Wednesday, May 25, 2005

Corruption – a Sign of the Community’s Fall

Corruption – a Sign of the Community’s Fall

The survival of the community depends upon the existence of a cluster or group of people who are committed in the struggle for reform and persevere in fighting corruption (fasad).When there is no more resistance then the end of a nation is near at hand. The decline of a civilization or the fall of a nation does not happen in a blink or in a moment. It starts with a deep malaise becoming cancerous until in the end it brings about death. For every community as for every individual comes its appointed time.

Causes of Decline

The decline of a civilization does not necessarily mean extinction and complete obliteration. It may happen to be an internal decay: loss of credibility, loss of nerve, loss of strength, honour and respect. It may be in the form of a loss of identity, dilution of character and personality, thereby converting the nation into something else or into another alien civilization. The process reaches its finale with the loss of spirit, will and resistance, falls into alien domination until its existence has no meaning or concern. This internal cause is described in surah al anfal: 53:-

"Because Allah will never change the Grace which he hath bestowed on a people until they change what is in their (own) souls: and verily Allah is He who heareth and knoweth (all things)."

This verse (ayah) concerns Sunnatullah – God’s Law in history – on the decline of a nation that originates from a change in character (taghyir al nufus) – an internal transformation, digression and corruption of the mind and self. This fall in character or self corruption is an internal disorder that brings about loss of grace, loss of peace, prosperity, dignity and social wellbeing. The most serious form of corruption of soul and mind is fasad al aqidah – the spoiling, the defiling of the foundation of belief and faith – especially by committing shirk – associating others with God, advocating something other than God and even regarding leaders as demigods.

Tawhid in its purity has liberative implications, giving complete freedom to the hearts and minds of people. However, when the heart and mind is corrupted by advocating other human beings, desires and various other forms of falsehood (taghut), mankind loses its freedom, becoming enslaved like the parable of ‘the cattle with a pinned nose’. Man without freedom has essentially lost his main character of humanity. This phenomenon has been attested to by the early reformers with the idea to empower man by rehabilitating his freedom of thought. To free man from all forms and obstacles which prevents his wishes and to free man from inhibitions to his thoughts.

Corruption of faith causes amnesia, forgetfulness, man becomes arrogant, proud, tyrannical, oppressive, brutal and a transgressor unleashed. This is seen when man puts his desire as his idol. From fasad al nufus (self corruption) it extends into fasad al mujtama’ (social corruption). Relations between men are broken; there is a loss of mutual respect, brotherhood, altruism, togetherness and cooperation. On the other hand, mutual hatred, self interest and eternal enmity becomes the norm. This happens when man transforms by disregarding aqidah (purity of faith) and throws away natural noble human traits. Men are derailed from the limits of humanity, some becoming like demigods while others are weak slaves to be exploited and manipulated. The phenomenon of Pharaoh is the manifestation of corruption of the hearts and minds to become arrogant, tyrannical, rampantly oppressive, enslaving, brutalizing and mistreating the weak, the Children of Israel. The Children of Israel manifests the loss of human dignity, self respect, loss of nerve and fighting spirit until they accept as perfectly natural the state of slavery generation after generation sheepishly. This phenomenon of corruption repeats itself throughout history. The message is in surah al rad: 11:-

"For each (such person) there are (angels) in succession. Before and behind him: they guard him by command of Allah. Verily never will Allah change the condition of a people until they change it themselves (with their own souls). But when (once) Allah willeth a people’s punishment, there can be no turning back, nor will they find, besides Him, any to protect."

Al marhum Abdullah Yusuf Ali in his commentary of the verse mentions: “It is only when he has made his own sight blind and changed his own nature or soul away from the beautiful mould in which Allah formed it, that Allah’s wrath will descend on him and the favourable position in which Allah placed him will be changed. When once the punishment comes, there is no turning back. None of the things which he relied upon other than Allah can possibly protect him.” Thus, man shall forever be regarded and treated according to their state and their qualities, the way they deserve, whether they be lions or sheep.

Sunnatullah: Cause and Effect

It is obvious that what happens to a nation is not accidental but has reasons and causes for it. The Qur’an always tells of the causes and effects especially the internal reasons. Failure to be wary of fasad al nufus (corruption of the self) causes the nation to be weak and brittle. Many civilizations rot and collapse from the inside with little disturbance from the outside. To be wary and guardful of the causes of destruction needs meticulous and conscious work and tireless efforts. There has to be concern, concerted effort and action towards fighting all forms of corruption (fasad) even those considered ‘small’, ‘light’, ‘minor’, ‘minute’ or ‘insignificant’ evil. Man due to his smug and arrogance, usually likes to disregard, push aside or belittle such ‘minor fasad’ , issues which are really big and of utmost importance. This is highlighted in the surah al nur: 15:-

"Behold, ye received it on your tongues and said out of your mouths things of which ye had no knowledge; and ye thought it to be a light matter, while it was most serious in the sight of Allah."

The verse condemns and warns of the false and slanderous news concerning an alleged scandal which maliciously attacks the sanctity of the Prophet’s s.a.w. family and household as well as threatening the fledgling first Muslim community. To a community of liars, scoundrels and slanderers, such an event is considered small and even as a passing sensation. But, to Allah s.w.t. and the Islamic community, it is a grave and serious affair because it stains and dishonours the dignity of a known and noble person. Honour and dignity are cherished and are priceless values. This is why they are guaranteed and protected by the shari’ah. When society belittles and tramples over honour and decency, hence slander, false accusations and backbiting are rampant, the acculturation of corruption has occurred and this is utterly despicable and condemned in the sight of Allah s.w.t.

The prohibition of fasad in all its forms: oppression, evil, iniquity, licentiousness, sin are stated explicitly as part of the Prophetic mission.

Conclusion

It is important for the continued existence and presence of reformers (muslih) to fight against corruption in all of its forms. The mission of reform is to save man by humanizing mankind to be free from the cancer of corruption of the self. It is hard and difficult as the problem has developed through the ages. So it was for Prophet Musa a.s. in facing the intransigence of the Children of Israel. So it is if the Muslim ummah allow their hearts and minds to be self destructed by ‘dead thoughts’ (al fikr al mumit). Imagine the situation of a generation of Muslims who are forced to accept Islam devoid of the dimension of jihad (strive and struggle). The fighting spirit is part of a nation’s character. It does not develop in an instant after much erosion and decay over generations. Without deep realization, proper understanding and driven by a fighting spirit, communities will quickly degenerate afflicted by fasad al nufus (corruption of the self) to become cowards (al jubn) and infected with al wahn (the excessive love of the material world and the fear of death).


Note: the above is adapted and translated from an article appearing in Risalah 7/8/9-2003 titled Tafsir al Maudu’iyy: Fasad Petanda Kejatuhan Ummah by Dr Siddiq Fadzil, President of Kolej Dar al-Hikmah.

Crisis in the Catholic Church

Outwardly Pope John Paul II, who has been actively involved in
battling war and suppression, is a beacon of hope for those
who long for freedom. Internally, however, his anti-reformist
tenure has plunged the Roman Catholic church into an epochal
credibility crisis.

The Pope's Contradictions
By Hans Küng

Don't be fooled by the crowds: Millions have left the Catholic
Church under Pope John Paul II's leadership. The Catholic church is in dire straits. The pope is deathly ill and deserves every bit of sympathy he can get. But the church must live on, and in light of the selection of a new pope, it will need a diagnosis, an unadorned insider analysis. The therapy will be discussed later.

Many marvel at the staying power of this highly fragile,
partially paralyzed head of the Roman Catholic church, a man
who, despite all medications, is barely able to speak. He is
treated with a sort of reverence that would never be extended
to an American president or a German chancellor in a similar
state. Others feel put off by a man they see as an obstinate
office bearer who, instead of accepting the Christian path to
his own eternity, is using all means at his disposal to hold
on to power in a largely undemocratic system.

Even for many Catholics, this pope at the end of his physical
strength, refusing to relinquish his power, is the symbol of a
fraudulent church that has calcified and become senile behind
its glittering façade.

The festive mood that prevailed during the Second Vatican
Council (1962 to 1965), or Vatican II, has disappeared.
Vatican II's outlook of renewal, ecumenical understanding and
a general opening of the world now seems overcast and the
future gloomy. Many have resigned themselves or even turned
away out of frustration from this self-absorbed hierarchy. As
a result, many people are confronted with an impossible set of
alternatives: "play the game or leave the church." New hope
will only begin to take root when church officials in Rome and
in the episcopacy reorient themselves toward the compass of
the Gospel.

One of the few glimmers of hope has been the pope's stance
against the Iraq war and war in general. The role the Polish
pope played in helping bring about the collapse of the Soviet
empire is also emphasized, and rightly so. But it's also
heavily exaggerated by papal propagandists. After all, the
Soviet regime did not fail because of the pope (before the
arrival of Gorbachev, the pope was achieving about as little
as he is now achieving in China), but instead imploded because
of the Soviet system's inherent economic and social
contradictions.

In my view, Karol Wojtyla is not the greatest, but certainly
the most contradictory, pope of the 20th century. A pope of
many great gifts and many wrong decisions! To summarize his
tenure and reduce it to a common denominator: His "foreign
policy" demands conversion, reform and dialogue from the rest
of the world. But this is sharply contradicted by his
"domestic policy," which is oriented toward the restoration of
the pre-council status quo, obstructing reform, denying
dialogue within the church, and absolute Roman dominance. This
inconsistency is evident in many areas. While expressly
acknowledging the positive sides of this pontificate, which,
incidentally, have received plenty of official emphasis, I
would like to focus on the nine most glaring contradictions:

HUMAN RIGHTS: Outwardly, John Paul II supports human rights,
while inwardly withholding them from bishops, theologians and
especially women.

