruskan agenda 'membalas jasa' di samping merompak duit rakyat yang mengundi Barisan Nasional (BN) dengan menghadiahkan kenaikan cukai tanah melebihi sekali ganda.
Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (Adun) PAS-Anak Bukit, Haji Amiruddin Hamzah berkata, inilah gara-gara mengistiharkan Alor Star sebagai Bandar raya pada 21 Disember 2003 lalu dengan hasil Majlis Bandaraya tersebut tidak seberapa dan sebaliknya duit rakyat terpaksa di'rompak' secara senyap. "Ia juga adalah ekoran beberapa projek mega di Kedah yang nyata tidak mendatangkan pulangan, sebagai bukti berbelas projek yang dijalankan oleh anak syarikat Perbadanan Kemajuan Negeri Kedah (PKNK) mengalami kerugian.
"Kedah Maju 2010, inilah hasil kerja sebuah kerajaan ke era negeri maju, 10 kali lebih maju dari wawasan 2020," tegas beliau.
Sambung beliau, pelaburan besar kerajaan BN Kedah untuk membangunkan Kulim High Tech Park (KHTP) nyata membawa padah kerana gagal menarik minat ramai pelabur luar malah ada syarikat yang gulung tikar dan mempunyai tunggakan bil-bil tertentu yang tinggi selain gagal membayar cukai tanah perniagaan mereka.
Di Gurun katanya, bagi tapak kilang kereta Naza Motor, kerajaan BN Kedah cukup bijak iaitu dengan membeli tanah dengan harga yang mahal dan menjual pada kadar yang terlalu murah kepada pihak Naza.
"Jelas sekali kerajaan BN Kedah telah mengalami kerugian untuk urus niaga dengan Naza itu sahaja, namun bekas Exco Kedah, Rosnah Majid menyatakan itu adalah cara terbaik untuk menarik minat pelabur datang melabur di Kedah.
Menurutnya premium cukai tanah di Kedah bakal dinaikkan tahun hadapan, dan jumlah kenaikan amat tinggi tidak lain tidak bukan sebagai menghargai jasa rakyat yang terus memberi mandat kepada BN di Kedah menerajui negeri ini.
Sementara untuk tanah kebun getah dan dusun pula, dari RM30 sehektar dinaikkan menjadi RM60 sehektar, bagi sawah padi kawasan MADA dinaikkan dari RM13 menjadi RM40 sehektar, untuk tanah kampung dinaikkan dari RM20 sehektar kepada RM80 sehektar.
Manakala cukai bagi kediaman (banglo) dari RM50 menjadi RM130 dan rumah teres dan kos rendah dari RM30 menjadi RM60.
Katanya lagi, jika diteliti, semua rakyat tidak akan terkecuali dari 'menerima' hadiah BN ini, sekaligus menunjukkan betapa prihatinnya BN Kedah sekarang ini, sekalipun tidak bermenteri besar, namun mempunyai jiwa yang besar untuk menindas rakyat.
Sementara itu, Bendahari PAS Kedah yang juga Adun (PAS-Tokai), Haji Mohd. Taulan Rasul berkata, keadaan ini amat malang sekali dan membuktikan BN Kedah sanggup menipu untuk mencapai status negeri maju.
Katanya, dalam satu persidangan DUN Kedah, sebelum pengistiharan Alor Star sebagai Bandaraya, beliau telah mengemukakan soalan tentang status cukai sama ada kekal atau dinaikkan selepas diistiharkan sebagai Bandaraya.
"Exco BN, Mohd. Basha Md. Haniffa menjawab kerajaan tidak akan menaikkan takrif cukai sekalipun bergelar Majlis Bandaraya selepas ini.
"Bashah yang disebut-sebut antara nama yang tersenarai dalam barisan MB baru Kedah ternyata bercakap tidak benar, itu sewaktu menjadi Exco, tak tahulah apa pula akan dibohongi kalau-kalau terpilih sebagai MB baru Kedah," jelas Taulan yang juga bekas Penasihat Undang-undang Majlis Perbandaran Alor Setar sebelum ini.- mks.
US Admits Koran Abuse at Guantanamo
US admits Koran abuse at Cuba base
Guantánamo probe uncovers 'mishandling' by troops
Josh White and Dan Eggen in Washington
Sunday June 5, 2005, The Observer
The US military confirmed yesterday that soldiers and interrogators at Guantánamo Bay did desecrate copies of the Koran. Brigadier General Jay Hood, who led an inquiry into the allegations, confirmed that there had been five cases of intentional or unintentional mishandling of the holy book. They included getting copies wet, standing on a Koran during an interrogation, and 'inadvertently' spraying urine on a copy.
But the Guantánamo commander said he found no evidence to support a further allegation that US personnel flushed a Koran down a toilet at the camp in Cuba. That claim, in a magazine article, led to anti-American riots in Afghanistan, Pakistan, India and Indonesia in which 16 people died and more than 100 were injured.
Hood's investigation into alleged incidents since the camp opened in January 2002 also found 15 cases of detainees desecrating their own Korans.
'Mishandling a Koran at Guantánamo Bay is a rare occurrence,' Hood said in a statement. 'Mishandling of a Koran here is never condoned. When one considers the many thousands of times detainees have been moved and cells have been searched since detention operations first began here in January 2002, I think one can only conclude that respect for detainee religious beliefs was embedded in the culture of [the task force] from the start.'
Detainees, human rights groups and some military personnel have complained about desecration of the Koran at Guantánamo Bay. Tom Wilner, an attorney for 11 Kuwaiti nationals being held at the prison, said the number and persistence of reports of Koran abuse from detainees indicate a much broader problem than indicated by the Hood inquiry.
'It's sort of amazing today that we define truth as only when the government confirms something happened,' Wilner said. 'I think there is no question that, especially in the early days of Guantánamo, there was a persistent pattern of physical abuse and religious
discrimination, including desecration of the Koran... But it hasn't been fully looked at.'
Hood's investigation was specifically looking at a report in Newsweek in May that a Koran had been flushed down a toilet at Guantánamo Bay. While denying the allegation - which was later retracted by the magazine - it did find that rumours of such an event were swirling around the camp in summer 2002.
The rumour began after a detainee dropped a copy on the floor and others blamed the mishandling on US guards. The story then changed in its retelling, until it related that soldiers had ripped pages out of the book and thrown it down a toilet. Hood's report, detailed in a US Southern Command news release, analysed several other reports of abuse of the Koran.
The first, in February 2002, arose when a detainee complained that guards at Guantánamo Bay had kicked a copy of the Koran in a neighbouring cell to his. Although the incident was noted at the time, there was no further investigation.
In another case, in August 2003, two detainees complained to guards that a number of Korans were wet because night-shift guards had thrown water balloons into their block. No further details of the incident were provided, but Hood's team determined that the complaints were 'credible'.
Other confirmed reports include a two-word obscenity being written on the inside cover of a Koran - although investigators suspected that the detainee who had complained may have defaced his own book.
Another report, in July 2003, detailed an incident in which a contract interrogator stood on a detainee's Koran. He was fired for 'unacceptable behaviour'.
The most recent, and perhaps strangest, case of mishandling was on 25 March, 2005, when a detainee complained to the guards that urine came through an air vent in his cell and 'splashed on him and his Koran'.
The report notes that the guard responsible reported himself to his superiors and was reassigned to different duties, while the detainee was given a new uniform and Koran.
'The guard had left his observation area post and went outside to urinate,' according to a summary of the incident. 'He urinated near an air vent and the wind blew his urine through the vent into the block.'
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005
Guantánamo probe uncovers 'mishandling' by troops
Josh White and Dan Eggen in Washington
Sunday June 5, 2005, The Observer
The US military confirmed yesterday that soldiers and interrogators at Guantánamo Bay did desecrate copies of the Koran. Brigadier General Jay Hood, who led an inquiry into the allegations, confirmed that there had been five cases of intentional or unintentional mishandling of the holy book. They included getting copies wet, standing on a Koran during an interrogation, and 'inadvertently' spraying urine on a copy.
But the Guantánamo commander said he found no evidence to support a further allegation that US personnel flushed a Koran down a toilet at the camp in Cuba. That claim, in a magazine article, led to anti-American riots in Afghanistan, Pakistan, India and Indonesia in which 16 people died and more than 100 were injured.
Hood's investigation into alleged incidents since the camp opened in January 2002 also found 15 cases of detainees desecrating their own Korans.
'Mishandling a Koran at Guantánamo Bay is a rare occurrence,' Hood said in a statement. 'Mishandling of a Koran here is never condoned. When one considers the many thousands of times detainees have been moved and cells have been searched since detention operations first began here in January 2002, I think one can only conclude that respect for detainee religious beliefs was embedded in the culture of [the task force] from the start.'
Detainees, human rights groups and some military personnel have complained about desecration of the Koran at Guantánamo Bay. Tom Wilner, an attorney for 11 Kuwaiti nationals being held at the prison, said the number and persistence of reports of Koran abuse from detainees indicate a much broader problem than indicated by the Hood inquiry.
