by Michael Rubin
New York Daily News
January 3, 2007
http://www.meforum.org/article/1071
In Iran, demonstrations are an art form. First, the government buses in
state workers. Next, officials distribute banners with revolutionary
slogans. Finally, state television reports a spontaneous rally in support
of the Islamic Republic.
Stage-managed demonstrations, though, mask weakness. On Dec. 11, a group
of students interrupted a speech by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad
with chants of "Death to the Dictator." On Jan. 2, a demonstrator in Ahvaz
waved a placard condemning inflation, unemployment and crime. Recent
elections rebuked hardliners.
And unfortunately, rather than find a way to capitalize on such weakness,
up to now, a desire for diplomacy has blinded the West. Between 2000 and
2005, European diplomats preaching engagement tripled trade with Iran.
Tehran pumped 70% of the resulting hard currency windfall into its
nuclear and military programs. After Secretary of State Rice offered
dialogue with Iran, the regime announced it would redouble its nuclear
efforts. Ahmadinejad said yesterday he would "humiliate" the United
States.
European diplomats declare their strategy to be working, but privately say
a nuclear Iran is inevitable. Last month's partial UN sanctions are only
symbolic. Effectiveness requires comprehensive sanctions - which
diplomats could lift in response to compliance.
But the UN is feckless. If President Bush is sincere when he says the U.S.
"will not tolerate" a nuclear-armed Iran, Washington may have to act
alone. This need not mean military action, but rather willingness to
exploit Iranian weakness.
The Islamic Republic is under tremendous pressure. A recent Johns Hopkins
University report predicts Iran's oil industry could collapse within a
decade because of poor management and disintegrating infrastructure.
Already, the Islamic Republic must import 40% of its fuel needs. The
Iranian economy is unable to provide jobs for 700,000 young people
entering the market annually. The World Bank estimates that Iran's GDP is
30% below its 1970s levels. Experts estimate 5 million Iranians are
addicted to drugs. Prostitution has skyrocketed as poverty spreads.
The White House should exploit the growing cracks in Iranian society. Just
as Ronald Reagan championed striking shipyard workers in Poland in 1981,
so too should Bush support independent Iranian trade unions. Forcing the
regime to be accountable to its people both betters the lives of ordinary
Iranians and undercuts Ahmadinejad's Dr. Strangelove fantasies. In Iran,
wildcat strikes helped launch the Islamic Revolution; so too might they
end it.
It is wrongheaded to criticize Bush's Axis of Evil rhetoric. Not only does
straight talk dampen European willingness to invest in Iranian industry,
but the willingness of Iranian democrats to speak out has grown in
proportion to all the White House talk about freedom. Peace activists
should applaud such effective, nonmilitary action.
Finally, U.S. public diplomacy should prioritize information over pop
music. The Iranian regime would be hard-pressed to dismiss as propaganda
stories of unrest and corruption originating in local Iranian papers and
amplified by the Voice of America into national news.
Military action against Iran would be a tragedy, but need only occur if
U.S. policy remains a muddle. Here the White House and new Congress are
fortunate. If they play their cards well, this year could be
Ahmadinejad's last.
----------------------------------------------------------------
This e-mail has been sent via JARING webmail at http://www.jaring.my
No comments:
Post a Comment