The Vatican -- once a resolute foe of human rights, but
nowadays all too willing to become involved in European
politics -- has yet to sign the European Council's Declaration
of Human Rights. Far too many canons of the absolutist Roman
church law of the Middle Ages would have to be amended first.
The concept of separation of powers, the bedrock of all modern
legal practice, is unknown in the Roman Catholic church. Due
process is an unknown entity in the church. In disputes, one
and the same Vatican agency functions as lawmaker, prosecutor
and judge.

Consequences: A servile episcopate and intolerable legal
conditions. Any pastor, theologian or layperson who enters
into a legal dispute with the higher church courts has
virtually no prospects of prevailing.

THE ROLE OF WOMEN: The great worshiper of the Virgin Mary
preaches a noble concept of womanhood, but at the same time
forbids women from practicing birth control and bars them from
ordination.

Consequences: There is a rift between external conformism and
internal autonomy of conscience. This results in bishops who
lean towards Rome, alienating themselves from women, as was
the case in the dispute surrounding the issue of abortion
counseling (in 1999, the Pope ordered German bishops to close
counseling centers that issued certificates to women that
could later be used to get an abortion). This in turn leads to
a growing exodus among those women who have so far remained
faithful to the church.

SEXUAL MORALS: This pope, while preaching against mass poverty
and suffering in the world, makes himself partially
responsible for this suffering as a result of his attitudes
toward birth control and explosive population growth.

During his many trips and in a speech to the 1994 United
Nations Conference on Population and Development in Cairo,
John Paul II declared his opposition to the pill and condoms.
As a result, the pope, more than any other statesman, can be
held partly responsible for uncontrolled population growth in
some countries and the spread of AIDS in Africa.

Consequences: Even in traditionally Catholic countries like
Ireland, Spain and Portugal, the pope's and the Roman Catholic
church's rigorous sexual morals are openly or tacitly
rejected.

CELIBACY AMONG PRIESTS: By propagating the traditional image
of the celibate male priest, Karol Wojtyla bears the principal
responsibility for the catastrophic dearth of priests, the
collapse of spiritual welfare in many countries, and the many
pedophilia scandals the church is no longer able to cover up.

Marriage is still forbidden to men who have agreed to devote
their lives to the priesthood. This is only one example of how
this pope, like others before him, is ignoring the teachings
of the bible and the great Catholic tradition of the first
millennium, which did not require office bearers to take a vow
of celibacy. If someone, by virtue of his office, is forced to
spend his life without a wife and children, there is a great
risk that healthy integration of sexuality will fail, which
can lead to pedophilic acts, for example.

Consequences: The ranks have been thinned and there is a lack
of new blood in the Catholic church. Soon almost two-thirds of
parishes, both in German-speaking countries and elsewhere,
will be without an ordained pastor and regular celebrations of
the Eucharist. It's a deficiency that even the declining
influx of priests from other countries (1,400 of Germany's
priests are from Poland, India and Africa) and the combining
of parishes into "spiritual welfare units," a highly unpopular
trend among the faithful, can no longer hide. The number of
newly ordained priests in Germany dropped from 366 in 1990 to
161 in 2003, and the average age of active priests today is
now above 60.

ECUMENICAL MOVEMENT: The pope likes to be seen as a spokesman
for the ecumenical movement. At the same time, however, he has
weighed heavily on the Vatican's relations with orthodox and
reform churches, and has refused to recognize their
ecclesiastical offices and Communion services.

The pope could heed the advice of several ecumenical study
commissions and follow the practice of many local pastors by
recognizing the offices and Communion services of non-Catholic
churches and permitting Eucharistic hospitality. He could also
tone down the Vatican's excessive, medieval claim to power, in
terms of doctrine and church leadership, vis-à-vis eastern
European churches and reform churches, and could do away with
the Vatican's policy of sending Roman-Catholic bishops to
regions dominated by the Russian Orthodox church.

The pope could do these things, but John Paul II doesn't want
to. Instead, he wants to preserve and even expand the Roman
power system. For this reason, he resorts to a pious two-
facedness: Rome's politics of power and prestige are veiled by
ecumenical soapbox speeches and empty gestures.

Consequences: Ecumenical understanding was blocked after the
council, and relations with the Orthodox and Protestant
churches were burdened to an appalling extent. The papacy,
like its predecessors in the 11th and 16th centuries, is
proving to be the greatest obstacle to unity among Christian
churches in freedom and diversity.

PERSONNEL POLICY: As a suffragan bishop and later as
archbishop of Krakow, Karol Wojtyla took part in the Second
Vatican Council. But as pope, he disregarded the collegiality
which had been agreed to there and instead celebrated the
triumph of his papacy at the cost of the bishops.

With his "internal policies," this Pope betrayed the council
numerous times. Instead of using the conciliatory program
words "Aggiornamento - Dialogue and Collegiality --
ecumenical," what's valid now in doctrine and practice is
"restoration, lectureship, obedience and re-Romanization." The
criteria for the appointment of a bishop is not the spirit of
the gospel or pastoral open-mindedness, but rather to be
absolutely loyal to the party line in Rome. Before their
appointment, their fundamental conformity is tested based on a
curial catalog of questions and they are sacrally sealed
through a personal and unlimited pledge of obedience to the
Pope that is tantamount to an oath to the "Fuehrer."

The Pope's friends among the German-speaking bishops include
Cologne's Cardinal Joachim Meisner, the Bishop of Fulda
Johannes Dyba, who died in 2000, Hans Hermann Groer, who
resigned from his post as Vienna's cardinal in 1995 following
allegations that he had sexually abused pupils years before
and the Bishop of St. Poeltin, Kurt Krenn, who just lost his
post after a sex scandal emerged in his priests' seminary.
Those are just the most spectacular mistakes of these
pastorally devastating personnel policies, which have allowed
the moral, intellectual and pastoral level of the episcopate
to dangerously slip.

Consequences: A largely mediocre, ultra-conservative and
servile episcopate is possibly the most serious burden of this
overly long pontificate. The masses of cheering Catholics at
the best-staged Pope manifestations should not deceive:
Millions have left the church under this pontificate or they
have withdrawn from religious life in opposition.

CLERICALISM: The Polish pope comes across as a deeply
religious representative of a Christian Europe, but his
triumphant appearances and his reactionary policies
unintentionally promote hostility to the church and even an
aversion to Christianity.

In the papal campaign of evangelization, which centers on a
sexual morality that is out of step with the times, women, in
particular, who do not share the Vatican's position on
controversial issues like birth control, abortion, divorce and
artificial insemination are disparaged as promoters of a
"culture of death." As a result of its interventions -- in
Germany, for example, where it sought to influence politicians
and the episcopacy in the dispute surrounding the issue of
abortion counseling -- the Roman Curia creates the impression
that it has little respect for the legal separation of church
and state. Indeed, the Vatican (using the European People's
Party as its mouthpiece) is also trying to exert pressure on
the European Parliament by calling for the appointment of
experts, in issues relating to abortion legislation, for
example, who are especially loyal to Rome. Instead of entering
the social mainstream everywhere by supporting reasonable
solutions, the Roman Curia, through its proclamations and
secret agitation (through nuntiatures, bishops' conferences
and "friends"), is in fact fueling the polarization between
the pro-life and pro-choice movements, between moralists and
libertines.

Consequences: Rome's clericalist policy merely strengthens the
position of dogmatic anti-clericalists and fundamentalist
atheists. It also creates suspicion among believers that
religion could be being misused for political ends.

NEW BLOOD IN THE CHURCH: As a charismatic communicator and
media star, this pope is especially effective among young
people, even as he grows older. But he achieves this by
drawing in large part on the conservative "new movements" of
Italian origin, the "Opus Dei" movement that originated in
Spain, and an uncritical public loyal to the pope. All of this
is symptomatic of the pope's approach to dealing with the lay
public and his inability to converse with his critics.

The major regional and international youth events sponsored by
the new lay movements (Focolare, Comunione e Liberazione, St.
Egidio, Regnum Christi) and supervised by the church hierarchy
attract hundreds of thousands of young people, many of them
well-meaning but far too many uncritical. In times when they
lack convincing leadership figures, these young people are
most impressed by a shared "event." The personal magnetism of
"John Paul Superstar" is usually more important than the
content of the pope's speeches, while their effects on parish
life are minimal.

In keeping with his ideal of a uniform and obedient church,
the pope sees the future of the church almost exclusively in
these easily controlled, conservative lay movements. This
includes the Vatican's distancing itself from the Jesuit
order, which is oriented toward the tenets of the council.
Preferred by earlier popes, the Jesuits, because of their
intellectual qualities, critical theology and liberal
theological options, are now perceived as spanners in the
works of the papal restoration policy.

Instead, Karol Wojtyla, even during his tenure as archbishop
of Krakow, placed his full confidence in the financially
powerful and influential, but undemocratic and secretive Opus
Dei movement, a group linked to fascist regimes in the past
and now especially active in the world of finance, politics
and journalism. In fact, by granting Opus Dei special legal
status, the pope even made the organization exempt from
supervision by the church's bishops.

Consequences: Young people from church groups and
congregations (with the exception of alter servers), and
especially the non-organized "average Catholics," usually stay
away from major youth get-togethers. Catholic youth
organizations at odds with the Vatican are disciplined and
starved when local bishops, at Rome's behest, withhold their
funding. The growing role of the archconservative and non-
transparent Opus Dei movement in many institutions has created
a climate of uncertainty and suspicion. Once-critical bishops
have cozied up to Opus Dei, while laypeople who were once
involved in the church have withdrawn in resignation.