'It's sort of amazing today that we define truth as only when the government confirms something happened,' Wilner said. 'I think there is no question that, especially in the early days of Guantánamo, there was a persistent pattern of physical abuse and religious
discrimination, including desecration of the Koran... But it hasn't been fully looked at.'
Hood's investigation was specifically looking at a report in Newsweek in May that a Koran had been flushed down a toilet at Guantánamo Bay. While denying the allegation - which was later retracted by the magazine - it did find that rumours of such an event were swirling around the camp in summer 2002.
The rumour began after a detainee dropped a copy on the floor and others blamed the mishandling on US guards. The story then changed in its retelling, until it related that soldiers had ripped pages out of the book and thrown it down a toilet. Hood's report, detailed in a US Southern Command news release, analysed several other reports of abuse of the Koran.
The first, in February 2002, arose when a detainee complained that guards at Guantánamo Bay had kicked a copy of the Koran in a neighbouring cell to his. Although the incident was noted at the time, there was no further investigation.
In another case, in August 2003, two detainees complained to guards that a number of Korans were wet because night-shift guards had thrown water balloons into their block. No further details of the incident were provided, but Hood's team determined that the complaints were 'credible'.
Other confirmed reports include a two-word obscenity being written on the inside cover of a Koran - although investigators suspected that the detainee who had complained may have defaced his own book.
Another report, in July 2003, detailed an incident in which a contract interrogator stood on a detainee's Koran. He was fired for 'unacceptable behaviour'.
The most recent, and perhaps strangest, case of mishandling was on 25 March, 2005, when a detainee complained to the guards that urine came through an air vent in his cell and 'splashed on him and his Koran'.
The report notes that the guard responsible reported himself to his superiors and was reassigned to different duties, while the detainee was given a new uniform and Koran.
'The guard had left his observation area post and went outside to urinate,' according to a summary of the incident. 'He urinated near an air vent and the wind blew his urine through the vent into the block.'
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005
[Malaysia] Open Up The Big Black Box of AP
Sin Chew Jit Pao
03 June 2005
Open Up The Big Black Box Of AP
If you are not that forgetful, perhaps you should remember that very instant when president Dr Mahathir suddenly announced his resignation prior to the close of 2002 UMNO General Assembly.
And that before Mahathir finished his announcement, Rafidah abruptly rushed to his side and pleaded sensationally, "You must not go...." The scene, which was carried live on TV screens across the country, was comparable to the touching scene on Titanic, where Rose told Jack, "You jump, I jump!"
The political allegiances between Mahathir and Rafidah did add a
touch of romance to the otherwise icy and hostile political picture.
But to the Westerners, even one day can be too long in politics, meaning major changes can take place within the span of one day, in politics. If even one day is considered too lengthy, it is therefore utterly possible for some unexpected turns and twists to emerge in the erstwhile warm relationship between Rafidah and her ex-mentor in more than two years' time.
In a very unusual manner, Mahathir recently held a press conference at his retirement home to refute allegations that he had not been doing his work to wipe out corruption, in a way that corruption has become so rampant today.
But an interesting development was that while defending himself, he made a sharp bend and mentioned the AP issuance. He proposed that identities of all AP awardees be made known to the public, including how many APs each of them had received from the authorities, how many cars had been imported with those APs, the prices of the cars, as well as the taxes paid.
AP (Approved Permits) is a teratism of the country's unique socio-economic modus operandi. Only AP holders are allowed to import completely built-up cars (CBUs). APs have been designed to allow bumiputras to venture into the country's automobile industry, and as such, only companies in excess of 70% bumimputra equity are eligible to receive APs.
As AP is a product not commensurate with market economics, it is therefore also shrouded in a veil of mystery. As long as you are able to get hold of the AP, even if you are not involved in automobile business, you can still trade it. As such, AP has also become a tradable commodity.
To possess AP therefore means possess wealth, and the issuer of this AP is none other than the ministry of international trade and industries which Rafidah has been heading for the past two decades.
How does the MITI assess AP qualifiers? And where have all the 60,000-odd APs issued annually gone?
These are not only the queries of the general public, but those of Mahathir as well. He put it squarely, "In order to remove the doubts, the authorities should reveal the names of AP holders, how many they have been given, and how many units they have imported."
Of course, there is a motive behind Mahathir's raising of this issue at this particular juncture.
In the past, APs were issued to allow the holders to import mainly luxurious sedans. However, the numbers of APs issued have soared in recent years, such that even modestly priced compact cars have been able to make inroads into the Malaysian markets by means of APs.
And at the forefront of such an impact is Proton, of which Mahathir is an advisor. Consequently, Mahathir's action can be best described as a lashback from the national car manufacturer.
If not for the former prime minister, probably hardly anyone would have the guts to raise such a sensitive issue. And Mahathir's queries have been obviously targeted at Rafidah.
Not to be defeated, Rafidah responded on the following day, blatantly refusing to announce the list of AP awardees. She said there was no precedent for the list to be made public, adding that no lists had been revealed even when Mahathir was the trade minister. As if that was not enough, she even accused Proton for having performed disappointingly.
The heads-on clash between Mahathir and Rafidah attests to the fact that political ties would never be able to rival real-life interests. On top of that, the clash has also exposed politico-economic ties and a clash of interests.
Although the existence of APs has been meant to help bumiputra businessmen, it has been manipulated to benefit the cronies of awardees. While "no precedent" has been cited for the refusal to announce the list, it is actually the refusal to allow any light to seep into the black box operation of AP. If the government is serious about keeping its operation transparent, it should open up this black box for public scrutiny.
Mahathir wants the list, and Malaysians want the truth.
03 June 2005
Open Up The Big Black Box Of AP
If you are not that forgetful, perhaps you should remember that very instant when president Dr Mahathir suddenly announced his resignation prior to the close of 2002 UMNO General Assembly.
And that before Mahathir finished his announcement, Rafidah abruptly rushed to his side and pleaded sensationally, "You must not go...." The scene, which was carried live on TV screens across the country, was comparable to the touching scene on Titanic, where Rose told Jack, "You jump, I jump!"
The political allegiances between Mahathir and Rafidah did add a
touch of romance to the otherwise icy and hostile political picture.
But to the Westerners, even one day can be too long in politics, meaning major changes can take place within the span of one day, in politics. If even one day is considered too lengthy, it is therefore utterly possible for some unexpected turns and twists to emerge in the erstwhile warm relationship between Rafidah and her ex-mentor in more than two years' time.
In a very unusual manner, Mahathir recently held a press conference at his retirement home to refute allegations that he had not been doing his work to wipe out corruption, in a way that corruption has become so rampant today.
But an interesting development was that while defending himself, he made a sharp bend and mentioned the AP issuance. He proposed that identities of all AP awardees be made known to the public, including how many APs each of them had received from the authorities, how many cars had been imported with those APs, the prices of the cars, as well as the taxes paid.
AP (Approved Permits) is a teratism of the country's unique socio-economic modus operandi. Only AP holders are allowed to import completely built-up cars (CBUs). APs have been designed to allow bumiputras to venture into the country's automobile industry, and as such, only companies in excess of 70% bumimputra equity are eligible to receive APs.
As AP is a product not commensurate with market economics, it is therefore also shrouded in a veil of mystery. As long as you are able to get hold of the AP, even if you are not involved in automobile business, you can still trade it. As such, AP has also become a tradable commodity.
To possess AP therefore means possess wealth, and the issuer of this AP is none other than the ministry of international trade and industries which Rafidah has been heading for the past two decades.
How does the MITI assess AP qualifiers? And where have all the 60,000-odd APs issued annually gone?
These are not only the queries of the general public, but those of Mahathir as well. He put it squarely, "In order to remove the doubts, the authorities should reveal the names of AP holders, how many they have been given, and how many units they have imported."
Of course, there is a motive behind Mahathir's raising of this issue at this particular juncture.
In the past, APs were issued to allow the holders to import mainly luxurious sedans. However, the numbers of APs issued have soared in recent years, such that even modestly priced compact cars have been able to make inroads into the Malaysian markets by means of APs.
And at the forefront of such an impact is Proton, of which Mahathir is an advisor. Consequently, Mahathir's action can be best described as a lashback from the national car manufacturer.
If not for the former prime minister, probably hardly anyone would have the guts to raise such a sensitive issue. And Mahathir's queries have been obviously targeted at Rafidah.
Not to be defeated, Rafidah responded on the following day, blatantly refusing to announce the list of AP awardees. She said there was no precedent for the list to be made public, adding that no lists had been revealed even when Mahathir was the trade minister. As if that was not enough, she even accused Proton for having performed disappointingly.
The heads-on clash between Mahathir and Rafidah attests to the fact that political ties would never be able to rival real-life interests. On top of that, the clash has also exposed politico-economic ties and a clash of interests.