SINS OF THE PAST: Despite the fact that in 2000 he forced
himself through a public confession of the church's historical
transgressions, John Paul II has drawn almost no practical
consequences from it.

The baroque and bombastic confession of the church's
transgressions, staged with cardinals in St. Peter's
Cathedral, remained vague, non-specific and ambiguous. The
pope only asked for forgiveness for the transgressions of the
"sons and daughters" of the church, but not for those of the
"Holy Fathers," those of the "church itself" and those of the
hierarchies present at the event.

The pope never commented on the Curia's dealings with the
Mafia, and in fact contributed more to covering up than
uncovering scandals and criminal behavior. The Vatican has
also been extremely slow to prosecute pedophilia scandals
involving Catholic clergy.

Consequences: The half-hearted papal confession remained
without consequences, producing neither reversals nor action,
only words.

For the Catholic church, this pontificate, despite its
positive aspects, has on the whole proven to be a great
disappointment and, ultimately, a disaster. As a result of his
contradictions, this pope has deeply polarized the church,
alienated it from countless people and plunged it into an
epochal crisis -- a structural crisis that, after a quarter
century, is now revealing fatal deficits in terms of
development and a tremendous need for reform.

Contrary to all intentions conveyed in the Second Vatican
Council, the medieval Roman system, a power apparatus with
totalitarian features, was restored through clever and
ruthless personnel and academic policies. Bishops were brought
into line, pastors overloaded, theologians muzzled, the laity
deprived of their rights, women discriminated against,
national synods and churchgoers' requests ignored, along with
sex scandals, prohibitions on discussion, liturgical spoon-
feeding, a ban on sermons by lay theologians, incitement to
denunciation, prevention of Holy Communion -- "the world" can
hardly be blamed for all of this!!

The upshot is that the Catholic church has completely lost the
enormous credibility it once enjoyed under the papacy of John
XXIII and in the wake of the Second Vatican Council.

If the next pope were to continue the policies of this
pontificate, he would only reinforce an enormous backup of
problems and turn the Catholic church's current structural
crisis into a hopeless situation. Instead, a new pope must
decide in favor of a change in course and inspire the church
to embark on new paths -- in the spirit of John XXIII and in
keeping with the impetus for reform brought about by the
Second Vatican Council.

REUTERS

End

Hans Kung is one of today's leading Catholic theologians.
Küng, a Swiss national living in the southern German city of
Tübingen, has been embroiled in an ongoing feud with church
authorities for decades. As a result of his critical inquiries
on the papacy, the Vatican withdrew his church authority to
teach in 1979. Nevertheless, Küng, 75, is still a priest and,
until his retirement in 1995, taught ecumenical theology at
the University of Tübingen. As president of the Global Ethic
Foundation, Küng is also an advisor to the United Nations.

How Will New Pope Handle Ties With Muslims?

The Toronto Star, Canada
21 April 2005

How Will New Pope Handle Ties With Muslims?
by Haroon Siddiqui

Joseph Ratzinger is entitled to his Catholic conservatism, his
theological rigidity and his opposition to religious relativism. It is
up to Catholics to internally debate his traditionalist views on a
series of social issues. They already are, even before the applause has
died down over his election as Pope.

It is not up to us to dictate what Catholics should believe and who
they pick as leader. Otherwise, the secular idea of freedom of religion
ceases to have meaning.

Rather, the relevant issue for the world is: How will Pope Benedict XVI
be different from his predecessor in dealing with other faiths and
nations?

It is only half correct to say he will follow John Paul II's
traditions. He clearly would on conservative theology. But would he
continue the papal outreach to others around the globe that we have
been blessed with in the last quarter of a century?

John Paul spoke up for the poor, affected by globalization and
unbridled capitalism.

He stood by the oppressed, including the Palestinians, whom he
addressed in Bethlehem: "No one can ignore how much you have had to
suffer in recent decades. Your torment is before the eyes of the world,
and it has gone on too long ... Only with a just and lasting peace —
not imposed but secured through negotiations — will legitimate
Palestinian aspirations be fulfilled."

He believed in the United Nations and multilateralism, which is why he
was emphatic in opposing the invasion and occupation of Iraq.

Much of the commentary of the last 48 hours has been about Cardinal
Ratzinger's belief in the superiority of Catholicism.

It strikes other faiths as "chauvinistic and triumphalist," in the
phrase of Rabbi Michael Lerner, of the American magazine Tikkun. It
offends Anglicans and other Protestants.

But don't most believers, regardless of religion or denomination,
believe, to a degree, that they alone possess the truth?

More instructive is Ratzinger's approach to one of the bigger issues of
the age: relations with Muslims and Islam. John Paul — the first pope
to pray in a synagogue, visit the Wailing Wall and call anti-Semitism
"a sin against God" — was also the first pontiff to enter a mosque,
open a dialogue with Muslims, condemn Islamophobia and urge Catholics
to join Muslims in fasting on the last Friday of Ramadan.

Ratzinger, however, has reservations not only about outreach to Muslims
but Islam.

"The rebirth of Islam is due in part to the new material richness
acquired by Muslim countries, but mainly to the knowledge that it is
able to offer a valid spiritual foundation for the life of its people,
a foundation that seems to have escaped from the hands of old Europe,"
he wrote last year.

One can read that as a statement of admiration. But, juxtaposed with
his concern regarding his flock in Europe, it may not be.

It fits the pattern of thinking of some conservatives who speak of the
increasing presence of Muslims in Europe in the same breath as the
decline of Christianity on the continent. That implies the two are
related, which they are not.

The "culprit" is secularism, and, in the case of Catholics, the
Vatican's social conservatism, which the faithful ignore.

Blaming Muslims is cheap politics.

Ratzinger has long wanted Europe to rediscover its Christianity. That's
understandable. But he crossed the line last year in opposing the entry
of Turkey into the European Union.

"Turkey has always represented a different continent, always in
contrast with Europe," he told the Paris newspaper Le Figaro.

That is disturbingly close to the racist notion that Muslim Turkey
cannot be a part of Christian Europe. The ignorance of that sentiment
is stupefying, for several reasons: The continent is no longer
Christian alone; Christian majority nations do not constitute Christian
states, and opposing Turkey on religious grounds makes a mockery of
Europe's self-admired secularism, even if that is of little or no
concern to the Vatican.

We will have to wait and see whether Pope Benedict XVI will distance
himself from Cardinal Ratzinger. One of the legacies of John Paul II
was that he helped end the Cold War. Will the new Pope fan the war
being waged by neo-conservatives and fundamentalist Protestants against
Muslims and Islam, or will he help diffuse it?

Haroon Siddiqui is The Star's editorial page editor emeritus.

© 2005 Toronto Star

Twelve Hours Old

Twelve Hours Old

Canadian convert Katherine Bullock marvels at becoming a Muslim

by Katherine Bullock

What am I doing down here? I wonder, my nose and forehead pressed to the floor as I kneel in prayer. My kneecaps ache, my arm muscles strain as I try to keep the pressure off my forehead. I listen to strange utterings of the person praying next to me. It's Arabic, and they understand what they are saying, even if I don't. So. I make up my own words, hoping God will be kind to me, a Muslim only 12 hours old. OK. God, I converted to Islam because I believe in you, and because Islam makes sense to me. Did I really just say that? I catch myself, bursting into tears. What would my friends say if they saw me like this, kneeling, nose pressed to the floor?...They'd laugh at me. Have you lost your mind? they'd ask. You can't seriously tell me you are religious. Religious...I was once a happy 'speculative atheist,' how did I turn into a believer and a Muslim? I ask myself. I turn my mind into the past and attempt a whirlwind tour through my journey. But where did it begin? Maybe it started when I first met practicing Muslims. This was in 1991, at Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada.

I was an open-minded, tolerant, liberal woman. 24 years old. I saw Muslim women walking around the international Centre and I felt sorry for them. I knew they were oppressed. My sorrow increased when I asked them why they covered their hair, why they wore long sleeves in summer, why they were so ill-treated in Muslim countries, and they told me that they wore the veil, and they dressed so, because God asked them too. Poor things. What about their treatment in Muslim countries? That's culture, they would reply. I knew they were deluded, socialised/brainwashed from an early age, into believing this wicked way of treating women. But I noticed how happy they were, how friendly they were, how solid they seemed. I saw Muslim men walking around the international centre.

There was even a man from Libya - the land of terrorists. I trembled when I saw them, lest they do something to me in the name of God. I remembered the television images of masses of rampaging Arab men burning effiges of President Bush, all in the name of God. What a God they must have, I thought. Poor things that they even believe in God, I added, secure in the truth that God was an anthropomorphic projection of us weak human beings. But I noticed that these men were very friendly. I noticed how helpful they were. I perceived an aura of calmness. What a belief they must have, I thought. But it puzzled me. I had read the Koran, and hadn't detected anything special about it. That was before, when the Gulf War broke out. What kind of God would persuade men to go War, to kill innocent citizens of another country, to rape women, to demonstrate against the US?

I decided I'd better read the Holy book on whose behalf they claimed they were acting. I read a Penguin classic, surely a trustworthy book, and I couldn't finish it, I disliked it so much. Here was a paradise described with virgin women in it for the righteous (what was a righteous woman to do with a virgin woman in Paradise?); here was a God destroying whole cities at a stroke.

No wonder the women are oppressed, and these fanatics storm around burning the US flag, I thought. But the Muslims I put this to seemed bewildered. Their Qu'ran didn't say things in that way. Perhaps I had a bad translation?

Suddenly the praying person I am following stands up. I too stand up, my feet catching on the long skirt I wear; I almost trip. I sniff, trying to stop the tears. I must focus on praying to God. Dear God, I am here because I believe in you, and because during my research of Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Sikhism, and Buddhism, Islam made the most sense.

Bending over, my hands at my knees, I try hard to reassure myself. God. Please help me to be a good Muslim. A Muslim! Kathy, how could you - a white western women who is educated - convert to a religion which makes its women second class citizens!

But Kingston's Muslims became my friends, I protest. They welcomed me into their community warmly, without question. I forgot that they were oppressed and terrorists. This seems like the start of my journey. But I was still an atheist. Or was I?

I had looked into the starry night, and contemplated the universe. The diamond stars strewn across the dark sky twinkled mysterious messages to me. I felt hooked up to something bigger than myself. Was it a collective human consciousness? Peace and tranquility flowed to me from the stars. Could I wrench myself from this feeling and declare there is no higher being? No higher consciousness? Haven't you ever doubted the existence of God? I would ask my believing Christian and Muslim friends. No, they replied. No? No? This puzzled me.

Was God that obvious? How come I couldn't see God. It seemed too much a stretch of my imagination. A being out there, affecting the way I lived. How could God listen to billions of people praying, and deal with each second of that person's life? It's impossible. Maybe a First Cause, but one who intervened? And what about the persistence of injustice in the world? Children dying in war. A just, good God couldn't allow that. God didn't make sense. God couldn't exist. Besides, we evolved, so that disposed of a First Cause anyway.

We kneel down again, and here I am, sniffing, looking sideways at my fingers on the green of my new prayer mat. I like my prayer mat. It has a velvetty touch to it, and some of my favourite colours: a purple mosque on a green background. There is a path leading to a black entrance of the mosque and it beckons me. The entrance to the mosque seems to contain the truth, it is elusive, but it is there. I am happy to be beckoned to this entrance.

When I was much younger I had a complete jigsaw picture of the world. It fell apart sometime during the third or fourth year of my undergraduate study. In Kingston I had reminded myself that I had once been a regular churchgoer, somewhat embarrassed, since I knew that religious people were slushy/mushy, quaint, boring, old fashioned people. Yet God had seemed self-evident to me then. The universe made no sense without a Creator Being who was also omnipotent.

Leaving church I had always had a feeling of lightness and happiness. I felt the loss of that feeling. Could it be that I had once had a connection to God which was now gone? Maybe this was the start of my journey? I tried to pray again, but found it extraordinarily difficult. Christians told me that people who didn't believe in Lord Jesus Christ were doomed. What about people who've never heard of Jesus? Or people who follow their own religion? And society historically claimed women were inferior because Christianity told us it was Eve's punishment; women were barred from studying, voting, owning land. God was an awful man with a long white beard. I couldn't talk to him. I couldn't follow Christianity, therefore God couldn't exist.

But then I discovered feminists who believed in God, Christian women who were feminists, and Muslim women who believed Islam did not condone a lot of what I thought integral to their religion. I started to pray and call myself a 'post-christian feminist believer.'

I felt that lightness again; maybe God did exist. I carefully examined my life's events and I saw that coincidences and luck were God's blessings for me, and I'd never noticed, or said thanks. I am amazed God was so kind and persistent while I was disloyal. My ears and feet tingle pleasantly from the washing I have just given them; a washing which cleanses me and allows me to approach God in prayer.

God. An awesome deity. I feel awe, wonder and peace. Please show me the path. But surely you can see that the world is too complex, too beautiful, too harmonious to be an accident? To be the blind result of evolutionary forces? Don't you know that science is returning to a belief in God? Don't you know that science never contradicted Islam anyway? I am exasperated with my imaginary jury. Haven't they researched these things?

Maybe this was the most decisive path. I'd heard on the radio an interview with a physicist who was explaining how modern science had abandoned its nineteenth century matierialistic assumptions long ago, and was scientifically of the opinion that too many phenomena occured which made no sense without there being intelligence and design behind it all. Indeed, scientific experiments were not just a passive observation of physical phenomena, observation altered the way physical events proceeded, and it seemed therefore that intelligence was the most fundamental stuff of the universe.

I read more, and more. I discovered that only the most diehard anthropologists still believed in evolution theory, though no one was saying this very loudly for fear of losing their job. My jigsaw was starting to fall apart.

OK, so you decided God existed. You were a monotheist. But Christianity is monotheistic. It is your heritage. Why leave it? Still these questioners are puzzled. But you must understand this is the easiest question of them all to answer. I smile.

I learned how the Qu'ran did not contradict science in the same way the Bible did. I wanted to read the Biblical stories literally, and discovered I could not. Scientific fact contradicted Biblical account. But scientific fact did not contradict Qu'ranic account, science even sometimes explained a hitherto inexplicable Qu'ranic verse. This was stunning.

There was a verse about how the water from fresh water rivers which flowed into the sea did not mix with the sea water; verses describing conception accurately; verses referring to the orbits of the planets. Seventh century science knew none of this. How could Muhammed be so uniquely wise? My mind drew me towards the Qu'ran, but I resisted.

I started going to church again, only to find myself in tears in nearly every service. Christianity continued to be difficult for me. So much didn't make sense: the Trinity; the idea that Jesus was God incarnate; the worship of Mary, the Saints, or Jesus, rather than God. The priests told me to leave reason behind when contemplating God. The Trinity did not make sense, and nor was it supposed to. I delved deeper. After all, how could I leave my culture, my heritage, my family? No one would understand, and I'd be alone. I tried to be a good Christian.

I learned more. I discovered that Easter was instituted a couple of hundreds of years after Jesus's death, that Jesus never called himself God incarnate, and more often said he was the Son of Man; that the doctrine of the Trinity was established some 300 odd years after Christ had died; that the Nicene Creed which I had faithfully recited every week, focusing on each word, was written by MEN at a political meeting to confirm a minority position that Jesus was the Son of God, and the majority viewpoint that Jesus was God's messenger, was expunged forever.

I was so angry! Why hadn't the Church taught me these things. Well. I knew why. People would understand that they could worship God elsewhere, and that there, worship would actually make sense to them. I would only worship one God, not three, not The Father, Son and Holy ghost; not Jesus as Lord, nor the Saints, nor Mary. Could Muhammed really be a Messenger, could the Qu'ran be God's word? I kept reading the Qu'ran.

It told me that Eve was not alone to blame for the 'fall;' that Jesus was a Messenger; that unbelievers would laugh at me for being a believer; that people would question the authenticity of Muhammed's claim to revelation, but that if they tried to write something as wise, consistent and rational they would fail. This seemed true. Islam asked me to use my intelligence to contemplate God, it encouraged me to seek knowledge, it told me that whoever believed in (Jews/Christians/Muslims/whoever) would get rewards, it seemed a very encompassing religion. We stand again and still standing, bend down again to a resting position with our hands on our knees. What else can I say to God? I can't think of enough to say, the prayer seems so long.

I puff slightly, still sniffling, since with all the standing and kneeling and standing I am somewhat out of breath. So you seriously think that I would willing enter a religion which turned me into a second class citizen? I demand of my questioners. You know that there is a lot of abuse of women in Islamic countries, just as in the West, but this is not true Islam. And don't bring the veil thing up. Don't you know that women wear hijab because God asks them to? Because they trust in God's word.

Still. How will I have the courage to wear hijab? I probably won't. People will stare at me, I'll become obvious; I'd rather hide away in the crowd when I'm out. What will my friends say when they see me in that?? OH! God! Help.

I had stalled at the edge of change for many a long month, my dilemma growing daily. What should I do? Leave my old life and start a new one? But I couldn't possibly go out in public in hijab. People would stare at me. I stood at the forked path which God had helped me reach. I had new knowledge which rested comfortably with my intellect. Follow the conviction, or stay in the old way? How could I stay when I had a different outlook on life? How could I change when the step seemed too big for me?

I would rehearse the conversion sentence: There is no God but God and Muhammed is his prophet. Simple words, I believe in them, so convert. I cannot, I resisted. I circled endlessly day after day. God stood on one of the paths of the fork, tapping his foot. Come on Kathy. I've brought you here, but you must cross alone. I stayed stationary, transfixed like a kangaroo trapped in car lights late at night. Then one night, God, I suppose, gave me a final yank. I was passing a mosque with my husband. I had a feeling in me that was so strong I could hardly bear it. If you don't convert now, you never will, my inner voice told me. I knew it was true. OK, I'll do it. If they let me in to the mosque, I'll do it. But there was no one there. I said the shahaada under the trees outside the mosque. I waited. I waited for the thunderclap, the immediate feeling of relief, the lifting of my burden. But it didn't come.

I felt exactly the same. Now we are kneeling again, the world looks so different from down here. Even famous football players prostrate like this, I remember, glancing sideways at the tassles of my hijab which fall onto the prayer mat; we are all the same and equally humbled before God. Now we are sitting up straight, my prayer leader is muttering something still, waving his right hand's forefinger around in the air. I look down at my mat again. The green, purple and black of my prayer mat look reassuringly the same.

The blackness of the Mosque's entrance entreats me: 'I am here, just relax and you will find me.' My tears have dried on my face and the skin feels tight What am I doing here? Dear God. I am here because I believe in you, because I believe in the compelling and majestic words of the Qur'an, and because I believe in the Prophethood of Your Messenger Muhammed. I know in my heart my decision is the right one. Please give me the courage to carry on with this new self and new life, that I may serve you well with a strong faith. I smile and stand up, folding my prayer mat into half, and lay it on the sofa ready for my next encounter with its velvety green certainty. Now the burden begins to lift.