Although the existence of APs has been meant to help bumiputra businessmen, it has been manipulated to benefit the cronies of awardees. While "no precedent" has been cited for the refusal to announce the list, it is actually the refusal to allow any light to seep into the black box operation of AP. If the government is serious about keeping its operation transparent, it should open up this black box for public scrutiny.
Mahathir wants the list, and Malaysians want the truth.
Thursday, June 02, 2005
Rakyat Are Not Burdened?
malaysiakini, 1 May 2005
Translation
LETTERS: Is it true that hikes "do not burden the rakyat"?
Original by Rozmal Malakan Jun 1, 05
We have been experiencing one price hike after another. To pacify the rakyat, a nice cliche is used - "Will not burden the rakyat".
Hike in toll rates - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in petrol price - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in diesel prices - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in water tariff - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in prices of goods - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in chicken price - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in bus and taxi fares - it will not burden the rakyat.
Every citizen is required to have health insurance - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in education fees - it will not burden the rakyat. Recently, I met an old friend who is working in the Student Affairs Department of one of the universities in Selangor. He was most saddened by what a majority of Malay students there are going through. Even after they have secured education loans and the money has been paid to the university, the universoty still has not made available adequate course facilities for students in the engineering field.
Such is the trying scenerio faced by all of us. But we will not pay attention to all of this as long as it did not involve us or our children directly.As one tsunami victim in Aceh said during an interview, we each lead our own lives, each looking out for our ownselves.
And we are soothed by a range of entertainment, concerts, music awards and Hitz music, until we forget to notice the fate of those around us.
Translation
LETTERS: Is it true that hikes "do not burden the rakyat"?
Original by Rozmal Malakan Jun 1, 05
We have been experiencing one price hike after another. To pacify the rakyat, a nice cliche is used - "Will not burden the rakyat".
Hike in toll rates - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in petrol price - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in diesel prices - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in water tariff - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in prices of goods - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in chicken price - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in bus and taxi fares - it will not burden the rakyat.
Every citizen is required to have health insurance - it will not burden the rakyat.
Hike in education fees - it will not burden the rakyat. Recently, I met an old friend who is working in the Student Affairs Department of one of the universities in Selangor. He was most saddened by what a majority of Malay students there are going through. Even after they have secured education loans and the money has been paid to the university, the universoty still has not made available adequate course facilities for students in the engineering field.
Such is the trying scenerio faced by all of us. But we will not pay attention to all of this as long as it did not involve us or our children directly.As one tsunami victim in Aceh said during an interview, we each lead our own lives, each looking out for our ownselves.
And we are soothed by a range of entertainment, concerts, music awards and Hitz music, until we forget to notice the fate of those around us.
Traditionalism Without the Extremism
The Atlantic Monthly, July/August 2005
The Show-Me Sheikh
The grand mufti of Egypt, Ali Gomaa, is peddling a new kind of radical Islam—traditionalism without the extremism
by G. Willow Wilson
In the night of December 30, 2004, the streets of downtown Cairo were unusually crowded. Government police officers, conspicuous in white gaiters, stood at attention outside a mosque, diverting traffic into a single congested lane. The police were on hand not to keep people out but to hem the mosque's occupants in. The speaker that evening was Mohammad Hassen, one of Cairo's most inflammatory sheikhs. President Hosni Mubarak's administration, anxious to allay fears of growing extremism after the October bombings in Sinai, was not taking any chances. Hassen and his followers had been known to advocate violence against Israel in the past.
That evening, however, the mood of the hard-line Islamic community was defensive, not aggressive. Earlier that day, in an appearance on Egyptian national television, Ali Gomaa, the grand mufti of Egypt and one of the highest-ranking clerics in the Sunni Muslim world, had denounced what the West refers to as fundamentalism. Although many Muslim leaders have stepped forward to condemn terrorist violence in recent years, no one before had even implicitly attacked the philosophy, often known as Wahhabism, that is thought to give rise to it—in no small part because Wahhabism is the official doctrine of Saudi Arabia, which controls the holy city of Mecca. But Gomaa did so, and went further: he referred to the extremists as khawerig, or "outsiders"—persons who fail to follow true Islamic law. Historically the term has been attached to the early Islamic dissidents who murdered Imam Ali, the son-in-law of the prophet Muhammad. In Arab Islamic society it is traditionally taboo to criticize the lifestyle or personal philosophy of any practicing Muslim. Never before had such a respected Islamic scholar and sheikh—much less the religious leader of the most populous Arab nation—laid bare the division between practicing fundamentalists and the rest of the Muslim umma, or religious community. In a region where extremist sheikhs have all but silenced their moderate rivals, this was a dangerous stance to take.
http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/prem/200507/wilson
The Show-Me Sheikh
The grand mufti of Egypt, Ali Gomaa, is peddling a new kind of radical Islam—traditionalism without the extremism
by G. Willow Wilson
In the night of December 30, 2004, the streets of downtown Cairo were unusually crowded. Government police officers, conspicuous in white gaiters, stood at attention outside a mosque, diverting traffic into a single congested lane. The police were on hand not to keep people out but to hem the mosque's occupants in. The speaker that evening was Mohammad Hassen, one of Cairo's most inflammatory sheikhs. President Hosni Mubarak's administration, anxious to allay fears of growing extremism after the October bombings in Sinai, was not taking any chances. Hassen and his followers had been known to advocate violence against Israel in the past.
That evening, however, the mood of the hard-line Islamic community was defensive, not aggressive. Earlier that day, in an appearance on Egyptian national television, Ali Gomaa, the grand mufti of Egypt and one of the highest-ranking clerics in the Sunni Muslim world, had denounced what the West refers to as fundamentalism. Although many Muslim leaders have stepped forward to condemn terrorist violence in recent years, no one before had even implicitly attacked the philosophy, often known as Wahhabism, that is thought to give rise to it—in no small part because Wahhabism is the official doctrine of Saudi Arabia, which controls the holy city of Mecca. But Gomaa did so, and went further: he referred to the extremists as khawerig, or "outsiders"—persons who fail to follow true Islamic law. Historically the term has been attached to the early Islamic dissidents who murdered Imam Ali, the son-in-law of the prophet Muhammad. In Arab Islamic society it is traditionally taboo to criticize the lifestyle or personal philosophy of any practicing Muslim. Never before had such a respected Islamic scholar and sheikh—much less the religious leader of the most populous Arab nation—laid bare the division between practicing fundamentalists and the rest of the Muslim umma, or religious community. In a region where extremist sheikhs have all but silenced their moderate rivals, this was a dangerous stance to take.
http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/prem/200507/wilson
Many Ways to Burden People
Another idea to burden the people
The Sun, 1 June 2005
It is a worrisome trend. A group of people write a project paper or working paper to be presented to the government. Almost immediately it is approved for implementation without any consultation whatsoever. The end-user is forced to absorb the price increase, while a few millionaires are created, aided and abetted by the system of political patronage.
What will they think of next? Holograms for soft drink bottles and cans and special ink for toilet paper rolls? There are perhaps scores out there who are thinking of innovative ideas to make money.
WHEN these words were penned for the No Punches Pulled column which appeared in theSun Weekend of April 23-24, little did this scribe realise that some parties were already hard at work preparing a project paper which would turn them into millionaires over a matter of months.
If the project paper is converted into policy and later law, a quarter of the people in Malaysia will have to fork out anything between RM30 and RM40 each to earn a living.
A paper has been submitted to the Domestic Trade and Consumer Affairs Ministry to compel all those involved in direct selling to carry special "chip-embedded" identification cards.
The cost of making these cards is about RM12, and you can calculate how much is going to be made by multiplying the margin by seven million - that's the number of people - full-time and part-time - in the direct selling business.
Why a chip-embedded card, when a simple card produced by the respective companies at a cost of a few sen each has been effectively used all these years?
The whole issue of compulsory identification cards for direct sellers was to help consumers identify persons who approach them with their products or services.
How does the consumer read the details in the chip without the proper equipment?
We all know that the country is going hi-tech with information technology and computerisation, but surely some thought must go into practicality and usefulness before plunging blindly into such exercises.
The only hope is that there will be right-thinking people at the ministry who can veto this proposal.
If not, I can picture this scenario: Chip-embedded ID cards for insurance agents, the Indah Water employees and perhaps even the neighbourhood grass-cutter who drops by your house monthly.
IT is indeed heartening to note that at least one person agrees with my views on the scandals of the Land Office.
Tan Sri Low Yow Chuan, top property developer and hotel magnate has echoed what I had espoused in my musings over the weekend.
Land grabbers are at work, aided and abetted by greedy politicians and crooked civil servants.
Land Offices have become hotbeds of illegal activities and millions are changing hands.
No piece of open land escapes the watchful eyes of the grabbers, their runners and their cronies.
Once a plot has been identified, the whole system is set in motion.
An application is made in the name of a proxy, amendments to local plans are done, and as an eyewash, the objections of the public are sought.
But do objections really matter when the powers-that-be have already identified the benefactors and have already reaped the rewards?