Kehidupan Malam KL dan UK

Kehidupan Malam KL dan UK
Dato' Dr ISMAIL IBRAHIM
Pengerusi Majlis Fatwa Kebangsaan
Mingguan Malaysia, 10 April 2005

SEORANG ibu yang saya temui semasa menyertai satu program anjuran Jabatan Penuntut Malaysia London minggu lepas, menyatakan bahawa anak remajanya yang berada bersamanya di Manchester, tempat dia sedang menyiapkan tesis doktor falsafahnya, tidak pernah keluar rumah pada waktu malam semasa berada di sana. Tetapi ketika kembali ke Kuala Lumpur masa cuti baru-baru ini, anaknya itu boleh dikatakan setiap malam meminta kebenarannya untuk keluar malam.

Di bandar raya tempat kediamannya di United Kingdom (UK) tersebut, pada waktu malam tidak ada "kehidupan" di dalam bandar, atau di jalan-jalannya. Kebanyakan kedai menutup pintunya sebelum menjelang waktu maghrib, bukan kerana penjaganya hendak bersembahyang maghrib, sebab kebanyakan mereka bukanlah beragama Islam, tetapi kerana masa berniaga
di sana, hanyalah sekadar pukul 6 atau 7 malam. Selepas itu kedai ditutup, tiada perniagaan lagi.

Itulah gambaran kehidupan malam di UK pada keseluruhannya. Malah di kota raya London yang
terkenal dengan kesibukannya itu pun, kedai dan gedung perniagaannya pada umumnya, menutup pintunya pada pukul 6 atau 7 malam. Jalan raya yang terkenal dengan syurga membeli-belahnya kepada para pelancong tempatan dan luar negara, termasuk pelancong dari negara kita, seperti Oxford Street, lengang menjelang malam, atau lewat petang.

Bagi sesetengah kalangan, hal ini menunjukkan kemalasan orang putih untuk berniaga, tetapi bagi orang-orang seperti ibu yang saya maksudkan di atas, hal ini agak sihat di dalam masyarakat moden yang amat canggih dan mencabar ini. Apa gunanya berniaga dan
mendapatkan keuntungan yang banyak, sekiranya hal itu membawa kepada satu gejala yang dapat mengorbankan nilai-nilai murni kehidupan, apa lagi bagi masyarakat beragama seperti kita ini?

Sebab itulah, ibu yang saya sebutkan di atas, menyatakan bahawa anak remajanya pada waktu malam di rumahnya di UK, akan berada di rumah, menonton televisyen, melayari komputer, membaca buku pelajaran dan sebagainya. Atau kalau tidak ada apa yang hendak dibuatnya, maka dia akan segera menarik selimut, belayar dalam alam mimpi, terutamanya ketika berada di dalam bilik yang dingin, pada musim sejuk.

Tetapi ketika balik ke Malaysia kerana menghabiskan cuti, kepala ibu menjadi pening, kerana hampir setiap malam anaknya itu akan meminta kebenarannya untuk keluar malam bersama kawan-kawannya. Di UK anaknya mempunyai kawan sebaya juga, tetapi dia tidak pula
sibuk untuk keluar dengan rakannya itu, malah rakannya juga tidak akan keluar pada waktu malam, kerana seperti yang dinyatakan di atas, di sana tidak ada kehidupan malam. Tidak ada restoran 24 jam, tidak ada gerai yang menjual nasi lemak atau roti canai, dan tidak ada gerai untuk mereka lepak-lepak berbual sampai pagi, pukul tiga atau empat, sambil minum-minum teh tarik atau Coca-Cola.

Di UK ibu remaja tersebut juga dapat menumpukan perhatian sepenuhnya kepada kajian dan tesis Ph.Dnya tanpa risau atau bimbang dengan keselamatan anaknya, kerana anaknya berada di dalam rumahnya mulai dari waktu senja sehingga pagi esok. Tetapi di Malaysia, kalau anaknya tidak minta keluar pada waktu malam, rakan-rakannya pula yang akan menelefonnya mengajak keluar. Waktu yang dipilihnya untuk keluar malam itu pula, bukan pada pukul 8 atau 9 malam, tetapi kebanyakannya, pada pukul 10 atau 11 malam baru mula nak pakai baju untuk keluar. Keluarnya pula bukan sejam dua, tetapi sampai berjam-jam, kadang-kadang menjelang azan subuh baru pulang keletihan dan mengantuk. Ketika itu hanyalah bantal yang menjadi temannya, dan segala azan atau subuh akan dibiarkan berlalu begitu sahaja, kerana badannya terlalu letih, dan matanya tidak mampu dibuka lagi.

Apabila orang mulai tidur pada pukul 4, 5 atau 6 subuh, tentulah dapat dibayangkan pukul berapa baru dia dapat bangun. Malah dapatlah juga dibayangkan bagaimanakah beratnya kepala dan badan orang yang bertindak demikian, kerana dia sebenarnya telah melanggar sunah alam, iaitu kejadian siang dan malam yang dijadikan Allah untuk tidur dan jaga.

Allah menjadikan malam untuk manusia berehat dan tidur, dan siang ialah untuk berjaga dan bekerja, kerana kejadian fizikal serta fitrah manusia pun telah diprogramkan begitu oleh sunah alam, maka ketika manusia menukar fitrah kejadian Allah itu, kehidupannya tentulah tidak normal dan seimbang lagi.

Memang suasana sekeliling yang sebenarnya mencorakkan kehidupan kita manusia ini. Di London tidak ada gerai untuk kita melepak, tetapi di Bangsar atau Sri Hartamas, terlalu banyak gerai yang menarik kehadiran generasi tua dan muda untuk berjaga malam. Di London,
bar atau pubnya, kebanyakannya hanya dibuka sehingga pukul 11 malam, tetapi di Bangsar dan tempat-tempat lain, mungkin dibuka sehingga pukul 2 atau 3 pagi. Kalau undang-undang mengatakan mereka boleh membuka hingga pukul 2 pagi umpamanya, mereka cuba-cuba juga
membukanya hingga pukul 3 atau 4 pagi, kerana biasanya pihak berkuasa tidak menghantar penguat kuasanya untuk melihat sama ada para peniaga itu mematuhi peraturan dan undang-undang yang dikuatkuasakan ataupun tidak.

Di London dan bandar-bandar lain juga di UK, orang yang meminum minuman ringan atau arak, nampaknya senyap-senyap saja di dalam kedai minuman, kerana mereka tidak boleh membawa minuman itu keluar premis yang ditetapkan. Tetapi di bandar ala Amerika atau New York negara kita, semua orang yang berjalan di atas jalan, dapat melihat orang meminum minuman keras atau ringan di dalam kedai minum, atau kadang-kadang kelihatan kelibat manusia berjalan, atau berarak di tengah jalan dengan botol atau tin minuman keras di tangannya.

Inilah suasana dan persekitaran yang merunsingkan kebanyakan ibu bapa yang mempunyai anak remaja sekarang ini di negara kita, seperti yang diceritakan oleh ibu di atas, khususnya di bandar-bandar yang telah dicorakkan sebegitu rupa, supaya kelihatan seperti bandar koboi, atau yang bersuasana kota uncle tom.

Bagi sesetengah golongan, mungkin hal ini tidaklah merupakan isu besar yang merunsingkan. Apa salahnya budak-budak muda itu keluar berhibur dan sembang-sembang dengan rakan sebayanya sepanjang malam, sambil minum teh tarik?

Malah bagi sesetengah ibu bapa moden pun, mungkin mereka beranggapan, apa salahnya anak-anak saya berada di luar, sama ada di gerai minum Coca-Cola, atau di kelab malam berhibur? Saya tahu anak saya berada dalam kelab malam, dan dia selamat di sana, malahan dia berjanji dengan saya akan balik ke rumah pada pukul 3 pagi, jadi apa yang hendak dirisaukan, dia berada di tempat yang selamat, bukan di atas jalan?

Tetapi bagi ibu yang berada di Manchester itu, dia mempunyai pandangan yang amat berlainan. Bila pulang ke Malaysia, dia risau anaknya terpengaruh dengan unsur jahat di luar, takut terlibat dalam permainan jahat, cuba-cuba minum Coca-Cola atau air syaitan,
hisap itu atau hisap ini, hidu itu atau hidu ini, dan takut juga bila keluar dari tempat minum, ditangkap pula oleh jabatan agama Islam, bukankah malu dibuatnya? Atau kalau tidak ditangkap jabatan agama yang menjadi polis moral yang mengacau daun itu pun, mungkin pula anaknya itu menumpang kereta mewah kawannya, yang dipandu secara gila-gila, seterusnya
berlanggar dan mengorbankan nyawa anaknya itu? Bukankah hal ini memeningkan kepala ibu tersebut?

Seterusnya dia takut pula, kesihatan anaknya terganggu, kerana tabiat tidur dan jaganya tidak mengikut fitrah kejadian dan biologikal manusia lagi, yang pada jangka panjangnya tentu akan menyebabkan mudarat kepada badan dan pemikiran, fizikal dan mentalnya. Malah lebih dari itu, dia risau juga kerana anaknya tak dapat sembahyang subuh, sebab bagaimana
nak bangun subuh, kalau pukul 3 atau 4 baru nak tidur?

Oleh itu, katanya, lebih baik dia tinggal di negara orang putih ini saja. Tak payah risau dan susah hati, tidak pening kepala dan tak perlu fikir yang bukan-bukan, seperti yang dialaminya di Malaysia ketika anaknya keluar malam dan tidak pulang-pulang hingga dinihari. Dia sendiri tidak dapat tidur malam, dan bukan hanya tidak dapat tidur, malah fikirannya juga menjadi runsing dan buntu, mana nak fikirkan hal tesisnya yang belum selesai, ditambah pula dengan perilaku anaknya yang melampau itu. Kalau tidak dibenarkan anaknya keluar di negara sendiri, nampak macam tidak adil pula, tambahan pula dia balik bercuti sekali-sekala sahaja, bukan selalu, dan peluang anaknya berjumpa kawan-kawannya pula hanyalah semasa balik cuti itu.