The paper work is done in secret and everything is self-classified as sulit or rahsia, and in a matter of days, land belonging to you is in the name of another.
When caught, there's always a convenient scapegoat called "It was an oversight."
Are those responsible for such oversights reprimanded? Of course not. Why should anyone want to kill the goose that lays the golden eggs?
He or she is not demoted or removed, perhaps to buy silence and loyalty and the whole thing is perpetuated in continuity.
TO the many readers who have written and e-mailed seeking solutions to their problems related to government departments, I have to say sorry. Many of you have also sent in voluminous documents to support your cases.
Unless there are extenuating circumstances, this writer does not even attempt problem solving.
May I suggest that you seek other avenues, including the Public Complaints Bureau to air your grouses or to vent your anger.
This column will continue to touch on bread and butter issues and remain a platform fighting for social justice and a better quality of life for all Malaysians.
The Sun, Kuala Lumpur, 30 May 2005
LETTERS: Legal issues concerning the use of holograms
The increasing concern from the pharmaceutical industry over the introduction of hologram stickers has raised some pertinent issues. I refer to two letters published in theSun -"Holograms will not prevent fakes" by Industry Insider and "Hologram effective anti-piracy tool" by Ian M. Lancaster of United Kingdom. There are some issues that have not
been properly highlighted which I wish to address:
If holograms were so effective, the global pharmaceutical industry, with a market size of US$0.3 trillion (US$1 = RM3.80), and major drug regulatory agencies would be using them. However, this is not the case.
The notion that the metal of blister packs can interfere with radio signals is inconceivable, as this is the same technology that powers the SmartTag system on highways and also used to identify shoplifters.
Furthermore, WalMart is now making all suppliers, including those using metal blisters, move to the new Radio Frequency Identification (RFiD)technology.
Indeed, the United States Food & Drug Administration (FDA), the largest drug regulating agency in the world, is working on RFiD mass serialisation of products likely to be counterfeited, as early as December.
Holograms which are much in use have not completely deterred counterfeits themselves. Indeed, they too can be faked. A good example would be that being used to curb the wave of piracy in VCD and DVD products. It is axiomatic to note that at present the battle against pirated VCD and DVD products is still uphill.
There are also concerns, as it is understood that the agreement with the Health Ministry ends in 2010, which will prevent Malaysians from enjoying developments in RFiD.
There is also much concern on issues pertaining to liability. Should a customer take a product that is found to be fake with a faked hologram to Mediharta (the supplier of the hologram) or the ministry?
R. Navaratnam
via e-mail
The Sun, 1 June 2005
It is a worrisome trend. A group of people write a project paper or working paper to be presented to the government. Almost immediately it is approved for implementation without any consultation whatsoever. The end-user is forced to absorb the price increase, while a few millionaires are created, aided and abetted by the system of political patronage.
What will they think of next? Holograms for soft drink bottles and cans and special ink for toilet paper rolls? There are perhaps scores out there who are thinking of innovative ideas to make money.
WHEN these words were penned for the No Punches Pulled column which appeared in theSun Weekend of April 23-24, little did this scribe realise that some parties were already hard at work preparing a project paper which would turn them into millionaires over a matter of months.
If the project paper is converted into policy and later law, a quarter of the people in Malaysia will have to fork out anything between RM30 and RM40 each to earn a living.
A paper has been submitted to the Domestic Trade and Consumer Affairs Ministry to compel all those involved in direct selling to carry special "chip-embedded" identification cards.
The cost of making these cards is about RM12, and you can calculate how much is going to be made by multiplying the margin by seven million - that's the number of people - full-time and part-time - in the direct selling business.
Why a chip-embedded card, when a simple card produced by the respective companies at a cost of a few sen each has been effectively used all these years?
The whole issue of compulsory identification cards for direct sellers was to help consumers identify persons who approach them with their products or services.
How does the consumer read the details in the chip without the proper equipment?
We all know that the country is going hi-tech with information technology and computerisation, but surely some thought must go into practicality and usefulness before plunging blindly into such exercises.
The only hope is that there will be right-thinking people at the ministry who can veto this proposal.
If not, I can picture this scenario: Chip-embedded ID cards for insurance agents, the Indah Water employees and perhaps even the neighbourhood grass-cutter who drops by your house monthly.
IT is indeed heartening to note that at least one person agrees with my views on the scandals of the Land Office.
Tan Sri Low Yow Chuan, top property developer and hotel magnate has echoed what I had espoused in my musings over the weekend.
Land grabbers are at work, aided and abetted by greedy politicians and crooked civil servants.
Land Offices have become hotbeds of illegal activities and millions are changing hands.
No piece of open land escapes the watchful eyes of the grabbers, their runners and their cronies.
Once a plot has been identified, the whole system is set in motion.
An application is made in the name of a proxy, amendments to local plans are done, and as an eyewash, the objections of the public are sought.
But do objections really matter when the powers-that-be have already identified the benefactors and have already reaped the rewards?
The paper work is done in secret and everything is self-classified as sulit or rahsia, and in a matter of days, land belonging to you is in the name of another.
When caught, there's always a convenient scapegoat called "It was an oversight."
Are those responsible for such oversights reprimanded? Of course not. Why should anyone want to kill the goose that lays the golden eggs?
He or she is not demoted or removed, perhaps to buy silence and loyalty and the whole thing is perpetuated in continuity.
TO the many readers who have written and e-mailed seeking solutions to their problems related to government departments, I have to say sorry. Many of you have also sent in voluminous documents to support your cases.
Unless there are extenuating circumstances, this writer does not even attempt problem solving.
May I suggest that you seek other avenues, including the Public Complaints Bureau to air your grouses or to vent your anger.
This column will continue to touch on bread and butter issues and remain a platform fighting for social justice and a better quality of life for all Malaysians.
The Sun, Kuala Lumpur, 30 May 2005
LETTERS: Legal issues concerning the use of holograms
The increasing concern from the pharmaceutical industry over the introduction of hologram stickers has raised some pertinent issues. I refer to two letters published in theSun -"Holograms will not prevent fakes" by Industry Insider and "Hologram effective anti-piracy tool" by Ian M. Lancaster of United Kingdom. There are some issues that have not
been properly highlighted which I wish to address:
If holograms were so effective, the global pharmaceutical industry, with a market size of US$0.3 trillion (US$1 = RM3.80), and major drug regulatory agencies would be using them. However, this is not the case.
The notion that the metal of blister packs can interfere with radio signals is inconceivable, as this is the same technology that powers the SmartTag system on highways and also used to identify shoplifters.
Furthermore, WalMart is now making all suppliers, including those using metal blisters, move to the new Radio Frequency Identification (RFiD)technology.
Indeed, the United States Food & Drug Administration (FDA), the largest drug regulating agency in the world, is working on RFiD mass serialisation of products likely to be counterfeited, as early as December.
Holograms which are much in use have not completely deterred counterfeits themselves. Indeed, they too can be faked. A good example would be that being used to curb the wave of piracy in VCD and DVD products. It is axiomatic to note that at present the battle against pirated VCD and DVD products is still uphill.
There are also concerns, as it is understood that the agreement with the Health Ministry ends in 2010, which will prevent Malaysians from enjoying developments in RFiD.
There is also much concern on issues pertaining to liability. Should a customer take a product that is found to be fake with a faked hologram to Mediharta (the supplier of the hologram) or the ministry?
R. Navaratnam
via e-mail
Back To Constitution
Sin Chew Jit Pao, Kuala Lumpur
01 June 2005
Back To Constitution
The Cabinet decision to stall the entertainment guidelines submitted by the Islamic Development Authority (JAKIM) is not only welcome, but also a step in the right direction.
Just as minister of culture, arts and heritage Rais Yatim has said, religious guidelines should only be confined to the realm of religion, and must never be applied to day-to-day living of ordinary Malaysians.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi reiterates that the government will not rule the country with a narrow religious mindset, while MPs from the ruling coalition and the opposition alike have also slammed the hudud laws introduced by PAS in Kelantan. Having said that, the entertainment guidelines have dealt a serious blow on the opponents of religious extremism.
In the face of the possible emergence of religious extremism, the government should be firm and not to allow aggressive ideologies to usurp the public's rights to religious freedom, and ensure that the relevant clauses provided under the country's Constitution be protected.
Of course, the federal Constitution states that although Islam is the country's official religion, Malaysians' rights to religious freedom are assured. Although the government has repeatedly stressed this, there are still individuals trying to cross over this threshold, attempting to restrict the religious freedom of Malaysians through all kinds of rules and regulations.
Given such people who are in gross disregard for the provisions and spirit of the federal Constitution, it is imperative that we reinforce in them former Chief Justice Tun Salleh's interpretation of the provisions of the Constitution with regards to the official religion and religious freedom: "Islamic laws, in the nation's history, have always been private or personal; and the Constitution has never empowered the Islamic laws to be extended to public sectors." Such a tradition in recognition of the distinction between private and public sectors in the country's legislature must be perpetuated so that our social structure would not be intimidated.
On top of that, Sections 12 and 13 of the Constitution also highlight that Malaysia's foundation of nation-building is on multiculturalism and religious freedom, and this social covenant of nation-building has made it very clear that politics should be segregated from religion. The Constitution Commission of the Malayan Federation clearly, and specifically, excluded religious ideologies from the Constitution, and this unique
feature, from Merdeka to now, and to the future, must never be swayed and altered.
Rais Yatim is one of the very few Cabinet ministers in this country with a law doctorate. His advice to the Islamic Development Authority not to go overboard and legislate guidelines beyond public acceptance and secular codes, should be seen as a proper way of interpreting the Constitution, and a clear manifestation of such a noble spirit. You should remember vividly that Rais slammed Kelantan's PAS state government for implementing the Islamic dress codes some time ago. Nevertheless, it is stunning to note that certain quarters within the ruling coalition itself is now after the same pursuit.
In view of this, some have repeatedly emphasised that any organisation or individual must never be in possession of the privilege of superseding the Constitution, while senior leadership and grassroots leaders alike must strive to erect such a constitutional spirit, and consciously administer within the bounds of the Constitution.
The Constitution is not merely a legal dossier which is placed in high places, it must also be seriously contemplated. Anyone with the intention can conduct street surveys to find out how many among the public know about the contents of the Constitution. I am afraid that the multitude have hardly any idea what the Constitution is all about.
Other than religion, the Constitution also touches on human rights, civil rights, the Cabinet, the Parliament, legislature, public services and elections. These provisions should not only be understood by lawyers and judges, but as a Malaysian citizen, your understanding of the Constitution should afford you a clearer understanding of your own rights. Your actions, affiliations, beliefs, educational rights etc are all protected under the Constitution, and no one can take them away from you.
When Rais was still in charge of the legal affairs department during his tenure as the minister in the prime minister's department, he proposed that federal Constitution be taught at schools, so that students could understand the most fundamental provisions of the Constitution since young.
This knowledge is now taught in General Papers in Form VI classes in government schools, but then not all students have the opportunity or choose to do Form VI. As a result, not everyone has the chance to learn this subject, unless the education ministry incorporates it into civic classes or sets up additional law classes.
It is now time for us to reconsider this proposal. Only through educating the young on how their forefathers built up this nation and how they strived to uphold the rule of law that our way forward would not be impeded by the demons of extremism, in a way that we continue to backslide on the road to full democratisation.
01 June 2005
Back To Constitution
The Cabinet decision to stall the entertainment guidelines submitted by the Islamic Development Authority (JAKIM) is not only welcome, but also a step in the right direction.
Just as minister of culture, arts and heritage Rais Yatim has said, religious guidelines should only be confined to the realm of religion, and must never be applied to day-to-day living of ordinary Malaysians.
Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi reiterates that the government will not rule the country with a narrow religious mindset, while MPs from the ruling coalition and the opposition alike have also slammed the hudud laws introduced by PAS in Kelantan. Having said that, the entertainment guidelines have dealt a serious blow on the opponents of religious extremism.
In the face of the possible emergence of religious extremism, the government should be firm and not to allow aggressive ideologies to usurp the public's rights to religious freedom, and ensure that the relevant clauses provided under the country's Constitution be protected.
Of course, the federal Constitution states that although Islam is the country's official religion, Malaysians' rights to religious freedom are assured. Although the government has repeatedly stressed this, there are still individuals trying to cross over this threshold, attempting to restrict the religious freedom of Malaysians through all kinds of rules and regulations.
Given such people who are in gross disregard for the provisions and spirit of the federal Constitution, it is imperative that we reinforce in them former Chief Justice Tun Salleh's interpretation of the provisions of the Constitution with regards to the official religion and religious freedom: "Islamic laws, in the nation's history, have always been private or personal; and the Constitution has never empowered the Islamic laws to be extended to public sectors." Such a tradition in recognition of the distinction between private and public sectors in the country's legislature must be perpetuated so that our social structure would not be intimidated.
On top of that, Sections 12 and 13 of the Constitution also highlight that Malaysia's foundation of nation-building is on multiculturalism and religious freedom, and this social covenant of nation-building has made it very clear that politics should be segregated from religion. The Constitution Commission of the Malayan Federation clearly, and specifically, excluded religious ideologies from the Constitution, and this unique
feature, from Merdeka to now, and to the future, must never be swayed and altered.
Rais Yatim is one of the very few Cabinet ministers in this country with a law doctorate. His advice to the Islamic Development Authority not to go overboard and legislate guidelines beyond public acceptance and secular codes, should be seen as a proper way of interpreting the Constitution, and a clear manifestation of such a noble spirit. You should remember vividly that Rais slammed Kelantan's PAS state government for implementing the Islamic dress codes some time ago. Nevertheless, it is stunning to note that certain quarters within the ruling coalition itself is now after the same pursuit.
In view of this, some have repeatedly emphasised that any organisation or individual must never be in possession of the privilege of superseding the Constitution, while senior leadership and grassroots leaders alike must strive to erect such a constitutional spirit, and consciously administer within the bounds of the Constitution.
The Constitution is not merely a legal dossier which is placed in high places, it must also be seriously contemplated. Anyone with the intention can conduct street surveys to find out how many among the public know about the contents of the Constitution. I am afraid that the multitude have hardly any idea what the Constitution is all about.
Other than religion, the Constitution also touches on human rights, civil rights, the Cabinet, the Parliament, legislature, public services and elections. These provisions should not only be understood by lawyers and judges, but as a Malaysian citizen, your understanding of the Constitution should afford you a clearer understanding of your own rights. Your actions, affiliations, beliefs, educational rights etc are all protected under the Constitution, and no one can take them away from you.
When Rais was still in charge of the legal affairs department during his tenure as the minister in the prime minister's department, he proposed that federal Constitution be taught at schools, so that students could understand the most fundamental provisions of the Constitution since young.
This knowledge is now taught in General Papers in Form VI classes in government schools, but then not all students have the opportunity or choose to do Form VI. As a result, not everyone has the chance to learn this subject, unless the education ministry incorporates it into civic classes or sets up additional law classes.
It is now time for us to reconsider this proposal. Only through educating the young on how their forefathers built up this nation and how they strived to uphold the rule of law that our way forward would not be impeded by the demons of extremism, in a way that we continue to backslide on the road to full democratisation.
PAS Facing Pressure to Change
Malaysia’s PAS facing pressure to change tack because of association
with Anwar Ibrahim
By Abdar Rahman Koya, June 2005
(Crescent International, London - http://www.muslimedia.com/my-paspress.htm)
The rise and fall of the Malaysian Islamic Party (PAS) seem to be tied to its arch-rival United Malay National Organisation (UMNO). Now that UMNO’s worst crisis is over with the end of the Anwar Ibrahim saga, all indications are that PAS is declining, with even party leaders becoming defensive when trying to answer accusations that the party has lost its direction.
If conversations with PAS supporters and feedback sent over the internet are any indication, this decline is real. PAS’s basis for existence – to establish an Islamic state in Malaysia – is under threat as it prepares to try to regain its support after the Anwar Ibrahim saga. The departure of both the Anwar saga and its chief player, Mahathir Mohamad, from the political limelight have put PAS back to where it used to be: on the fringe of the system, merely an opposition political party with its own set of leaders and views.
Now that Mahathir is gone, the question is what PAS can do to make its way back to mainstream politics. Right now there is not much sign that this will happen, except that its leaders are seen to be increasingly tying the party’s political destiny to Anwar Ibrahim, the man whom many political analysts will not discount just yet as a possible future prime minister, either through the opposition or through the ruling UMNO, the party which once ostracised him. Given the short memories in politics, either scenario is possible.
Anwar will have to be content with the opposition camp for the time being. Being on the other side of the fence after so long in the government is something he has been reluctant to do, believing that the opposition cannot come to power, at least in his lifetime. With little idea of what he should do, Anwar is postponing his immediate planning by paying more attention to topics such as “inter-civilizational dialogue” and preaching “democracy” and “freedom” in Muslim societies. Clearly his portrayal of a man concerned with global issues is overshadowed by his domestic ambitions, and many of his audience are more curious about his plans in Malaysia than about his new interest in “bridging the West-Islam divide”.
Like it or not, Anwar and the party he advises are now closely aligned with PAS, under what used to be known as the Alternative Front. This poses a lot of problems for him personally, especially because he feels he has to engage the world’s interest, for instance by meeting right-wing leaders from Washington and shady European think tanks, that would all like to groom him as a “moderate Muslim leader”. Anwar’s around-the-world trip to meet political leaders and his friends who occupy key posts in Washington and Europe had a twofold and win-win objective: his recruitment in the West’s effort to groom him as an agent of ‘change’ before he takes power; and to make the point that PAS is not a “fundamentalist” Islamic party, as Western leaders fear, but a liberal and democratic party which the West could “work with” should it come to power.