Saya hanya mendengar saja ceritanya itu, kerana saya ke sana bukanlah sebagai pakar runding cara, atau pakar motivasi. Tetapi terlintas juga di kepala saya, takkanlah pula kita yang berada di negara sendiri, beramal, beragama dan berbudaya serta berbudi bahasa,
akan lari ke negara Barat yang pesimis, negara orang tidak beragama dan tidak beriman, malah negara yang sentiasa kita anggap jahat itu?

Sehingga saya selesai menulis catatan ini, saya masih tidak tahu, bagaimanakah keadaan yang kusut ini hendak kita rungkaikan. Bagaimanakah kecelaruan perasaan hati kecil seperti hati kecil ibu yang prihatin ini dapat kita tolong redakan. Dia berkata juga bahawa dia takut sekiranya pengalaman dan kerisauan ini berterusan, mungkin satu hari dia akan mendarat di dalam klinik psikiatri kerana mengalami penyakit kemurungan dan tekanan jiwa yang hebat!

Namun kalau dia hendak terus tinggal di UK pula, dia tidak akan dibenarkan berbuat demikian, kerana dia sedang memakan wang universiti yang menyara dan membelanjakannya untuk mendapatkan ijazah tinggi itu, ertinya mahu tidak mahu, dia mestilah pulang ke negara sendiri.

Oleh itu persoalan yang ditimbulkannya, apa mungkinkah bila dia pulang nanti keadaan di sekelilingnya, khususnya pada waktu malam akan berubah? Mungkinkah cara hidup dan budaya kehidupan malam di negara sendiri yang kelihatan tidak terkawal itu akan mempunyai disiplin dan batas-batas tertentu yang tidak memberikan ruang kebebasan yang begitu banyak kepada generasi muda untuk mengubah sunah Allah dalam memanfaatkan siang dan malamnya?

Saya berfikir, sekiranya pun hendak diadakan perubahan yang radikal, maka siapakah pula yang akan mengadakan perubahan itu? Jabatan agama? Kerjanya sebagai "polis moral" tidak diperlukan lagi oleh banyak kalangan. Akta moral? Akta itu telah didesak supaya dimansuhkan. Ibu bapa? Ibu bapa pun, ada yang suka kehidupan dan gaya hidup anak mudanya seperti itu. Jadi siapa? Hanya Allah sahaja yang lebih mengetahui. WaLlahu a'lam
bissawab.

India-China Axis

The Bangkok Post
19 April 2005

INDIA-CHINA AXIS: Asian giants help reshape our world

China and India are emerging as future superpowers, both independently
and in unison in a few cases
By JOSEPH S. NYE

Is a new alignment between India and China rising to balance America's
global power? Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao just completed a four-day visit to India
during which 11 agreements were signed, including a comprehensive five-year strategic cooperation pact. In addition, Mr Wen announced that China would support India's bid for a permanent seat on an expanded UN Security Council, and opposed the inclusion of Japan, which the United States supports for a council seat.

With over a third of the world's population and two of the globe's highest economic growth rates, an alliance between China and India could be a serious factor in world politics. While both are developing countries - many of whose people remain impoverished - they also boast impressive capabilities in information age technologies both for
civilian and military purposes. As Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh put it during Mr Wen's visit, India and China can together reshape the world order.

The two countries' recent rapprochement marks a huge change from the hostility that bedevilled their relations following their 1962 war over a disputed border in the Himalayas. When I first visited India as an American government officer in the late 1970s, I was struck by my Indian hosts' fixation on gaining equal status with China. In 1998, when India tested its nuclear weapons, the defence minister referred to
China, and then Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee spoke of China as India's number one enemy.

By contrast, on more recent visits to India, I have found my hosts referring to the need to learn from China. Trade between the two giants has grown from $100 million (3.96 billion baht) in 1994 to nearly $14 billion (554.3 billion baht) last year, and India's minister of commerce and industry has predicted that it will double by this
decade's end. One agreement signed during Mr Wen's visit was a new set of guiding principles on how to settle boundary disputes between the two countries.

While improved relations and diminished prospects for conflict are welcome, relations between India and China are more complex than they appear at first. Not long before the visit of the Chinese premier, India hosted US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. Ever since President Bill Clinton's visit to India, but especially under President George W.
Bush, the US has moved from relative indifference to India to the development of a strong strategic relationship.

This new approach might have seemed threatened by al-Qaeda's attacks on America, which led to a strengthening of US relations with Pakistan's General Pervez Musharraf. But the US reassured India that they faced a common threat from transnational terrorism, and that the old Cold War pairings of India and Pakistan were outdated.

Ms Rice made this plain during her March visit, stressing the importance of a strategic relationship, including a willingness to consider trade in high technology, nuclear energy, and co-production of fighter aircraft such as F-16s and F-18s.

Shortly after Ms Rice's visit, the US announced that it would honour a long-standing promise to sell F-16s to Pakistan. While the announcement incited Indian protests, they were relatively muted compared to the past. One reason is that the state department also issued a statement that America would help India to become a major world power in the 21st century, involving both a strategic and economic dialogue.

Several factors underpin this new American attitude towards India. Rhetoric about ``the world's two largest democracies'' is not new, but it fits with the Bush administration's new emphasis on promoting democracy. The increasing role of the Indian diaspora in the US, particularly in the information industries, also had an influence, as has the rise in bilateral trade accompanying India's surging economic growth. Equally important are strategic concerns about transnational terrorism and the rise of Chinese power.

The rise of China is a major factor in the politics of the 21st century. China has tripled the size of its economy in the past two decades, and has been increasing its military strength. While both India and the US seek trade and good relations with China, both are aware and wary of China's growing strength.

Thus, both seek to hedge their bets, and what better way to do so than by improving their strategic relationship? Neither country aims to restrain China in the way the containment strategy aimed at an aggressive Soviet Union during the Cold War, but both want to create an international structure that does not tempt China to throw its weight around.

India has a 3,000km border with China, a 2,000km border with Pakistan (which has been the beneficiary of Chinese military and nuclear assistance), and growing concerns about the security of sea routes in the Indian Ocean over which oil and other trade move. As one Indian strategist put it to me during a recent visit: ``By 2030, we envisage the US, China and India as the three largest powers in world politics. We don't want a China- or a US-dominated world, but it we had to choose, it would be easier for us to live with the latter.''

So, while improvement in India-China relations is welcome, it is unlikely to herald the beginning of an India-China alliance against the US. Rather, it more likely represents another move in India's age-old tradition of managing regional balances of power.


Joseph S. Nye, a former US assistant secretary of defence and dean of
the Kennedy School at Harvard, is now a professor at Harvard and author
of ``The Power Game: A Washington Novel''. Copyright: Project
Syndicate. www.project-syndicate.org

© Copyright The Bangkok Post Publishing Public Co., Ltd. 2005

US Reaching Out to Muslim Brotherhood

US Reaching Out to Muslim Brotherhood: Report

"Make no mistake about it: we don't deal with the US embassy and any
[foreign] contacts should be done via the Foreign Ministry," said
Habib.

CAIRO, April 3, 2005 (IslamOnline.net) – The US State Department has
drawn up a memo calling for direct and permanent political dialogue
with the banned Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, a leading Arabic
newspaper reported on Sunday, April 3.

The US administration sees the Muslim Brotherhood as one of the most
powerful opposition movements in Egypt, unnamed Western diplomatic
sources in the Egyptian capital told Al-Sharq Al-Awsat.

The memo recommends inviting the group's representatives to the United
States for better communication and common grounds on Egypt's reform
policies and the pressing issues in the region, they added.

The State Department believes that Washington can contain the group
and its ilk through dialogue.

The memo, according to the Western diplomatic sources, maintains that
it is about time that the administration looked differently at
religious groups and avoided any further clash with them, because this
would only fan hatred and incite more attacks against US interests.

They added that the State Department has asked the US Embassy in Cairo
to reach out to the Muslim Brotherhood's leaders as a preliminary step
for an organized dialogue.

The memo recommends that after reaching common understandings with the
Muslim Brotherhood, Washington should pressure the Egyptian government
to let the group members speak out their minds freely and play a role
on the country's political landscape, according to the sources.

The Muslim Brotherhood, which has been banned since 1954, has 16
deputies in Egypt 's 454-member parliament, making it the main
opposition force in Egypt.

Alleged Bugaboo

The memo maintains that it would be a "historical mistake" to
marginalize the Muslim Brotherhood or treat the group as an enemy to
the US, said the sources.

It recognizes that the group enjoys a soaring popularity in Egypt
which necessitates regular meetings with its leaders.

The State Department cautions against listening to the warnings of the
Egyptian government which have not proved "serious" in all cases.

The memo asserts that the Egyptian government has been describing the
Muslim Brotherhood as a "bugaboo" to justify rigging election or
scaling down reforms.

"They (government) fear that free and fair election will bring about
opposition figures and undermine the privileges they have been
enjoying for years," the Western diplomatic sources told the
London-based daily.

Egyptian Minister of Justice Mahmoud Abu El-Leil said last week that
the Egyptian judiciary would supervise the multi-candidate
presidential election to be held in September.

President Hosni Mubarak has not indicated whether he would run for a
fifth term in office.

But a senior official from the ruling National Democratic Party (NDP)
told the official MENA news agency that Mubarak would announce his
decision after the result of a referendum in May on a proposed
amendment to the constitution allowing multi-candidate presidential
election.

Conditional Dialogue

Mohammad Habib, the first deputy of the Muslim Brotherhood
Guide-General, signaled conditional welcome to a dialogue with
Washington.