His ties with PAS are one of the hurdles he has to clear for the sake of his otherwise more than cordial relations with Western leaders. While Anwar might view them as a liability as he travels to Washington and Europe, where he can be “grilled” on his alliance with a fundamentalist, anti-Western party like PAS, in Malaysia he is perceived as being in the same camp as PAS because of its championing his cause during his six-year imprisonment, during which the party mobilised people to sympathise with him through its once-popular tabloid Harakah.
That was then; now things have changed. With the crisis largely gone from public memory, PAS is again left to fend for itself. After having tasted some sort of political power when it took control of two states and nearly formed state governments in two others, PAS lost heavily in elections last year. Now, with the People’s Justice Party (Keadilan, led by Anwar’s wife and sundry loyalists), PAS finds itself under increasing pressure to reformulate its agenda, even to repackaging its raison d’etre, the establishment of an Islamic state. Many regard PAS’s espousal of an Islamic state (especially during general elections) as the main reason that opposition parties could never be as united as the ruling coalition, and why the opposition alliance almost always collapses soon after elections. Non-Muslim politicians, secular Muslims and former UMNO strongmen, who are disgruntled with the current leadership, are now campaigning for PAS to change its stance on the aspiration for an Islamic state; in other words, to take the ballot-box more seriously. Some Keadilan leaders, including Anwar, have taken it on themselves to speak on behalf of PAS, trying to defend its Islamic state agenda, especially during interviews with the western media and in talks organised in the West, and at local gatherings attended by “moderate Muslims” and non-Muslims.
On May 10 Anwar Ibrahim was interviewed by the BBC in its Hardtalk programme. Anwar’s transformation from what is often called a “firebrand Islamic leader” to a “moderate Muslim” promoting “dialogue between Muslims and the West” was for the first time openly challenged. His relationship with the right-wing Bush administration (most notably with Paul Wolfowitz), and how he sells it to his supporters back home, were among the things he was questioned about. When asked whether he agrees with PAS’s struggle for an Islamic state, in a loaded question that implied that an Islamic state means denial of freedom to non-Muslims to practise their faith, Anwar’s answer only reinforced such perceptions: he said that PAS would work within a “constitutional guarantee” of freedom of religion to non-Muslims, as if there were no such guarantee in Islam.
While all this has been going on, the PAS leadership has been quiet. Many analysts and supporters have attributed this to a leadership vacuum, particularly since the death of Fadzil Noor, its previous president, in 2002, but there are other reasons: among them is PAS’s obsession with taking power from UMNO, which has ruled Malaysia since the country was created. At the peak of PAS’s popularity, mainly because of the public’s anger against Mahathir over his treatment of Anwar, the leadership of PAS was not an issue.
As the party’s internal elections draw near, in which members will elect their leaders, the divisions are laid bare not by their age differences but by the gap of political maturity. Those who have been nominated for top positions include young leaders whose jobs have only been important during elections because of their aggressive campaigning style. ‘Traditional’ leaders such as Abdul Hadi Awang and Nik Abdul Aziz excepted, many in PAS would agree that their leaders are not really in tune with the party’s political perspective. Hadi and Nik Aziz, like the late Fadzil Noor, have performed well as a unifying force and are able to engage government leaders in debate. The new breed of leaders, some of whom are called ulama because of their Arabic education, risk further pushing PAS into”repackaging” its agenda to appease “secular Muslims” who are reluctant to vote for it despite their opposition to UMNO.
Speculation is rife that a set of new “ulama” and “professionals”, who joined PAS because of their anger about Anwar’s mistreatment, are set to take over the party’s leadership; there is also talk of plans to work more closely with Anwar, or even to bring him into PAS’s ranks. How PAS will deal with Anwar’s patronage by shady figures in Washington and with the West’s political interest in him is partly answered by the fact that some leaders of PAS have begun to speak about ‘image’ (an obsession among some Muslims since September 2001), rather than PAS’s role as a movement that could put pressure on the government of a Muslim-majority state. Some PAS leaders are holding private talks with American and Australian diplomats, and there seems to be a suspicious absence of key leaders at anti-US demonstrations.
The pressure on PAS to give up its Islamic-state ambitions may or may not alter the political landscape of Malaysia, where the Islamic and racial cards have ensured that the ruling coalition stays in power despite the challenges of those who oppose it. The question is whether the current leaders and activists in PAS, as well as the incoming “new blood”, will be able to tackle these challenges from within the Islamic intellectual framework, rather than by crude politicking and empty arguments. The Islamic state cannot be taken off the agenda of any Islamic movement; what varies is methods and what form the Islamic state is expected to take. It would be wise for PAS to be wary of the pressure, and re-evaluate its aspirations not apologetically but with a view to laying the foundation for Islamic states to emerge within complex realities such as those that obtain in Malaysia.
In ‘democracies’ such as Malaysia, the number of parliamentary seats and crowd attendances at public talks can be used to gauge a party’s support. Although these are both at present very low for PAS, its leadership should realise that they cannot be used to gauge how far it has progressed with its real work. It is only its ability to move on a higher intellectual plain that might bring PAS back to a respectable place in the eyes of Muslims in Malaysia and around the world.
with Anwar Ibrahim
By Abdar Rahman Koya, June 2005
(Crescent International, London - http://www.muslimedia.com/my-paspress.htm)
The rise and fall of the Malaysian Islamic Party (PAS) seem to be tied to its arch-rival United Malay National Organisation (UMNO). Now that UMNO’s worst crisis is over with the end of the Anwar Ibrahim saga, all indications are that PAS is declining, with even party leaders becoming defensive when trying to answer accusations that the party has lost its direction.
If conversations with PAS supporters and feedback sent over the internet are any indication, this decline is real. PAS’s basis for existence – to establish an Islamic state in Malaysia – is under threat as it prepares to try to regain its support after the Anwar Ibrahim saga. The departure of both the Anwar saga and its chief player, Mahathir Mohamad, from the political limelight have put PAS back to where it used to be: on the fringe of the system, merely an opposition political party with its own set of leaders and views.
Now that Mahathir is gone, the question is what PAS can do to make its way back to mainstream politics. Right now there is not much sign that this will happen, except that its leaders are seen to be increasingly tying the party’s political destiny to Anwar Ibrahim, the man whom many political analysts will not discount just yet as a possible future prime minister, either through the opposition or through the ruling UMNO, the party which once ostracised him. Given the short memories in politics, either scenario is possible.
Anwar will have to be content with the opposition camp for the time being. Being on the other side of the fence after so long in the government is something he has been reluctant to do, believing that the opposition cannot come to power, at least in his lifetime. With little idea of what he should do, Anwar is postponing his immediate planning by paying more attention to topics such as “inter-civilizational dialogue” and preaching “democracy” and “freedom” in Muslim societies. Clearly his portrayal of a man concerned with global issues is overshadowed by his domestic ambitions, and many of his audience are more curious about his plans in Malaysia than about his new interest in “bridging the West-Islam divide”.
Like it or not, Anwar and the party he advises are now closely aligned with PAS, under what used to be known as the Alternative Front. This poses a lot of problems for him personally, especially because he feels he has to engage the world’s interest, for instance by meeting right-wing leaders from Washington and shady European think tanks, that would all like to groom him as a “moderate Muslim leader”. Anwar’s around-the-world trip to meet political leaders and his friends who occupy key posts in Washington and Europe had a twofold and win-win objective: his recruitment in the West’s effort to groom him as an agent of ‘change’ before he takes power; and to make the point that PAS is not a “fundamentalist” Islamic party, as Western leaders fear, but a liberal and democratic party which the West could “work with” should it come to power.
His ties with PAS are one of the hurdles he has to clear for the sake of his otherwise more than cordial relations with Western leaders. While Anwar might view them as a liability as he travels to Washington and Europe, where he can be “grilled” on his alliance with a fundamentalist, anti-Western party like PAS, in Malaysia he is perceived as being in the same camp as PAS because of its championing his cause during his six-year imprisonment, during which the party mobilised people to sympathise with him through its once-popular tabloid Harakah.
That was then; now things have changed. With the crisis largely gone from public memory, PAS is again left to fend for itself. After having tasted some sort of political power when it took control of two states and nearly formed state governments in two others, PAS lost heavily in elections last year. Now, with the People’s Justice Party (Keadilan, led by Anwar’s wife and sundry loyalists), PAS finds itself under increasing pressure to reformulate its agenda, even to repackaging its raison d’etre, the establishment of an Islamic state. Many regard PAS’s espousal of an Islamic state (especially during general elections) as the main reason that opposition parties could never be as united as the ruling coalition, and why the opposition alliance almost always collapses soon after elections. Non-Muslim politicians, secular Muslims and former UMNO strongmen, who are disgruntled with the current leadership, are now campaigning for PAS to change its stance on the aspiration for an Islamic state; in other words, to take the ballot-box more seriously. Some Keadilan leaders, including Anwar, have taken it on themselves to speak on behalf of PAS, trying to defend its Islamic state agenda, especially during interviews with the western media and in talks organised in the West, and at local gatherings attended by “moderate Muslims” and non-Muslims.