"It should take place under the supervision of the Egyptian Foreign
Ministry," he told the mass-circulation newspaper.

Habib denied that the group had been locked in talks with the US,
stressing that the Muslim Brotherhood rejected any reform recipe from
abroad.

"Egypt's reform agenda should come from within," he said emphatically.

The Muslim Brotherhood leader further denied knowledge of any contacts
between officials from the US embassy in Cairo and the group's
leaders.

"Make no mistake about it: we don't deal with the US embassy and any
[foreign] contacts should be done via the Foreign Ministry," Habib
said.

He reaffirmed his group's readiness for dialogue with all political
parties in Egypt, including the NDP, for the welfare of Egyptian
society.

Despite the arrest of at least 55 members, including leading figures,
several thousand members of the group took part in three
demonstrations in Cairo last Sunday to press for constitutional
reforms and the lifting of restrictive emergency laws.

Anwar Ibrahim Speech at US-Islamic World Forum, April 2005

Forging A New Symbiosis in Democratization

Anwar Ibrahim, Senior Associate, St Anthony's, Oxford University, and
Distinguished Senior Fellow, SAIS, Johns Hopkins University, at the
U.S.-Islamic World Forum, 10th-12th April, 2005, Sheraton Hotel, Doha,
Qatar.

Some forty five years ago when I was still attending junior high
school, someone read to me Churchill's "This was their finest hour"
speech. Of course he didn't sound like Churchill but who cares? My
mother tongue is Malay and till today I can never speak like an
Englishman. But what really mattered was that that short speech was so
powerful in its appeal to my adolescent idealism that it inspired me
to want to know more of other cultures and histories.

As I relate this, I am aware that mine is not really an exceptional
case. Like many other Muslims of my time, I grew up in an environment
steeped in tradition and religious rituals. At the same time, I was
often exposed to other faiths and cultures including Western
civilization and values. In the process, it was only natural that
apart from the Quran and the Ahadith, I was also familiar with the
works of Dante, Shakespeare, and T.S Eliot (which, by the way, had
kept me company during my six years of solitary confinement). At High
school, it was not considered unusual for Muslim students to be able
to quote from memory, verses from Shakespeare, or the speeches of
Churchill or Abraham Lincoln. While we were familiar with the Arabic
songs of Ummi Kalthoum and Fairuz and the music of Abdul Wahhab we
were also very much at home with the ballads of Bing Crosby and the
rock and roll numbers of Elvis Presley. There were some constraints of
course. Those pelvic gyrations of Elvis were strictly prohibited in
school concerts. We were only allowed to vocalize, not to tantalize!
This was not a Muslim reaction. It was universal. I believe that in
America as well, similar strictures were in force against Elvis. Well,
the point of all this is that growing up in a traditional Malay Muslim
family in a predominantly Muslim country back in the sixties did not
mean that the door to Western culture, art or learning was slammed
shut in our faces.

The winds of change from autocracy to democracy have been blowing
across various parts of the Muslim world for some time now. The Iraq
war, though still mired in controversy, has yielded the country's
first democratic elections. In this regard, I must say that though I
remain opposed to the war in principle, I must concede that the voices
of freedom in Iraq are now finding expression after decades of
oppression and being forced into silence. I dare say that given half a
chance, Muslim societies not just in Iraq but throughout the world,
will seize the opportunity to enjoy democracy.

Conditions for democracy

But a major concern in our deliberations is whether the mere
phenomenon of elections means that democracy is being practiced the
way it is being preached, or are there still certain fundamental
issues to be resolved. I think it is obvious that among the first will
be that elections must be free, fair and transparent. Free as in free
from interference from all extraneous factors in the determination of
the electoral outcome. Candidates to be elected must be the choice of
their own electorate. And as to fair elections, by some basic
reckoning the starting point would be the so called "level playing
field". And this would include equal access to a free media, open
debates and a conduct of elections that can stand up to international
scrutiny.

Institutions of civil society

It is not enough just to have civil liberties guaranteed in a document
which represents the seal of the people's will. The other basic
institutions of civil society must be in place. If not in place at the
time of the elections, then they must be as soon as possible put in
place once the democratic process gets started.

There must be an independent judiciary that will function as an
effective check and balance against the powers of the executive and
the legislative branches of government. Essentially, the judiciary
must be the bulwark of fundamental liberties. Complementing this, the
position of the state prosecutor should be protected by the
constitutional guarantees as to security of tenure and also be made
accountable to a nonpartisan parliamentary committee.

Need for vibrant opposition

The argument that encouraging democracy in the Muslim world would only
create instability is therefore clearly untenable. Already,
significant progress has been made in the area of civil liberties in
Qatar's new constitution. And undoubtedly, the Doha Declaration for
Democracy and Reform resonates well for the prospects of political
reform in the region. But I believe that a vibrant democracy needs a
vibrant opposition. The "Pandora's box" syndrome that is being raised
runs counter to the fostering of true democracy. Civil liberties
entrenched in the constitution become pious platitudes when the voices
of dissent are not allowed to be heard.

Soul searching

This forum could not have come at a more opportune time and I pray it
will pave the way for more concrete and direct ways of engagement.
None of us from the Muslim world can honestly say that America has not
left a lasting imprint on us. Conversely, America will be equally
dishonest if it fails to acknowledge the vast impact made by the
Muslim world.

It is true though that recent events have widened the chasm. All the
more reason then to heed the call for dialogue and active engagement.
Why can't we give more due to the ties that bind us rather than those
which separate us. Why then should we lend our ears to those who
continue to beat the drums of discord? But Muslims are prone to pride
themselves as being the followers of a religion where the principles
of justice, equality, fair dealing and tolerance are paramount. Yet,
between the idea and the reality falls the shadow. The reality is that
the contradictions are shockingly glaring: For isn't it true that
Muslim leaders are among the greatest perpetrators of injustice? Can
we, in all honesty, deny that Muslim regimes are in fact among the
most blatant violators of human rights, and that their leaders have
the dubious distinction of being the most corrupt and having the most
tenacious grip on power? And when confronted with these issues, these
self-same leaders are not averse to citing chapter and verse to
justify why changes can only be brought about gradually, that Muslim
societies can only take democracy in small doses, and that freedom
will bring about anarchy. And with the war on terror, it is indeed
ironic and even tragic for the cause of democracy, that these regimes
are allowed to persist in their errant ways with impunity.

Allow me to elaborate. It is said that the underlying causes for the
current progress of political reform in the Muslim world are to be
found in the aggressive foreign policy initiatives embarked upon by
the Bush Administration. This is the policy that was launched
following the tragic events of 9-11, a policy marked by a so-called
"forward strategy of freedom". To my mind, while it cannot be denied
that the pro-reform initiatives under this policy have indeed
contributed positively to current developments, yet sometimes the
rhetoric may be more convincing than the reality.

For certain countries, this policy is marked by what I would
characterize as "a strategy of selective ambivalence". In reality, it
means constructively aiding certain countries to resist the tide of
reform by a process of omission rather than commission. Prompted no
doubt by the dictates of expediency, this policy has meant turning a
blind eye to blatant human rights violations and other kinds of abuses
which clearly fly in the face of this forward strategy of freedom. In
return for the support to the United States in the war against terror,
these countries are conferred the status of strategic partners. To my
mind, this is a case of conditionality working backwards. It is a case
of allowing repressive regimes to don the cloak of legitimacy simply
because they raise the specter of terror.

Indonesia, the largest Muslim nation in the world, stands out as the
single most significant political development in the recent history of
democracy. When the East Asian financial crisis broke out, Indonesia
underwent major socio-political upheaval but emerged from the storm a
new nation. In place of oppression and dictatorship, she is now
secured by freedom and democracy. Indeed, Indonesia can serve as a
model of democracy for the world. The press there is absolutely free
and the fairness in the conduct of elections is unsurpassed. The
phenomenal changes brought about through Reformasi should provide an
enduring lesson on peaceful transition from autocracy to democracy.

But if we go beyond the rhetoric, it would not be an exaggeration to
say that for the last two centuries, the Islamic world has been
dazzled by the wealth, power and technological prowess of the West.
Under the bondage of colonialism, the Muslim nations developed a
deep-rooted sense of self-resentment and inferiority and the natural
upshot was an almost total erosion of confidence in their own
traditions.

Confronted with centuries of traditional thinking and submissiveness
to the past, Adonis, arguably the foremost contemporary Arab poet,
denies his roots in the following verses:

My Gospel is rejection,
And my map
A land without a creator

In literature and the arts, Arab writers could not resist the allure
of European existential influence. From Baudelaire, Proust, Joyce and
Kafka to T.S. Eliot, Ezra Pound, Brecht and Beckett, the theme of the
predicament of modern man's loneliness and sense of futility and the
inequities of political oppression fitted in perfectly with the angst
of the Arab writers. Combine this with the effects of the politics of
dispossession, we get the overpowering emotional outburst of the
Palestinian poet, Tawfiq Sayigh:

I drag myself from place to place,
Destitute except for
Daylong remembrances of a home
That was mine yesterday;
Only yesterday.

The point is that it is just as reckless for the Muslim world to
generalize that Americans are the best example of a morally depraved
nation as it is for America to lable the Muslim world as a
civilization full of menacing fundamentalists. We must unequivocally
reject this kind of stereotyping. We must also learn to break free
from the anxiety of historical influence and not succumb to the allure
of bigoted and racist chantings wherever they may issue from, in
whatever shape or form.

To Muslims this will not be just a matter of choice. I believe this
search for greater understanding in a diverse world is a Quranic
imperative:

Oh mankind! Verily we have created you all from a male and a female,
and have made you into nations and tribes that you may come to know
one another.