On May 10 Anwar Ibrahim was interviewed by the BBC in its Hardtalk programme. Anwar’s transformation from what is often called a “firebrand Islamic leader” to a “moderate Muslim” promoting “dialogue between Muslims and the West” was for the first time openly challenged. His relationship with the right-wing Bush administration (most notably with Paul Wolfowitz), and how he sells it to his supporters back home, were among the things he was questioned about. When asked whether he agrees with PAS’s struggle for an Islamic state, in a loaded question that implied that an Islamic state means denial of freedom to non-Muslims to practise their faith, Anwar’s answer only reinforced such perceptions: he said that PAS would work within a “constitutional guarantee” of freedom of religion to non-Muslims, as if there were no such guarantee in Islam.
While all this has been going on, the PAS leadership has been quiet. Many analysts and supporters have attributed this to a leadership vacuum, particularly since the death of Fadzil Noor, its previous president, in 2002, but there are other reasons: among them is PAS’s obsession with taking power from UMNO, which has ruled Malaysia since the country was created. At the peak of PAS’s popularity, mainly because of the public’s anger against Mahathir over his treatment of Anwar, the leadership of PAS was not an issue.
As the party’s internal elections draw near, in which members will elect their leaders, the divisions are laid bare not by their age differences but by the gap of political maturity. Those who have been nominated for top positions include young leaders whose jobs have only been important during elections because of their aggressive campaigning style. ‘Traditional’ leaders such as Abdul Hadi Awang and Nik Abdul Aziz excepted, many in PAS would agree that their leaders are not really in tune with the party’s political perspective. Hadi and Nik Aziz, like the late Fadzil Noor, have performed well as a unifying force and are able to engage government leaders in debate. The new breed of leaders, some of whom are called ulama because of their Arabic education, risk further pushing PAS into”repackaging” its agenda to appease “secular Muslims” who are reluctant to vote for it despite their opposition to UMNO.
Speculation is rife that a set of new “ulama” and “professionals”, who joined PAS because of their anger about Anwar’s mistreatment, are set to take over the party’s leadership; there is also talk of plans to work more closely with Anwar, or even to bring him into PAS’s ranks. How PAS will deal with Anwar’s patronage by shady figures in Washington and with the West’s political interest in him is partly answered by the fact that some leaders of PAS have begun to speak about ‘image’ (an obsession among some Muslims since September 2001), rather than PAS’s role as a movement that could put pressure on the government of a Muslim-majority state. Some PAS leaders are holding private talks with American and Australian diplomats, and there seems to be a suspicious absence of key leaders at anti-US demonstrations.
The pressure on PAS to give up its Islamic-state ambitions may or may not alter the political landscape of Malaysia, where the Islamic and racial cards have ensured that the ruling coalition stays in power despite the challenges of those who oppose it. The question is whether the current leaders and activists in PAS, as well as the incoming “new blood”, will be able to tackle these challenges from within the Islamic intellectual framework, rather than by crude politicking and empty arguments. The Islamic state cannot be taken off the agenda of any Islamic movement; what varies is methods and what form the Islamic state is expected to take. It would be wise for PAS to be wary of the pressure, and re-evaluate its aspirations not apologetically but with a view to laying the foundation for Islamic states to emerge within complex realities such as those that obtain in Malaysia.
In ‘democracies’ such as Malaysia, the number of parliamentary seats and crowd attendances at public talks can be used to gauge a party’s support. Although these are both at present very low for PAS, its leadership should realise that they cannot be used to gauge how far it has progressed with its real work. It is only its ability to move on a higher intellectual plain that might bring PAS back to a respectable place in the eyes of Muslims in Malaysia and around the world.
Wednesday, June 01, 2005
Dr M: I Spoke Against Corruption!
Dr M: "I spoke out against corruption"
The Sun, Kuala Lumpur
31 May 2005
Excerpts of Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad's press conference on Monday (30 May), which he called specifically to reply to criticism in a Sunday newspaper column which said he could have done more to fight corruption during his 22 years as prime minister.
Q: Who is the one trying to shut you up?
A: The report (in the Sunday Star) made it out, more or less, trying to tell me, what did I do? These things do not happen overnight, it takes years to build. What did I do? If you ask what I did, I did a lot of things.
I appealed to Umno, I even stopped elections in Umno to curb the habit. Malays have got more money now and they are using it wrongly. I know people who finance certain people.
I know during the recent election, a group of delegates were offered RM50,000 for a vote, openly. Everybody knew about it. The thing (is) it's getting worse and worse. During my time, I criticised, you people (reporters) know, how many times I had spoken out against corruption.
Q: Are you trying to say while you appealed to Umno, in the government machinery you also did the same?
A: I appealed to everybody because I know it's difficult to prove and get evidence on corruption. Because the person involved will never tell. He will tell you, but if I tell him to appear in court ... no way. He said "my business will be destroyed, these people will take action against me". They are afraid. It is very difficult to prove corruption.
Q: Can you indicate who is trying to shut you up?
A: Well ... the way it is reported ... (asking) me "what did you do when you were the prime minister?" So, if I comment on anything, he can go back (and) say what did you do when you were the prime minister. If you don't want my comment, don't ask me any questions. I didn't ask that you should come and see me. They wanted to come and see me. So, if you want to come and see me and ask for my opinion, I give my opinion lah ...
I have always maintained that you can't fight against corruption if it has become part of the culture. I am talking about that. I am not talking (about) government action. Government has limited capacity. Kalau boleh ... government action ... you know in China they shoot people to death if you are corrupt and still there is corruption. Because it is a culture, not the punishment. Same with drugs, we pass the death sentence but they still smuggle drugs.
Q: Umno vice-president Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin proposes allowing grassroots members to elect Umno Supreme Council members. Don't you think this would involve more money politics? I know money politics also involves people at the branch level and many are
prepared to pay to win to become branch leaders. Sometimes, it does not involve money and other times they get things like computers, jerseys and calculators and they said they are just helping.
A: My suggestion is if you want to give to the members, give it to Umno headquarters and let them distribute to whoever deserves it but this did not happen. They want to be seen giving things to people to get publicity. From there everybody wants to become elected as delegates to the general assembly.
They like to become wakil because they have the chance of making money. Before it was not like this ... this is a new erosion, I remember before, you don't even have to campaign. I didn't go around campaigning, except during Anwar's time, we used to bring people to my house to give a speech.
Q: Do you agree that the cost of doing business goes up if corruption is involved?
A: Of course ... corruption is bad and I tried to explain that. It will destroy the whole country. It will make everything expensive and retard development. Already (there's) no development. You can see countries which are corrupt can't develop at all.
Q: What do you think of the level of corruption in Umno now?
A: There is slow erosion and corruption is now worse than before. Umno members are now talking more about this than debating on important issues like the party president's speech.
Q: Were you satisfied with what you had to do to fight corruption?
A: Yes ... ACA will take action only if they really have a proven case and they will not take any case to court if they don't have any water-tight case. What I tried to do in Umno was to tell them don't get involved in buying votes and things like that.
To a certain extent l knew that somebody who was paying money lost in the election because I told them to reject anybody who paid money. Nowadays, they come out openly and say, 'you pay me money l will vote for you'. The attitude is different now.
Q: Was money politics worse before?
A: Now it's worse. After the Umno general assembly, that is what they talked about. They never talked about the party president's speech. These people gave this much, that person gave that much. When complaints were made against the accusers, they retaliated, saying they were not involved.
Q: How about the awarding of closed tenders during your administration?
A: It was agreed that if it was an open tender, bumiputra contractors will not get any. But we didn't give to the same person all the time. We gave to people who were capable as, sometimes, the capital needed was very high. If you need one billion (ringgit) as capital, how many bumiputra contractors have one billion (ringgit) capital? It's not given to one person ... it's given to a whole lot and you can go and check on it.
The government used to give to Class-F bumiputra contractors computer lab projects and when we gave to everybody without experience, everything collapsed ... you had to choose.
Now it's a choice between bumiputras and bumiputras with the open tender, bumiputras will compete with bumiputras. It's good ... now we don't have to go through negotiated tender.
Dr M: My legacy will speak for me
The Star, Kuala Lumpur
Tuesday May 31, 2005
KUALA LUMPUR: The most important thing in the fight against corruption is to ensure that a culture of viewing the practice as normal and acceptable does not develop, Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad said.
"For me, this is a question of inculcating noble values, not about catching people," the former prime minister said.
He said this at a press conference at his residence here in response to a column in the Sunday Star by The Star's deputy group chief editor II Datuk Wong Chun Wai.
In the article entitled Pile on pressure against the corrupt, Wong said: "It is good that Dr Mahathir had come out strongly against corruption but personally I wished that he could have done more during his 20 over years in office."
Wong added that despite his strong leadership, authority and grip on Umno, Dr Mahathir had let slip the opportunity to introduce reforms, including effective enforcement of laws against corruption.