The challenge before us is indeed enormous. For the Muslim world,
together with authoritarianism, extremism and terrorism are the
greatest impediments to the formation of civil society. The war in
Iraq rages on with increasing ferocity. Suicide bombers continue to
blow themselves up murdering innocent people. Just three weeks ago,
this nation was the victim of such an outrage.

As for America, to many in the Muslim and Arab worlds it still carries
the tag of arrogant power and Metternichian machinations. To merely
dismiss this as a manifestation of hatred of modernity or envy of
technological progress is to miss the point entirely. That there
should be a war against terror is not in dispute. But this military
war must be subsumed under a war of ideas. To my mind, the issues of
modernity and democracy; and fundamentalism and autocracy will loom
large across the battle horizon.

Even as America has not understood Islam, Muslims have also failed to
grasp the spirit of America. Where are the Muslim Tocquevilles?
America has countless centres for Christian and Muslim understanding.
Can we say the same about Muslim countries? Why is the Muslim world so
reluctant to reach out and learn more about the Christian and the
Jewish faiths?

I believe that active engagement through sustained dialogue will not
only help us erase our mutual prejudices borne of ignorance but will
also help us to discover this universal dignity and common humanity
hidden by deep seated fear and distrust. Failure to pursue active
engagement only serves to fortify the prophecies of soothsayers of
impending doom. It is also a wanton dereliction of moral
responsibility to our future generations.

We have much to do together. That we are all gathered here is indeed a
good sign that a new chapter has begun. But we shall need to work
harder to understand each other, and to give the past a decent burial.
Only upon that can we confidently forge ahead with concrete strategic
action plans and translate ideals into reality. Let us take the road
not taken. It may not be tomorrow that we shall relish the fruits of
our labour. But if we do not cast aside our fear of uncertainty and
walk through the storm together, there may not even be a tomorrow to
wake up for. This is our collective responsibility.

In the words of Robert Penn Warren, "We shall come back, no doubt, to
walk down the Row;But that will be a long time from now, and
soon now we shall go out of the house and go into the convulsion of
the world, out of history into history and the awful responsibility
of Time."

Thank you.

Guilty Until Proven Innocent

EDITORIAL: Guilty Until Proven Innocent
Published: April 12, 2005

The post-9/11 world involves two competing nightmares. One imagines
another terrorist attack that occurs because authorities fail to
respond to signs of danger. The other is about innocent people who are
arrested by mistake and held indefinitely because authorities are too
frightened, or embarrassed, to admit their errors. We have to be
equally vigilant against both.

Right now, two New York City girls, both 16, have been detained and
accused of plotting to become suicide bombers. If there is a real
reason to believe that charge, officials are obviously right to have
acted. But so far, they have said little about the evidence against the
girls, and the girls' friends and families have offered accounts that
suggest the charges could be completely false.

At this point, it's impossible not to worry about a potential
miscarriage of justice, given the number of previous incidents in which
the government has rushed to make a terrorism arrest that turned out to
be baseless.

Details of the cases against the two girls - one from Bangladesh and
the other from Guinea, and both in the country illegally - are sketchy.
According to reporting by Nina Bernstein in The Times, the parents of
the Bangladeshi girl went to the police several weeks ago to file a
complaint about their daughter's defying their authority. When the
dispute was resolved, they tried to withdraw the complaint, but the
police proceeded with an investigation.

The police and federal immigration officials searched her belongings
and are reported to have found an essay on suicide. According to the
family, the essay says suicide is against Islamic law. But detectives
went on to question the girl about her political beliefs before
arresting her. Even less is known about the investigation of the girl
from Guinea. Teachers and students at the high school she attended
expressed outrage at the arrest and at the idea that she could be
plotting terrorism.

The government calls the girls an "imminent threat," and says it has
"evidence that they plan to be suicide bombers." But it has not
described the evidence, insisting that national security requires that
much of it remain secret. Because the girls are here illegally, they
have been put into a deportation system that affords them far fewer
rights than ordinary criminal suspects have. There is no definite limit
on how long they can be held.

No one wants to leap to conclusions about a government case in such an
important area. But the record is not reassuring. Last year, the
government wrongly jailed Brandon Mayfield, a lawyer who is a Muslim,
for two weeks after the F.B.I. mistakenly matched his fingerprint to
one found at the scene of the Madrid train bombing. After the Sept. 11
attacks, the Justice Department rounded up hundreds of Muslim men who
were here illegally and detained them for months, often in deplorable
conditions. The department's inspector general later found that the
F.B.I. had made "little attempt to distinguish" those with terrorism
ties from those without. Shortly after 9/11, federal authorities
detained a Nepalese tourist for three months in a tiny cell after he
inadvertently included an F.B.I. building in a videotape of the sights
of New York for folks at home.

More information about the two girls will no doubt surface over time.
If the evidence isn't there, the arrests are very disturbing. The
government will have taken 16-year-olds from their families, branded
them as would-be terrorists and put them into a frightening legal limbo
for no good reason.

Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company

Bahrain Bloggers

Bahraini bloggers fall foul of government

Jane Kinninmont in Manama
Wednesday May 25, 2005
The Guardian

Three Bahraini bloggers are facing criminal charges, including
defaming the king, for running a web forum that allows free political
debate.

Ali Abdulemam, who founded Bahrain's first website,
BahrainOnline.org, in 1999, was arrested along with the site's two
other moderators.

Although the state telecoms' monopoly has been trying to block it
since 2002, Bahrain Online is the country's most popular website. It
has has 26,000 registered users.

The Gulf state's technologically literate youth have become adept at
accessing the site (which is hosted in the US) through proxy addresses.

Many of Bahrain Online's contributors attack what they see as
government repression, corruption and religious discrimination.
The three were arrested ear lier this year, and detained on five
charges including "inciting hatred against the government".
They were later released, but still face charges.

Bahrain is witnessing unprecedented calls for more democracy. But the
authorities want more control over new media.

This month, the government said bloggers had to register with the
ministry of information - and has even proposed a bill to regulate
the use of Bluetooth technology on mobile phones.

The lawyer for the three accused said the charges against them were
based on articles they did not write, something a government source
also confirmed.

Mr Abdulemam said: "I hadn't even seen the postings they [the
authorities] showed me but I could face up to 10 years in prison just
for publishing a website."

Source: Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005 (London)

[Malaysia] Ministerial Insensitivity

Senior Minister contemptuous of Muslim sensitivity
by Puan Elya Lim Abdullah
Founding Member Muslim Professionals Forum

The Muslim Professionals Forum (MPF) regrets Datuk Seri Dr. Lim Keng Yaik's recommendation [May 2005] that religious matters be kept out of national schools if this means abolishing religious instruction to Muslim students.

The assertion that the teaching of Islam in national schools deters non-Muslims from enrolling their children into national schools may have its substance, however we think much of that has to do with ingrained prejudice and problems inherent within the national schools system.

Some degree of religious instruction has always been an element of our educational system, whether they are schools established by Christian missions or national ones. It fulfils the holistic educational needs of our children as we parents perceive them. Children of other faiths receive instruction in moral education when Muslim students have their religious classes. The recent initiative to introduce the teaching of Mandarin and Tamil in national schools is indicative of the Ministry's concern for further improving national integration.

While it is true that the family plays an important role in imparting religious values to impressionable children, instruction in the basic fundamentals of Islam, rituals of worship, study of the sacred texts, religious morality and Islamic history has to be done by qualified teachers.

The national schools have admirably fulfilled this need without altering their character into religious schools. Muslim parents accept this compromise and send their children for extra religious lessons outside the normal school hours. It is utterly insensitive to demand that religious instruction for Muslims be scrapped from national schools if that is the intent of Dr. Lim's recommendations.

By virtue of demography and history, Islam has been very much part of the nation's social and cultural fabric. Our colourful history bears testimony to the religious tolerance, harmony and mutual respect which has stood the test of time and which Malaysians have continued to guard jealously.

It is somewhat baffling that Islam is suddenly demonized as an obstacle to national integration. The call to keep religion out of the national schools is contemptuous of Muslim sensitvity and flies in the face of our tradition of respect and understanding among the religions.

it is an idea unmistakably borrowed from a particular brand of secularism that has its roots in a conflict between religion and the state which has a very specific historical context. It is by no means the universal experience of all modern states, least of all Malaysia.

Instead of purportedly promoting national integration, such brazen insensitivity is potentially disruptive of our hardwon religious harmony. That such a proposal had come from a senior member of the cabinet is all the more regrettable.

There are probably more valid reasons why non-Malay parents are reluctant to send their children to national schools especially those outside the affluent middle-class areas. And this has more to do with the school's academic performance, class size, facilities, quality of the teaching faculty, morale of teachers and standards of discipline rather than religious studies.

These are equally the concerns of many Muslim parents, some of whom are willing to pay for private education or send their children to Chinese schools. While we urge that the government take immediate measures to remedy these pressing problems, various aspects of religious instruction for Muslims need to be tailored to mould young Muslims with Islamic spirituality (iman), examplary behaviour (soleh wa musleh) and intellectual strength (ilm) to prepare them as citizens of a modern, pluralistic Malaysia.

Selamat Datang!

Weblog MERDEKA diwujudkan untuk mengetengahkan pandangan, penjelasan dan pemikiran mengenai aspek-aspek penting dalam kehidupan sama ada dari sudut peribadi, keagamaan, kemasyarakatan, kenegaraan dan keantarabangsaan. Ia dilandaskan kepada prinsip dialog secara beradab. Pandangan tuan-tuan dan puan-puan yang budiman adalah dialu-alukan. Yang pasti, kita tetapkan hati untuk mencari kebenaran dan dengan kebenaran itu kita bina keadilan. Semoga semuanya mendapat manfaat dari weblog ini. Terima kasih.