While remaining grateful to Dr Mahathir for the economic boom, Wong said one source of unhappiness was the introduction of the negotiated tender that lacked accountability and openness, which was like not having a tender at all.
Expressing his disappointment over Wong's column, Dr Mahathir said it seemed to suggest that "I did not do anything about corruption when I was Prime Minister."
"You can look at my record. There were wakil rakyat and exco members who were caught and punished.
"I did a lot, but I didn't want to talk about it.
"I took all kinds of action, but there is no need for me to tell you what they were," he said.
He added that he had even cried, prayed and even stopped elections when dealing with the issue.
However, he said his stress was on building a culture where corruption was not tolerated at all.
"People must reject corruption, because it is not correct. You do not steal because it is wrong, not because there is a policeman trailing you, waiting to catch you," he said.
Dr Mahathir said his fight against corruption was also hampered by the difficulty in proving that such acts had taken place, both in Umno and in the Government.
"Unless somebody comes up to give evidence, corruption cannot be proven. It is very difficult because everybody will deny that they had done it," he said.
Dr Mahathir added that corruption seemed to have become more rampant.
"After the last Umno assembly, all that people talked about was money politics. There was no discussion on points raised in the president's speech or other issues," he said.
Dr Mahathir suggested that Wong's article could be one way of stopping him from talking on corruption following his speech on the subject at the Perdana Leadership Foundation discourse on Social Reengineering last month.
During the function, when replying to a question from the floor, Dr Mahathir said people were no longer hiding the fact that they were corrupt.
Voicing his fear that corruption might become institutionalised, he called on the Government and political parties to be more serious in tackling the problem.
On negotiated tenders, Dr Mahathir said that under the open tender system, bumiputra contractors would never have been able to get jobs.
"However, we didn't give all contracts to the same person. We gave to people who were capable and who had delivered," he said.
Nevertheless, he said, it was good that there would now be open tenders.
The Sun, Kuala Lumpur
31 May 2005
Excerpts of Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad's press conference on Monday (30 May), which he called specifically to reply to criticism in a Sunday newspaper column which said he could have done more to fight corruption during his 22 years as prime minister.
Q: Who is the one trying to shut you up?
A: The report (in the Sunday Star) made it out, more or less, trying to tell me, what did I do? These things do not happen overnight, it takes years to build. What did I do? If you ask what I did, I did a lot of things.
I appealed to Umno, I even stopped elections in Umno to curb the habit. Malays have got more money now and they are using it wrongly. I know people who finance certain people.
I know during the recent election, a group of delegates were offered RM50,000 for a vote, openly. Everybody knew about it. The thing (is) it's getting worse and worse. During my time, I criticised, you people (reporters) know, how many times I had spoken out against corruption.
Q: Are you trying to say while you appealed to Umno, in the government machinery you also did the same?
A: I appealed to everybody because I know it's difficult to prove and get evidence on corruption. Because the person involved will never tell. He will tell you, but if I tell him to appear in court ... no way. He said "my business will be destroyed, these people will take action against me". They are afraid. It is very difficult to prove corruption.
Q: Can you indicate who is trying to shut you up?
A: Well ... the way it is reported ... (asking) me "what did you do when you were the prime minister?" So, if I comment on anything, he can go back (and) say what did you do when you were the prime minister. If you don't want my comment, don't ask me any questions. I didn't ask that you should come and see me. They wanted to come and see me. So, if you want to come and see me and ask for my opinion, I give my opinion lah ...
I have always maintained that you can't fight against corruption if it has become part of the culture. I am talking about that. I am not talking (about) government action. Government has limited capacity. Kalau boleh ... government action ... you know in China they shoot people to death if you are corrupt and still there is corruption. Because it is a culture, not the punishment. Same with drugs, we pass the death sentence but they still smuggle drugs.
Q: Umno vice-president Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin proposes allowing grassroots members to elect Umno Supreme Council members. Don't you think this would involve more money politics? I know money politics also involves people at the branch level and many are
prepared to pay to win to become branch leaders. Sometimes, it does not involve money and other times they get things like computers, jerseys and calculators and they said they are just helping.
A: My suggestion is if you want to give to the members, give it to Umno headquarters and let them distribute to whoever deserves it but this did not happen. They want to be seen giving things to people to get publicity. From there everybody wants to become elected as delegates to the general assembly.
They like to become wakil because they have the chance of making money. Before it was not like this ... this is a new erosion, I remember before, you don't even have to campaign. I didn't go around campaigning, except during Anwar's time, we used to bring people to my house to give a speech.
Q: Do you agree that the cost of doing business goes up if corruption is involved?
A: Of course ... corruption is bad and I tried to explain that. It will destroy the whole country. It will make everything expensive and retard development. Already (there's) no development. You can see countries which are corrupt can't develop at all.
Q: What do you think of the level of corruption in Umno now?
A: There is slow erosion and corruption is now worse than before. Umno members are now talking more about this than debating on important issues like the party president's speech.
Q: Were you satisfied with what you had to do to fight corruption?
A: Yes ... ACA will take action only if they really have a proven case and they will not take any case to court if they don't have any water-tight case. What I tried to do in Umno was to tell them don't get involved in buying votes and things like that.
To a certain extent l knew that somebody who was paying money lost in the election because I told them to reject anybody who paid money. Nowadays, they come out openly and say, 'you pay me money l will vote for you'. The attitude is different now.
Q: Was money politics worse before?
A: Now it's worse. After the Umno general assembly, that is what they talked about. They never talked about the party president's speech. These people gave this much, that person gave that much. When complaints were made against the accusers, they retaliated, saying they were not involved.
Q: How about the awarding of closed tenders during your administration?
A: It was agreed that if it was an open tender, bumiputra contractors will not get any. But we didn't give to the same person all the time. We gave to people who were capable as, sometimes, the capital needed was very high. If you need one billion (ringgit) as capital, how many bumiputra contractors have one billion (ringgit) capital? It's not given to one person ... it's given to a whole lot and you can go and check on it.
The government used to give to Class-F bumiputra contractors computer lab projects and when we gave to everybody without experience, everything collapsed ... you had to choose.
Now it's a choice between bumiputras and bumiputras with the open tender, bumiputras will compete with bumiputras. It's good ... now we don't have to go through negotiated tender.
Dr M: My legacy will speak for me
The Star, Kuala Lumpur
Tuesday May 31, 2005
KUALA LUMPUR: The most important thing in the fight against corruption is to ensure that a culture of viewing the practice as normal and acceptable does not develop, Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad said.
"For me, this is a question of inculcating noble values, not about catching people," the former prime minister said.
He said this at a press conference at his residence here in response to a column in the Sunday Star by The Star's deputy group chief editor II Datuk Wong Chun Wai.
In the article entitled Pile on pressure against the corrupt, Wong said: "It is good that Dr Mahathir had come out strongly against corruption but personally I wished that he could have done more during his 20 over years in office."
Wong added that despite his strong leadership, authority and grip on Umno, Dr Mahathir had let slip the opportunity to introduce reforms, including effective enforcement of laws against corruption.
While remaining grateful to Dr Mahathir for the economic boom, Wong said one source of unhappiness was the introduction of the negotiated tender that lacked accountability and openness, which was like not having a tender at all.
Expressing his disappointment over Wong's column, Dr Mahathir said it seemed to suggest that "I did not do anything about corruption when I was Prime Minister."
"You can look at my record. There were wakil rakyat and exco members who were caught and punished.
"I did a lot, but I didn't want to talk about it.
"I took all kinds of action, but there is no need for me to tell you what they were," he said.
He added that he had even cried, prayed and even stopped elections when dealing with the issue.
However, he said his stress was on building a culture where corruption was not tolerated at all.
"People must reject corruption, because it is not correct. You do not steal because it is wrong, not because there is a policeman trailing you, waiting to catch you," he said.
Dr Mahathir said his fight against corruption was also hampered by the difficulty in proving that such acts had taken place, both in Umno and in the Government.
"Unless somebody comes up to give evidence, corruption cannot be proven. It is very difficult because everybody will deny that they had done it," he said.
Dr Mahathir added that corruption seemed to have become more rampant.
"After the last Umno assembly, all that people talked about was money politics. There was no discussion on points raised in the president's speech or other issues," he said.
Dr Mahathir suggested that Wong's article could be one way of stopping him from talking on corruption following his speech on the subject at the Perdana Leadership Foundation discourse on Social Reengineering last month.
During the function, when replying to a question from the floor, Dr Mahathir said people were no longer hiding the fact that they were corrupt.
Voicing his fear that corruption might become institutionalised, he called on the Government and political parties to be more serious in tackling the problem.
On negotiated tenders, Dr Mahathir said that under the open tender system, bumiputra contractors would never have been able to get jobs.
"However, we didn't give all contracts to the same person. We gave to people who were capable and who had delivered," he said.
Nevertheless, he said, it was good that there would now be open tenders.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)